Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

I need a router recommendation

Posts

I need a router recommendation

#1

I need a router recommendation

Bill Tindall

I have an ancient Sears router. Bearings are shot-screams like a Banshee, fan blades have fractured. It's on death's door. However it has the best features I have ever seen in a router for the way I use it- precision wood removal for hinge mortises and similar operations where I am making precise cuts to a scribe line. (think "power chisel")

It has:

1. two comfortable handles to provide precise control

2. the switch is in a handle, again to aid control

3. an internal light that illuminates the bit so one can see to route "to the line".

Does any modern router have these features? A foot switch can substitute for the switch in the handle but the internal light and two handles are a must.

Re: I need a router recommendation

#2

Re: I need a router recommendation

del schisler

bosch ev 1617 is a nice one. I have one in my table that stays in their and a couple pc690's. These don't have a lite . Are these table or hand. must be hand with 2 handles? I have 5 total routers. I use them most every day . Not look at any other's . Some one will chime in with newer routers. have a good holiday

Re: I need a router recommendation

#3

Dale Lenz

My first router

Dale Lenz

was a 1980 Sears, last year with the "rack & pinon" depth control w/ light and handle switch, loved it! Light bulbs did not last long if I recall, they where auto bulbs I belive. Rebuilt it at least once within 10-15 years. Purchased another on on Ebay, lightly use, looks at the pictures. However by the time I got the second Sear's router I'd gotten an ELU/DeWalt with the R&P depth control. Smoother running router but does not have the other options you request. The R&P is not cover like the Sears and it does get caked with sawdust from time to time.

Re: I need a router recommendation

#4

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: I need a router recommendation

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Closest I could come is a P-C "D handle" router, but there's no light. I do ue mine a lot.

I had one of the Craftsman routers you describe, and I liked it, but it finally died.

When that happened, I actually took the handles off it, and cobbled them onto a P-C 690 plunge base - switch and all. I hardwired the 690 motor into the switched handle, and have been using it like that for about ten years now. I think it's a nice improvement over the original P-C setup.

I couldn't salvage the light, though. :(

Re: I need a router recommendation

#5

Re: I need a router recommendation *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I can't recall where I saw this, but you can apparently get some very compact little LED flashlighty things these days, small enough to fasten to the router and rugged enough not to vibrate to death. If you can't find a complete solution, you might consider that.

That said, DeWalt's new "compact router" (they're no longer calling them laminate trimmers, and rightly so), while lacking the two handles you're seeking, does have built-in LED lights and seems like it would have the grunt for your application.


http://www.dewalt.com/pages/promotions/CompactRouters-Promo/CompactRouters-Promo.aspx

Re: I need a router recommendation

#6

Re: I need a router recommendation

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

Bill: I too had a Craftsman router with a light and switch in the handle. I do miss those features, but the rest of it was not much to my liking. I like my PC 690 series much better. I'll send you my Craftsman for the cost of postage if you want it (purchased in Canada in mid-late 80's).

I don't know about all the other features, but the only routers with lights that I am aware of are the new compact routers (think souped up laminate trimmers). I can't recall which ones have the light, but I am certain that at least one of them do. Most of these are made to wrap your hand around the body rather than a big base with handles. For your application, if I were doing the buying, I'd certainly take a good look at this class of router. Many new models on the market in the last 12 months have improved/precise depth control, some have plunge bases, etc. No handles however.

Henry

Re: I need a router recommendation

#7

Second that

Henry Higginbotham

For the uses you described, I've always found my PC310 to be the most controllable. The DeWalt not only has the light you want, but maybe (unlike the PC310) you can actually remove the bit without explosives and expletives.

Re: I need a router recommendation

#8

Removing the bit on the PC 310 and similar routers

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Someone told me that bit removal on a PC 310 and similar routers can be done this way:

1. Take the body out of the base.

2. Loosen the collet nut some.

3. Set the collet nut down on the benchtop - the motor is then projecting out horizontally from the front of the bench, with one flat of the collet nut resting on the benchtop.

4. Give the upper flat of the collet nut a sharp rap with the back of the collet wrench or something similar. You don't want a heavy hammer, which might distort the nut.

