Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Car totaled....Questions

Posts

Car totaled....Questions

#1

Car totaled....Questions

Barry Irby

I had an accident in my Honda CRV. Its a 2003 with 150,000 miles. Insurance company claims it is only worth about $4600 and the repairs would be near that so they want to total it and give me $4600 If I decide to keep the car and fix it myself, they want me to buy it back from them for the salvage value which they state is about $1800 so I would net $2800.

I have gone on line and can only find three similar cars with in 250 miles and they are about $6800 and they have similar mileage and features.

It seems to me they should give me the value of the car and they should give me the salvage value. Why should they give me a reduced value, because the car is "high mileage" and then keep the car and get the salvage value?

What am I missing here other than I am getting a beating from the insurance company?

Re: Car totaled....Questions

#2

Re: Car totaled....Questions

Phil Joines

Insurance companies never give the real value of the car.

Re: Car totaled....Questions

#3

Re: Car totaled....Questions

Nat Robison

The insurance co. has pegged the value of your car at $4600 in an undamaged state. If you they pay you that, you're made whole and they're free to get whatever they're able to out of it since they "bought" the car. You may disagree with the amount but you don't get the benefit of both values.........just as if you sell a tool to someone and then expect the amount they resell it for. You don't get both.

The only potential gripe you have here is the amount you fee the car is worth vs. what they're offering you.

Re: Car totaled....Questions

#4

Also.....

Nat Robison

Take the comparables to the ins. company and have them work a little harder to justify why they're pegging your value at a chunk less than the comparables in the area. Check blue book values online from www.kbb.com. I would say, though, that it's difficult to make out well on a total loss on any car older than 1 year. Often, depreciation happens to a much larger degree than we think.

Re: Car totaled....Questions

#5

I looked at their website......

Barry Irby

They have a "we help you buy a car" website. I went to it at their suggestion and set the parameters for my car within 200 miles. No car at any age or mileage came close to what they were claiming my car was worth. Even High mileage cars very like mine were about $2000 more. I will discuss this with them soon. I have told them that if they would put a nearly identical car in my driveway, less the deductible, I would be happy.

Re: Car totaled....Questions

#6

That's the profit...

John in NM

They're paying you what a dealer would pay you for the undamaged car, or at least an estimate of it. The prices you're seeing on various sites reflect what people (dealers or otherwise) are trying to get for vehicles, but not necessarily what they ultimately sell for. I've noticed whenever I try to sell anything, I get told how grossly overpriced it is, but when I try to buy something it's a "steal" at a price above what I'd like to pay. The world is apparently no place for an honest person :D:D:D

Insurance is a business, they count on you paying for years and never needing it, and when you do need it, they try to get out as cheaply as possible. Every time my dealings with an insurer has gone deeper than giving them a check for 6 more months this has been re-enforced to me.

Is the insurer in this case your insurance company or another? At least your own insurer has some motivation to keep you happy, they want your continued business buying insurance they hope to never pay on. I've had even worse luck with other people's insurers, they have absolutely no interest in paying you if they can get out of it. The last time I tried to make a claim, they actually had the nerve to tell me that their client who caused the accident (on private property naturally, no police report, no ticket) was "unreachable" because they wouldn't respond to inquiries about the accident. I bet they're still reachable when the premium is due! Dead end.

Re: Car totaled....Questions

#7

Re: I looked at their website......

Galen Vetterick

I had a Jeep Cherokee that the insurance company wanted to total it out and started out with a low value. I looked at what a replacement "equal" would be and that is what they HAD to settle for in cash. The other parties insurance, so I would not settle for any less. Also paid for rental car till I got something else to drive.

They had already given a local shop the Jeep to rebuild before we even settled!

Ruffled my feathers knowing it was going back on the street, but not to me.

When I signed over the Jeep I listed it as "totalled" in the line for damages. They wanted me to list the damage value in terms of money. By noting it was "totalled" it was going to cost them more to get it back on the street and not just parted out. So it made me feel even better.

Re: Car totaled....Questions

#8

I agree with Galen...

Stuart Hough

When I was hit and the car was to be totalled, I looked around as you did and found several that were comparable and got quotes from the dealerships as to the price asked. I then presented this to the other person's insurance company and told them I would be VERY happy to drive a rental on their dime for as long as it took to make me happy. After 4 weeks I had a man standing at my front door with a check for the average of the estimates and a waiver form to be signed, which I gladly accepted. For once, I actually MADE money on a car deal. You have to play hardball, even with your own insurance company. Remind them how many years you have been a loyal customer, and how you have net your end of the bargain.

good luck!

Re: Car totaled....Questions

#9

Re: Car totaled....Questions

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

It sounds like this is your own insurance company? If not and if they don't budge on the car value, push for money for pain, suffering, and potential medical bills. Just be sure what your medical situation is; some accident trauma won't show up right away.

