Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Seeking Advice on Drawers

Posts

Seeking Advice on Drawers

#1

Seeking Advice on Drawers

Ed

I�m building a workbench and I have it to the point of building the drawers. I�ve got two sections that are 19� wide by 21� tall and 31� deep. Since this will be a free standing work bench I want to build drawers on each side, so they�d be about 15� deep on each side.

I also have a space for a cabinet on one end for larger hand tools, like circular saws, drills, etc.

Storage space is a problem, and this bench is meant to mitigate that problem.

I�m looking for advice on several topics and am hoping that I can tap into the wealth of knowledge on this site.

* How many drawers of what size would you put into the 21�? (e.g. two 4�, and one 13�, or two 4� and two 6.5�)

* Ever make a specialty drawer, like a drawer just for router bits?

* Ever get finished and think �I should have done ��?

* Ever have a fantastic idea that didn�t pan out so well?

I�d appreciate all comments, lacking experience, I�m looking for yours.

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

#2

JL

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

JL

* How many drawers of what size would you put into the 21�? (e.g. two 4�, and one 13�, or two 4� and two 6.5�)

* Ever make a specialty drawer, like a drawer just for router bits?

* Ever get finished and think �I should have done ��?

* Ever have a fantastic idea that didn�t pan out so well?

Do you want drawer separators? Either on the face frame or between the drawers?

What sort of drawer front are you going to have? Flush or overlap? If overlap, how much?

I like separators (rails) between drawers in a shop. I also like to have a drawer front that overlaps the rail by a bit. You could also do a rabbet on the drawer front to help seal the drawer (minimize the dust).

If you are going to have rails between the drawers (and on the top and bottom) - figure on maybe 3 drawers at 5.5" each. This gives you 4.5" of space for rails and empty space (you do want a little space). You may want to consider having rails and plywood between the drawers.

Specialty drawers - I have one for saw blades. I don't have one for router bits - I have a "cabinet" that I attached to my router table for that. I could see that a router bit drawer (with inserts and maybe two levels) would work quite well.

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

#3

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

Good morning, Ed, OK, I would use the sizes you mentioned, but space the different drawers sizes so you would have a lot of space for things you can't think of right now.....i.e. two 4" and two 6.5" in one space; two 4" and one 13" in the next space next to the first ones mentioned.....this on one side of the bench; and then you can decided how the drawers would be on the other side as well.

Like JL mentioned, install the stiles and rails for separation, and also use 3/8" for the drawer bottoms....you do not want them to sag from all the things you are going to be putting into them.

Use your router table to cut all the sides and fronts and rears in one setup for the dadoes for the 3/8" plywood bottoms; rabbit the dronts and rears to accept the sides, glue and pin nail them together, slide in the bottoms and pin nail only the rears, and use the drawer slides you can purchase at the BORGS for easy running of the drawers.

I am also building a bench...jack-bench.com... but with no drawers in this one, and will be building my drawers into another bench like yours later this week too.

Just rearranging things for a different style of shop for me and easier working too.

Use the Shopsmith and the bandsaw for most of my work....

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

#4

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

Barry Irby

I have a number of drawers I find very useful. There are several shallow drawers about two inches deep. They might actually be more useful if they were shallower, say 1 1/2" or even less, so that stuff would lay in them one layer deep with no temptations to double up.

Another useful drawer is one that is about seven inches deep and my routers will lay in them quit nicely.

I have my router bits on a rack on the wall with their shafts stuck into holes. This works well, as different sized bits can be accommodated without toughing each other and no chance of rattling around and chipping the edges. A drawer for router bits might be tough because some of them are a 1/4" in diameter and some are 3".

Try to decide what you want store and then make the drawer accommodate the largest item in the set.

I have some drawers mounted on pieces of metal I scavenged. 1/4" metal epoxied into slots. Been working for thirty years. I have others mounted on full extension rails. Not as good. Sawdust finds the rials and they get sort of crunchy and I have to blow them out.

