Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Different model routers and dovetails

Posts

Different model routers and dovetails

#1

Different model routers and dovetails

Ed

I had two Porter Cable 690LR routers and when I used them to make dovetails I put a bit in each one and used them on a Porter Cable 4212 dovetail jig. I'd set the built-in depth guide and use it for both the pins and tails. One of them broke and I replaced it with a different model, the Porter Cable 893 PK.

Now when I try to make dovetails they're way too loose. This makes no sense to me at all. The bits extend the same distance below the bottom of the routers. I spend a lot of time trying to get the routers to match up and make a good joint.

Does this make sense to anyone?

Merry Christmas,

Perplexed in Puyallup

Re: Different model routers and dovetails

#2

Re: Different model routers and dovetails

Dave Paine

I am not familiar with these particular routers, but some weeks ago I was doing searches about hand held routers. One of the links was Pat Warner's excellant router site. Pat had an article about the bases he sells for certain routers, one was the Bosch I was considering.

Pat stated that many bases can have the centered hole not exactly centered. If this were the case with the new router, and the hole is used to center a template, I think this could result in the loose fit.

I would measure the dovetail part being created from the remaining original router, then use the new router to make a test piece for the same either pin or tail. If the test piece measures different then you may have a slightly offset base.

I have recently been considering a dovetail jig and like the Keller model. One feature I like is that Keller uses a bearing on their dovetail bit which would eliminate any issues from a slightly off center base template hole.

Re: Different model routers and dovetails

#3

Re: Different model routers and dovetails

del schisler

the newer router must go a little deaper in the wood. That would make the pin's loose. I bet if you can make a small spacer some how and keep the newer router from going all the way in with the pin bit?? That is if the 690 does the dovetales and the newest router does the pin's. the same depth of cut doesn't make them loose or tight. On the pins deeper in or less in make them tight.

Re: Different model routers and dovetails

#4

I Use Two P+C 690's And The P+C 4212 Jg

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Ed,

It is perplexing. I'd bet a few bucks that the difference in depth you now experience has little to do with the 890 base you now use. I agree that a shim is a good quick fix. Keeping your router permanently set up for the dovetails, once you get the perfect depth, may be another solution.

I'd check on your use of the correct depth guage on the jig itself. There are more than one built in guage, as I recall, to accommodate the different jig templates/functions ( dovetail, pin depth, and box joint depth) and each is adjustable despite being factory set.

I would also be sure to use the rub collar/ bushings supplied with the 4212 jig. Lastly, I'd clean the collets to insure a firm setting for the bits. A slight slip in depth of the dovetail bit during operation could have caused the problem.

I've used the same hardware for several years without a problem. Good luck.

George

Re: Different model routers and dovetails

#5

Re: Different model routers and dovetails

FredD

Your on the right track with a Keller jig.

FredD

Re: Different model routers and dovetails

#6

Re: Different model routers and dovetails

Jesse Cloud

The bit may not be centered in the rub collar. If you have a centering cone, you can loosen the screws on the base, place in cone in the collect and lower the depth until the cone contacts the rub collar and you can gently move the base to get it centered. While its centered, tighten those screws.

Good luck, let us know how this gets solved!

Re: Different model routers and dovetails

#7

Bit depth setting is the likely culprit

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

I use the 690 for dovetails on a Hartville jig which is almost a dead copy of the PC style jig. Your bit depth is what controls how tight or loose the pieces fit. A very small depth of cut difference can result in a noticeable difference in fit.

I've also experienced the effect of having the bit not exactly centered in the guide bushing. This has nothing to do with the resulting tightness of the fit. But it will drive you crazy since the result is a slightly offset front and side piece when assembled. Make absolutely sure the bit is centered in the bushing and the tail and pin pieces will align perfectly.

At least this has been my experience.

Re: Different model routers and dovetails

#8

Re: Different model routers and dovetails

charlie belden

I never understood the value of "Bit Depth Jigs". For through dovetails, depth of cut of the bits is determined by the thickness of the stock you're dovetailing. If you're working with Store Bought boards - though they'e sold as nominally half inch or three quarter inch thick - if you put a micrometer to them you'll find variations - in the same batch of boards. Like nominal 2x4s, thickness is getting kind of loosey goosey. Unless you milled all your parts - and cut the dovetails within a day or so of milling the stock, gauges for setting the router bits' depth of cut will get you close - but often not close enough.

Is the looseness uniform for ALL the pin/tails joints, or does it get progressively sloppier from first to last?

Are you "bottoming out" the bit in the router collet? If so, you may be getting a jack hammer effect - bouncing the bit up out of the collet a little. This jack hammering effect will result in individual pairs of pin/tail to get progressively looser with progressive cuts.

Another source of looseness has to do with tilting the router as you cut. Supporting the router on the dovetail fingers just doesn't make for good stability - which is why I went with the AKEDA DT JIG. The router doesn't rest on the guides at all - it's supported back AND front by the pretty beefy frame of the unit.

You didn't mention how WIDE your stock is that you're having problems with. DT Jigs now go out to 24". That's a long span if the router is supported by the guide fingers - and maybe a front support bar. Is the new router heavier than the other one you're using. Sag may be a source of problems for wide parts.

Bottom line for all the DT jigs I'm aware of is - despite the ads that say No Test Cuts Required - test cuts are the only way I know of to assure that the DTs I route in the real parts - will fit right.

More info please.

Re: Different model routers and dovetails

#9

Re: Different model routers and dovetails

Ed

Some answers to questions:

* I'm using wood that I milled myself.

* They're not more than 6" wide.

* The error is extreemly consistent.

* There's also a very consistent error in the alignment.

I think my problem is that they have different bases. Thanks everyone.