Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

On the subject of beech

Posts

On the subject of beech

#1

Clint Searl

On the subject of beech

Clint Searl

The recent discussion on the virtues (or not) of beech as a furniture wood did not reflect much direct experience. I used it about fifteen years ago in the bases of the pair of night stands pictured below. I found it to be dense and uniform in structure and easy to work, though it feels "brittle." The lumber was flat when I got it and wasn't inclined to warp or twist.


The drawer faces on the lower unit are faced with spalted beech, which have more presence than the spalted maple on the upper drawers.

Clint


Re: On the subject of beech

#2

Re: On the subject of beech

allen in two rivers, wi

I agree. There was a comment (or two) on the stability of beech. About two years ago, I made a large armoire (sp?) for my daughter. It is 7 1/2 feet tall, 4 feet wide and 3 feet deep.Its construction is of rail and stile, with all raised panels. I also constructed a 7-drawered chest of drawers (matching) for her birthday. The beech has not moved or cracked at all. There is no warping or twisting that I can find. I think this is more the result of good quality sawing and drying at the mill that I purchase most of my wood from. I think beech is one of the "prettier" woods to work with.

allen

Re: On the subject of beech

#3

Re: On the subject of beech

FredD

As much of Beech as there is , one would think it would be a staple in lumber yards.

It is one of the "big three" in the Forrest , gradually taking over the place of rapidly declining Maple stocks and Yellow Birch..

FredD

Re: On the subject of beech

#4

Very nice work!

John in NM

Good to hear of first hand experiences too, thanks!

Re: On the subject of beech

#5

Some more first hand experience

Bill Tindall

I am no longer on vacation and hence have access to a computer with a real keyboard, and I can see what I am typing, so I can elaborate more on beech.

It is a fact that there is essentially no market for beech. The species is never quoted in the Hardwood Market Reporter for KD wood. There are quotes for green lumber, where a 1C grade is essentially the same price as FAS ( for an in-demand furniture wood the differential would be 2X or more). All these data point to the fact it is not used in furniture in the US. What commercial use it has is for small items like paint brush handles and rail ties. I rarely see it on a log yard which is leading to the fact Fred pointed out. It doesn't get cut, so over time its fraction of what is left is increasing. It tolerates heavy shade, so it lays in waiting for the valuable trees to be cut and then it flourishes, shading out everything under it dense canopy, particularly maple and especially birch which requires bare soil to seed. I regard it as a forest weed and kill it(which is near impossible) when improving a timber plot. I have cut hundreds of these weeds in the past year. So, given that it is plentiful and becoming more so, why is it eschewed by the market (Fact, if you aren't buying truck loads you aren't the "market" and hence you don't determine what gets logged and sawed in "market" quantity).

1. The difference between radial and tangential shrinkage in beech is more than 2X, and less than 0.5X for typical furniture hardwoods. While you may be able to accommodate the relatively large absolute and relative dimensional response to humidity changes in the design of your furniture, or humidity control in modern homes, it is a bitch to dry and keep flat and a challenge to a factory shipping furniture to Alabama and Arizona. The European mills mitigate this problem by steaming the wood which lessens the drying issue. In much of Europe beech is all they got so they are motivated to deal with it. With most of the world's hardwood lumber resources here in the Eastern US, we have choices, much better choices.

2. US beech does not make good logs. I helped log a boundary of timber in the 70's that had, for here, seemingly outstanding beech trees. They were large, tall and well limbed out. Never-the-less, they sawed out very little high grade lumber. Larger trees are often hollow, the limbs survive in the shade so the trees don't limb out till late in life and even "clear" lumber is often gnarly.

3. Beech is plain as dirt and there is little demand for plain as dirt furniture in this country's furniture and cabinetry buyers. As nice as ash is there is little demand for it either (in the '60's and 70's when light furniture was fashionable, it was the same price as cherry). Occasionally maple has a run as a light colored wood but mostly it is out of fashion too.

There may be yet other reasons for the lack of a US beech market.

Re: On the subject of beech

#6

PS

Bill Tindall

I talked to a German beech supplier at IWF. He said for the most part the logs were plantation grown, which means they are groomed to get the best possible logs, which mitigates the crummy log issue with American Beech. I do not know if European beech is inherently better than US beech, but plantation grown and steamed certainly vastly improves the product. It still looks plain as dirt so even the European beech isn't making much of a dent in traditional hardwoods.

Re: On the subject of beech

#7

Just for you Bill....

John in NM

I'm going to make something out of beech, and then paint it with milk paint!:D:D:D ;)

Re: On the subject of beech

#8

my least favorite wood AND finish!

Bill Tindall

Would that be the equivalent of some sort of woodworking Voodoo doll? Don't hex my bow front. I am having enough trouble with the drawers.

If you all get together and order a truck load of beech I can have it to you for 1/5 the cost of cherry and you will make a land owner(me), a logger and saw mill delighted to get the order.

Re: On the subject of beech

#9

Re: On the subject of beech

FredD

That's some good looking stuff Clint and you not alone by any means in thinking it looks and works nice.

I never paid much attention to it ,except in the case of interior doors and a large Architectural Milling operation in Santa Rosa that stocked the Bay Area in Ca. with trim.

On looking up the literature on the wood , one will find it has many uses , is actually in demand by Furniture Factories and so on.

This is one of many sites I looked at and no where were there any denigrating remarks about Beech or it's uses.

http://www.doityourself.com/stry/the-benefits-of-beech-wood-furniture

FredD

Re: On the subject of beech

#10

Re: Some more first hand experience

John in NM

I think the real reason lies in #2, if I were a logger I would tend to shy away from hollow trees too.

As to #3, well, lots of woods are very plain, that doesn't wash.

Something's fishy in #1, numbers I've seen are roughly 5% radial and 10% tangential, not stellar by any means, but not completely unworkable. Looking at the ratios you've cited, I wonder if they are inverted. Looking at a table here in WC's archives, most furniture woods are slightly less, say 3-4% radial and 7-8% tangential. In some cases I've seen numbers for sugar maple that are as high as those for beech. Maple is gorgeous stuff for the most part, I suspect if there were a similar reason to work with beech (there very well may not be) then the stability problem could be overcome.

No reason to like the wood if you don't want to. I have this annoying habit of questioning conventional wisdom when it doesn't seem to add up. I've no doubt I would hate the stuff if it were sold as a cheap frame grade material and then some designer started spec'ing it for custom doors and cabinets.

If the Germans can make usable lumber out of it, well good for them. Its been used for cheap rifle stocks in Europe for decades, the two surplus ones I have held their zero having spent decades in Europe and then getting moved to arid New Mexico. Clearly skillful work can overcome material limitations.