Machinist vice needed
Thomas Norton
So what kind/brand? Is Harbor Freight worth considering?
What I want to do is mount it to a board in order to clamp it to my bench when needed.
Thanks
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Machinist vice needed
Thomas Norton
So what kind/brand? Is Harbor Freight worth considering?
What I want to do is mount it to a board in order to clamp it to my bench when needed.
Thanks
Re: Machinist vice needed
George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA
Good Afternoon Tom,
They are handy gadgets to use around the shop. I've been considering getting another Harbor Freight cross slide vise for use on my drill press. I've had one modified for use beneath my Shop Fox Mortiser, and it works great, clamping stock in place and then advancing it thru the required plunge operations. I've read accounts here written by people with vastly more knowledge than I have, and there have been some reservations laid against the HF variety. However, you couldn't prove it by me. Mine works fine. There are a couple sizes available.
George
Re: Machinist vice needed *LINK*
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
Myself, I wouldn't buy any lower grade vise than Sears (Craftsman, at that).
Look for a vise with a closed slide, like the one linked below (this isn't a specific recommendation, just an example). The other common design, which will likely be cheaper, has a solid slide with a screw above it. With a closed slide, you won't get chips and junk in the screw threads, won't mark your work with the screw threads, and you have somewhere to rest work while you're tightening it up (this also provides some resistance to downward force, which helps hold it in place).
At the other end, you can spend $300 and up, used, and prices I won't even mention, new for some of the fine old names like Wilton and Parker - but the vise you get for that comes with a certificate for free hernia repair to go with its 100 lbs and up weight, so not such a good tool for putting on and off the bench.
An example
Re: Machinist vice needed
Barry Irby
I have a small one I can mount on the table to my drill press. Not a cross slide, just a vice, I think it a HF and it was cheap, but very useful. It will tilt. I would not hesitate to buy it again. I would consider a cross slide HF vice as well, even though I seldom buy anything there.
Re: Machinist vice needed
Clint Searl
When I need mine, I just lag it to the bench....same place every time. But then, my bench might not be considered "fine furniture."
Clint
Depends on use...
John in NM
If you're going to use it to really smash stuff, I don't think a HF would hold up for long. But it really depends on vise design as well as tolerances in manufacture. If there's a used tool store around, look there first, you might find something really good for $50 or so.
Also, if you don't mind the tool wearing and being replaced, HF has a lot of stuff worth using. Drives me nuts when things don't work the same every time though, and I consider fighting with tools to be a waste of time, so I rarely buy much at HF.
In all fairness though, I've poured something over 100 tons of concrete with one of their crummy $189 mixers, so I'm not going to be a total snob about it 
Re: Machinist vice needed
Phil Joines
What ever you get don't use the saddle as an anvil. It's not strong enough unless you get a really large one.
Re: Machinist vice needed
craigd
I've had a Wilton machinists' bench vise (3�" jaws) for twenty years or so and it is awesome, still like new and it gets abused (I've moved the bench it is mounted around the shop bending stuff with a cheater bar). Still make in the USA and priced like it.
http://www.wiltontools.com/us/manufacturing/en/wilton/product.html?node=4546&product=273855
Re: Machinist vice needed
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
I have one of those, too, and really like it. I will confess I occasionally miss the flat top surface to rest things on.
But I can't complain too much about it for the $3 I paid for it at a garage sale.
I have dreams of someday having a shop big enough to have a dedicated metal bench where I can mount the Prentiss that my dad had on his garage floor for years. 100 pounds or so of mighty cast iron.
Re: Machinist vice needed
Barry
HB and the like only if you can't afford better quality. If vise jaws are machined well enough to hold, they aren't worth much. Also, the lower quality vise manufacturers have been known to use a little Bondo to smooth up castings before painting. Craftsman makes some decent quality machinist vises. I've had one in my shop for over 30 years with no problems. I think I paid about $59, probably $89 now.
Re: Machinist vice needed
Marv
I have one exactly like yours. I've had mine for about 30 years too. Still just as tight as it was new. Paid about $235 for it way back then.
Sometimes you can find a good deal on eBay, but everyone seems to know the quality of these vises. Good bargains are scarce.
Marv