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

#5

Moses Yoder

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

Moses Yoder

I would go through you shop and plan on what you are putting into the drawers then size them accordingly. A 13" deep drawer is fine for a kitchen to store pots, but does not make so much sense in a shop. Perhaps you would store routers in the drawers, standing upright? If so, you would want to put a false bottom in the drawer with holes cut in it for the bits to go through so the router base sets flush on the bottom. I lay my routers on the sides to store them and only have 2 so they would probably fit in a 9" drawer; I have an extended base on one. When I built my tool box I thought about it and plannned on where I was putting stuff and it has worked out well so far. I think too in a shop maybe sawdust would get into drawer slides so perhaps the best way to build them would be with rails between boxes and the drawers would just slide on the rails like the old dressers, wood on wood. I also think being shop drawers this would offer a good chance to practice cutting hand cut dovetails in soft maple for the boxes.

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

#6

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

Jim Dillon

Ed,

Here, hopefully, is a pic of of my bench with drawers. As you can see, the drawers are various sizes which has worked out well. The drawer on the left with the hand cutout is for router bits stored in their original plastic case. The bottom pullout on the left is for routers/fences etc. and has worked fine except that it does collect sawdust and chips. The electrical outlets have proven useful, as has the shelf just below the benchtop. I wish I could claim credit for the base design, but it came from a past FWW mag. The top design is from another mag with my own changes. I second the need for a sturdy drawer bottom, especially in the larger drawer. The drawers glide on locust runners and are enclosed in a 3/4 inch plywood four-sided box. For a free-standing bench like you have, these drawers could easily be put on both sides. Not sure if these ideas will help with your bench design, but thought they might be useful.

Jim


Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

#7

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

Bill Tindall

I have some shallow (about 4") drawers in my bench and I find them useful. I have drills, measuring devices, chisels in these drawers. A drawer for router bits would be nice but I don't have it.

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

#8

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

John McGaw

Do you have any long tools which will need a home? You might glance at the Accuride 2002 "passthrough" slides for at least one drawer. If that doesn't ring your bell because they are only good for 50 pounds you might still consider at least one full-depth drawer using conventional heavy-duty full-extension slides.

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

#9

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

Jesse Cloud

Interesting topic! We all have different personalities on this one. My advice is to make them flexible, e.g. different sized drawers with dividers or foam inserts that can be taken out and reconfigured.

One thing I really like is the ability to have a "task drawer" for instance, all the stuff I use to cut dovetails. I can just take the drawer out of the carcass and put it next to the work.

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

#10

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

Ed

I've seen that design with the opening below the top. Do you use that to store things that you're using for the current task but want them off of the top?

Thanks to everyone, there's a lot of good comments, please keep them coming, it seems that there are a lot of opinions on this topic, from people who have a lot of experience.

I'm particularly interested in anything that you did, that you wish you hadn't.

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

#11

Do It Your Way

David Yoho

I think you're the only one that can decide the answers to your questions as far as sizes and numbers go. I think we all work a little differently to arrive at the end result. How you work is what's important.

Think about which side of the bench you work from most, where do you need certain tools at hand, which tools are they, and what is their importance to what you do most. These are the tools you want the closest and readily available. Your placement and sizing should be determined by these first.

There are those tool that you need but not as much as the first group. These should occupy the next closest space.

Finally, there are tools and things you just want to store. Those should get the space that's left. Sizing should be easy for this group.

Also, if you plan to use mechanical slides, most of the regular slides are 3/4 extension, which leaves an area toward the rear that's not always easy to get to and things have a way of making their way there not to be seen for some time! Although pricey, if the budget will allow, I'd go with full extension slides on any drawers you feel need full access.

I might be the only one to approach this solution in this way but it's the way I would do it if it were mine to do.

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

#12

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

Ed

Thanks, a pass-through is something that I thought about, but it drifted to the back of my mind, probably becasue all my long tools are easy to hang or clamp up. Now that you mention it I think it would be a great thing to have for long tools that I don't yet own. In the mean time I could always put in some dividers to make use of the space until I need it for a long tool.

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

#13

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

Ed

I had thought of a task drawer, but hadn't thought about taking it out to use. That's a good idea.

How do you deal with stops that you can bypass to remove the drawer? I was thinking of using wood rails to rest the drawers on.

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

#14

Re: Do It Your Way

Ed

You're right about doing it my way, surveying what tools I have, etc. The reason I started this thread is because I think one way, and I want to find out how other people think. Your explenation of how you organize tools is a perfect example of how to think it through, as is the task drawer way of looking at it.

Thanks,

Ed

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

#15

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

David Hay Denver

I'm currently making some drawers for some built-in cabinets in my workshop. I have several banks of drawers with a combination of 4", 8" and 10" or 11" high drawers. I have a 13" or 14" drawer in an existing cabinet, and I find it's just too deep. It just becomes a mishmash of stuff that I have to dig through to get to the item I want...which is usually on the bottom.