The vibration from the blow seems to jiggle the collet loose. So far, it's worked every time.

Re: I need a router recommendation

#9

Re: I need a router recommendation

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

Is this going to be your only router, or just one for those specific needs?

It would be a shame to put the light feature over plunge, if you don't already have a powerful plunge router.

It would be nice, when we decide to buy a new tool, if we had a crystal ball that would allow us to see into all our future needs, rather than rely on past experience and current needs.

Re: I need a router recommendation

#10

Help with plunging

Bill Tindall

I have 6 routers of various sizes and applications (two live bolted into tables). I have never seen an application where I needed the plunge feature. What does one use it for? There seem to be bunches out there so I am confident they must have some application.

Re: I need a router recommendation

#11

Dewalt

Hoa in Alameda

I currently have a few routers, but here is my most often used (no LED light, however):


You can see that each of them has a customized clear base. The fixed base is (almost always) dedicated to the flush trim jig base (a la Bill Hilton).

I use them with PC accessories (I don't think they mind now that it's one company :) ):


Re: I need a router recommendation

#12

When you find that crystal ball . . .

Henry Higginbotham

. . . ask it if it wants to buy my Sand Rite pump sander that I somehow thought I needed a couple of years ago. :D

Re: I need a router recommendation

#13

Re: I need a router recommendation *LINK*

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

Bill,

Here is a pic of my homemade task lighting on a PC310.The small flashlights can be found at Lowe's,Walgreens,Harbor Freight and I am sure others for less than $5.


I have also upgraded that router with a new adjustable knob that is much easier to loosen/adjust the base.Thanks to McMaster Carr the knob is a great improvement.I'd have to go out to the shop and measure the threads to know which is the exact one.

Andy


http://www.mcmaster.com/#catalog/116/2208/=a5xas3

Re: I need a router recommendation

#14

Re: Help with plunging

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

Well Bill, you need to take the leap, and I'm sure you will be glad that you did. I have got 4 plunge routers that see most of routing jobs in my shop. I also have 5 smaller trimmers for other various specialty needs, but on a daily basis, the plunge routers do most of the work, even little delicate things.

Three of these are Makita 3612's. I like the square base better than round. I also have a Ryobi too, but don't like the trigger as much. It is in the handle, like you like, but has a safety button, but no lock-on, so I use it mainly as a drill for my 32 mm templates.

The switch on the Makita's is a toggle, in easy reach of thumb and forefinger while the right hand is rapped around the nice big handles. This is very convenient.

Some of the handy uses for plunge, is being able to change the depth while on the fly, while the base is in full contact with the work or template, keeping it straight up and down, while being able to plunging about 2" deep for a mortise. You are pushing against a spring, which also retracts the router while the base is still keeping it perpendicular to the face.

Some people might be afraid of getting a powerful router, due to having lost control of a small one that got traction, and took off with them. I think that tendency if more likely to happen with an under-powered router than one with enough power to keep cutting rather than bog down.

You can get some really good little LED lights that would be easy to attach when you need one. I have one from Gander Mt. about half the size of a paper match book, with a wire for my cap bill, for $15, that will clip to the depth-stop screws.

I never buy a 1/4" bit, if I can get what I want with 1/2".

Re: I need a router recommendation

#15

That is funny Henry . . .

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

Maybe it would like to keep the one I bought about 25 years ago company. It has been about that long since it got out to play. ha

Re: I need a router recommendation

#16

Variable mileage

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I own two plungers, but use them rarely. I find the lower handles and resulting lower perceived center of gravity of a fixed base works better for me.

Maybe it's a difference in the kind of work we do, you and I.

Re: I need a router recommendation

#17

Re: I need a router recommendation

Bill Tindall

Thanks for all the helpful ideas.

Re: I need a router recommendation

#18

what plung router is used for *LINK*

del schisler

here is what i use the plung router for. I use this from milescrafter 1207 for these pattern's on my jewelry box's. Here is a video . I use mine a little different and lot's faster. They have to show it in a slow and safer ?? Also for inlay work . here is the link


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x1i6dUmi9xg