Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Need to match some beech...

Posts

Need to match some beech...

#1

Need to match some beech...

John in NM

Problem 1, beech seems to be pretty hard to find... odd for such a common tree...

Found a vendor on ebay though, just need some small pieces, so those guys sell bowl blanks save the day. But that brings us to problem 2. Stuff I need to match is likely European, likely steamed, and has that nice uniform pinkish tan color. Blanks I'm looking at are awfully pale....

So just what is the deal with beech? Anyone used our domestic species for much? Does it come out looking just like the European stuff? I've seen European beech for sale here and there around the web, but usually it's a plank when I need a chunk :D

Re: Need to match some beech...

#2

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Need to match some beech...

Jesper, Denmark

To the best of my knowledge, the only commercially harvested beech in the USA is a stand in Northern new Hampshire around Mt. Washington.

It is not the European beech, which is the prime native species in Denmark as well as in the northern parts of Germany, Poland and some other North Eastern countries.

You could say that the European beech is kinda boring wood, with just small flecks and no colour variations.

If you need to match something, soft maple might be close, but not have the typical small flecks as the beech.

Re: Need to match some beech...

#3

Re: Need to match some beech...

Philip Duffy

Another option, one commonly used in the Navy's modeling shop, is pearwood. It is colored, marked, etc with all kinds of different stains/dyes, etc to match the wood used in all the old ships. How much pear would you need? Philip

Re: Need to match some beech...

#4

Re: Need to match some beech...

Jesse Cloud

I asked for Beech once at Alpine Building Supply, arguably the best lumber yard in NM. The salesguy gave me a look and said coldly "We have never carried Beech." I felt like I had insulted him.

Re: Need to match some beech...

#5

Clint Searl

Re: Need to match some beech...

Clint Searl

John, I'm away from my shop in PA for a couple weeks, but I have a length if beech trunk about 7"-8" in diameter that I can whack a chunk off. Drop me a note if you're interested.

Clint

Re: Need to match some beech...

#6

answer.

bill tindall

there is no commercial demand for US beech except rail ties. the wood is unstable and hence useless for furniture. what exactly are you looking for? your didn't specify.

Re: Need to match some beech...

#7

That's what I've always heard too....

John in NM

Unstable.... but I'm not buying that, because the two places I've seen it used a lot, molding planes and gunstocks, both require some degree of stability. Ok, so planes are such a small chunk that it won't matter a whole lot :D

Its just somewhat curious to me, it's used for furniture in Europe, why not here? Just because we have lots of oak and maple for inexpensive woods? Not that maple is that inexpensive any longer :D

Any idea how involved steaming is? I probably don't want to get into that, but you never know, if its easy enough I can pick up some turners blocks and see how it goes.

Re: Need to match some beech...

#8

Re: That's what I've always heard too....

FredD

I have seen thousands of Beech veneered hollow core doors for interior use in housing over the years John, and I have heard the same about Sycamore being unstable , but it sure looks nice for drawer sides ;-))

FredD

Re: Need to match some beech...

#9

I've considered pear...

John in NM

Easily available in small quantities if somewhat more expensive, color's good since it's typically steamed also. Only trouble is it's not terribly durable. I might just order some and see how it looks, I've always wanted to make something with it anyhow.... can always use it for a nice box if it doesn't work out for the current project. :D

Re: Need to match some beech...

#10

Jesper, Denmark

Re: That's what I've always heard too....

Jesper, Denmark

There is quite a differene between European beech, which is quite stable and used for furniture and wooden planes amongst other things, and the American beech.

The European beech is not very weather resistant, so is not used for RR ties or any outside applications - like fence posts, boats or garden furniture.

Re: Need to match some beech...

#11

Sycamore

David Yoho

Flat-sawn sycamore is the culprit and the one you probably heard about. However, quarter-sawn sycamore is the cat's meow. I have a stash of quarter and rift-sawn sycamore I use for drawer boxes on the higher end stuff I build. Quater-sawn is stable and has the nice figure - flat-sawn is plain looking.