Re: Car totaled....Questions

#10

Re: Car totaled....Questions

Mark Nowicki

Was your policy a replacement policy?

Mark

Re: Car totaled....Questions

#11

Re: Car totaled....Questions

Dave Nichols

I have over 45 years exper. working in body shops and insurance. The last 23 years were as an insurance appraiser in Penna. In Pa. the state insurance dept. only allows several methods for an insurance co. to determine the value of a total loss vehicle. They do not allow values from the Kelly Blue Book, if a book value is used to obtain the vehicle value you must use a book called the Red Book and the NADA Guide and average the 2 values, after that is done you would then check the totaled vehicle for any prior damage or wear above a normal amount for the age of the vehicle and deduct that from the averaged value. The wear could be burns in the seats, very dirty interior or trunk, paint scratches or poor tires. If the vehicle had not been in a loss and you were to trade it in the dealer would also deduct for these items since they would have to repair them to ready the vehicle for resale. In Pa. they can also get dealer quotes and average them, use a state certified company such as CCC to get values through dealer surveys or pay for a replacement vehicle which has to be the same as the one you owned with about the same mileage and condition. In the other choices I've listed the deduction for any wear or prior damage would also apply. If you have any questions about how the insurance co. is settling your claim you should check with the state insurance commision in your state.

Re: Car totaled....Questions

#12

From "The Shark" . . .

steve mackay

SWMBO sells the stuff (hence, I don't concern my little brain with it. Thank God !) We watched the guy across the street try to keep his brand new Mustang and STILL get the insurance money. At the time I "got" the "idea" of what was going on but could never explain it. I sent your question to "The Boss". Soooooooo, from The Shark's mouth :

In my opinion you need to take the $4600 and not have a salvage title vehicle. When the title is salvage and you have another loss most insurance companies will only give you 50% of the loss after your deductible. Auto insurance is not replacement cost it is Actual Cash Value and then the companies will deduct for the wear & tear on your particular vehicle as a general rule.

Re: Car totaled....Questions

#13

Re: Car totaled....Questions

Joe Mohnike

Insurance companies use one book KBB (high) to establish a value to set the cost of the comp & coll. on your car. In the event of a loss they use a different book (low) to establish a settlement value.

Have you had your own body shop look at the car? Many times they will have a lower estimate than an insurance adjuster, and with the slow economy they may be willing to work with you and keep it lower.

Do not buy back the car. When you repair a totaled car and put it back on the road you become the same thing as Ford, Chev, Toyota etc. you are considered the mfg. of that auto. If you sell the and something goes wrong, and someone is injured due to some failure of the car you are, or could be considered liable.

You should also talk to your state insurance department.

You may also, be able to ask for non-binding arbitration.

Also, if the accident was your fault, you will/may not be able to get a rental, unless rental coverage is included on your policy.

I am a California insurance agent (37 yrs)and 50 yr wood worker

Joe

Re: Car totaled....Questions

#14

Ahhhh, the old retail vs wholesale debate

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

In my experience insurance companies work off wholesale prices not retail prices for car values. I seriously doubt that they will buy an identical car for you. It won't hurt to negotiate with them and show them the comparables and ask how they arrived at their figures. Sometimes over zealous insurance adjusters try to save their clients or employers (Insurance companies) money by low balling the value of the car.

Lee

Re: Car totaled....Questions

#15

Re: Car totaled....Questions

gary peterson

here's a story. Lived in NYS moved to NJ, policy in effect from NYS. son's auto totalled in NJ. Auto body estimate which we submit to insurance says $2700 to fix. NYS says car is totalled and sending us a check for $4300. NO, they weren't going to pay the $2700, I had to settle for the $4300. Now, go figure.

Re: Car totaled....Questions

#16

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

The reason.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Insurance companies don't total a car when the damage estimate meets or exceeds the value of the car. They total it when the damage estimate is around 70-80%. Often, the damage estimate is just that--an estimate, and it goes up from there once the mechanics at the body shop start digging in. So, while the estimate was $2700, the insurance adjuster probably figured it would be higher, say $3500, so they total it, send a check for $4300, then sell the totaled vehicle for its salvage value, which might put their total outlay under $2700.

Jason

Re: Car totaled....Questions

#17

Re: The reason.

gary peterson

ooops, forgot to mention, we also got to keep the car. thank you for the reply tho.

Re: Car totaled....Questions

#18

Re: Car totaled....Questions

Barry

When you are driving into a new city, look at the skyline. Notice that the tallest buildings are insurance companies or banks. You have ust discovered the reason.

Re: Car totaled....Questions

#19

Re: I looked at their website......

Barry

Never let the think they have made you happy..........