David

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

#16

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

Jim Dillon

Ed,

I think the original designer intended that space below the bench top to be used for bar-type clamp storage, but I have never used it for that purpose. The main reason for not using it for even temporary clamp storage is because I have a convenient clamp rack next to the bench, plus I have the bench up against a wall so that limits the length of clamp. I find it very convenient to store a bench hook, a 1-foot aluminum square, rubber mallets, saber saw etc. I loosely have what is in the drawers broken down by task, as a poster mentioned: cutting tools (chisels), measuring tools, planes and scrapers, and large tools/bulky stuff in the bottom drawer, with router wrenches and miscellaneous junk in the top left drawer. Changes? The base unit has worked out fine except I might put a door on the router bin. And if my overall shop were bigger, I would make it larger. There is one change I would make to the bench top, but your question concerned bench drawers so I won't go there.

Jim

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

#17

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

Ed Beck

But the 10" or 11" drawers are OK? What do you keep in them.

So far I'm thinking that more smaller drawers sounds good, in the 2" range, using rails to sit them on, and at least one pass-through.

Faces overhanging a little to keep dust out.

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

#18

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

Ed Beck

You may want to consider having rails and plywood between the drawers.

I'm not sure what you mean. I have plywood vertically set in the bench on each side of the drawer sections. I'd glue the rails to this plywood for the drawers to run on.

Is this the plywood between the drawers? It doesn't sound like it would be. Are you saying to have plywood set horizonatally in the space between the drawers?

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

#19

Re: Do It Your Way

FredD

I agree with David , especially about doing it to fit your needs and by all means use Accuride full extension slides.

The comment about slides being stuck because of sawdust getting in them hasn't been my experience, mine work as smooth as Silk and I saw a lot.

Here's my take on a workbench, note the router storage and the use of it for a off feed table.

http://picasaweb.google.com/FredD17209/20080801?authkey=Gv1sRgCI_vnPD30fOqzQE&feat=directlink

Here's the rest I left out of the first link

http://picasaweb.google.com/FredD17209/C?authkey=Gv1sRgCN7It8KpxcK0bQ&feat=directlink

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

#20

JL

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

JL

On the face frame, the stiles run vertically and the rails run horizontally.

I was suggesting that you have horizontal rails. Also, some like to physically separate their drawers. Instead of having the drawers (and slides or glides) being the only thing in the case, some people like to separate the drawers. This prevents stuff from migrating from one drawer to another. I've done this with a couple of sets of drawers. You can cut dadoes into the sides of the carcass.

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

#21

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

Ed Beck

Ok, got it. Rails on the front to provide separation and to have something for the drawer face to push against to keep dust out. And a divider between the drawers to prevent stuff from cascading from one to the other.

Wish I had thought of the rails before I glued the stiles in.

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

#22

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

David Hay Denver

I haven't finished making the drawers, so I can't comment on whether the 10"-11" drawers are ok ;) I did build them with some of my tools and supplies in mind. IIRC, they should be deep enough to hold some gallon containers of mineral sprits and other solvents as well as my routers, when standing upright.

I figure that if have a lot of flat stuff to store in the 4" drawers, I can always add a sliding tray within a couple of the drawers later.

David

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

#23

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

FredD

Don't fret Ed , look at the shots I sent and see if you see any rails between the drawers.

In a utility bench with a drawer box ,space is a premium not to be wasted on rails that separate the drawers.

There is no "migration of items" between the drawers and the drawers if kept neat , do not collect dust, at least mine don't.

One last thing about the Bench , I thought about making one for forty years and finally did it just the way I envisioned, it works for me and as David points out that is the driving force behind the design , what you want, go do it.

FredD

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

#24

Ellis Walentine

Ed, a request

Ellis Walentine

You apparently have used an incorrect e-mail address in your profile, so whenever someone posts a reply to your posts, and you have the "E-mail me" box checked, the notification bounces back to me. Please either correct your e-mail address or don't check the "E-mail me" box.

Thanks,

Ellis

Re: Seeking Advice on Drawers

#25

Re: Ed, a request

Ed

I just checked and the address in my profile is correct. I received a number of mail yesterday but have not gotten any more today. I unchecked the email box on this reply, is there anywhere else that my address could be incorrect?