Re: Need to match some beech...

#12

Re: Need to match some beech...

Ron Bauman

Don't know what they've got or if they'll ship, etc. but I've had good luck with them, maybe worth a call http://www.friendshiphardwoods.com/first.html

Re: Need to match some beech...

#13

Re: Need to match some beech...

Ron Bauman

He's got some spalted beech flat stock on another site, but email him maybe he's got some heavier stuff, too http://www.milwaukeewoodworks.com/index.html

Re: Need to match some beech...

#14

Re: Sycamore

FredD

Right you are David , my favorite drawer box material.

FredD

Re: Need to match some beech...

#15

Re: That's what I've always heard too....

bill tindall

Unstable.... but I'm not buying that........well,if you know more than the saw mills and furniture factories, I can't help.

Its just somewhat curious to me, it's used for furniture in Europe, why not here? .......Most don't like its looks. You don't see much ash furniture either, (or elm, or sycamore) and it is plentiful, and a fine furniture wood. If you can generate demand for beech furniture hundreds of saw mills and thousands of land owners will bless you as will the German companies trying to establish a market for European beech.

Re: Need to match some beech...

#17

RR ties are treated

bill tindall

the untreated wood only needs to be hard and cheap

Re: Need to match some beech...

#18

Let me clarify...

John in NM

I'm not saying that the wood is not unstable, I'm questioning how important that is for many applications. Most beech rifle stocks I've seen are European, so it's possible that the European species has vastly different properties than the American - but I find that unlikely.

Now I'm not saying that I'd use big flat sawn panels for a door, or make a drop leaf table top out of it.... but is "unstable" really a valid argument in an industry that makes use of knotty alder? However bad beech could be, its got to be better than that junk. :D I think most of the "industry lore" as it were is little more than habit.

As to appearance, I like it about as much as red oak or hickory, but then I like all woods (except alder :D:D:D)

Re: Need to match some beech...

#19

Re: that would be Birch, not beech

FredD

Since you weren't there Bill , you wouldn't know .

The last Beech skinned doors we used came from Union Door in Union City , Ca. and were clearly invoiced as Beech and were similar in appearance , but not interchangeable with Birch.

FredD

Re: Need to match some beech...

#20

Re: RR ties are treated

FredD

"the untreated wood only needs to be hard and cheap "

And Green , like in wet.

My Dad , A Santa Fe Road Master at the time and I went though the Santa Fe's Tie plant in Albuquerque and it was a eye opener for sure.

They ran the ties after they had been milled for the Tie plates though a Vacuum Chamber which slurped out the water and then they were immediately plunged into a vat of hot creosote which replaced the water down to the core of the Tie.

The smell of old ties and Creosote was pleasant to me and every time I get a whif of it , back come a lot of memories of working on the Railroad during summer vacations in High School.

FredD

Re: Need to match some beech...

#21

Re: Let me clarify...

FredD

FYI John

http://www.blueplanetbiomes.org/american_beech.htm

FredD

Re: Need to match some beech...

#22

Thanks Fred...

John in NM

Good info :D

Re: Need to match some beech...

#23

Thanks for the offer...

John in NM

I found a couple vendors on ebay, ordered from one, might get some turning blanks from the other.

Re: Need to match some beech...

#24

Re: answer.

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

My local hardwood supplier carries both american and european beech. It's around $2/board foot for 4/4 american and $4.30 for european. The supplier touts the american beech for stair treads and risers.

Re: Need to match some beech...

#25

Re: Need to match some beech...

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

One of my local suppliers has both Euro, and local, however, the imported is very expensive.

Down here, there is a fair amount of it out in the woods, but because it grows so close to the upland streams, it falls under the protection of environmental laws to prevent erosion.

I have been hunting some woods where there is a nice stand of big Beech growing alongside a little creek. To me these big trees are living works of art. The Yellow-bellied Sapsuckers like the smooth thin bark for sending their Morris-code messages out to the rest of the natural world.