Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

OT Motion Sensing light switches

Posts

OT Motion Sensing light switches

#1

OT Motion Sensing light switches

Dustmaker Mike

howdy all. I have looked at the BORGs and on line at Ebay and Amazon as well as shopzilla. I am looking to get about 5 or 6 motion sensing light switches for the kids room bathroom etc. The problem I am having is the cost of ~$14.00 a piece. Is there a place I can get them a little cheaper? Thanks

Re: OT Motion Sensing light switches

#2

Re: OT Motion Sensing light switches

Dave Paine

Mike, sorry I cannot offer locations of a cheaper alternative, but I can offer an experience of the other day.

I had one of these units in a downstairs bathroom with two lamps.

One of the lamps appeared to be blown so I started to remove. As I removed I saw a flash and the switch blew, as well as the other bulb.

I replaced with a standard rocker switch.

Prime reason was so that I can later replace the bulbs with compact fluorecscent. These motion detector switches do not work with many CFL bulbs. There are CFL's which are now designed for this use, but I do not have any.

Re: OT Motion Sensing light switches

#3

Re: OT Motion Sensing light switches

John McGaw

As Dave wrote, using these switches with CFLs is quite problematic. Most of the sensing switches are single-pole devices and depend on leakage current through the switch having someplace to go (through a standard lamp filament) to make their circuitry operate. Most CFLs don't conduct this leakage current and leave the switch inoperative.

There are PIR switches which are made to work with CFLs but if $14 bothers you then these will give you a heart attack. Besides, I'm pretty sure that these switches aren't universal drop-in units and may require a neutral wire to assure that they get power.

http://www.energycircle.com/shop/hubbell-motion-sensing-wall-switch.html

Re: OT Motion Sensing light switches

#4

Wow Great Info

Dustmaker Mike

Now I will look for the PIR switches. It is not so much the cost that is stopping me the ~$14.00 seems about the going rate either on-line or in the stores I was just checking to see if there was a better source.

Thanks Again Merry Christmas

Re: OT Motion Sensing light switches

#5

Re: OT Motion Sensing light switches

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot ID

Hi Mike!

There was a time when I needed to buy lots of electrical parts and pieces for the wiring of my cabin and my shop. I actually had luck getting good, name brand stuff off of Ebay at a decent price. If you're buying one at a time then it is prohibitive for the shipping, but in bulk it got to be pretty reasonable. You have to know what you want, and look just for that. Good Luck!

Scott.