Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

3-Way Joint

Posts

3-Way Joint

#1

3-Way Joint

Rob Scrimgeour

I need to make a number of kitchen cabinets in a style that incorporates an external frame in solid wood, with recessed veneered side panels. The frame members are 1.75" square in section, and I will need to make joints with 3 frame elements on each corner. I propose to make the joint as shown in this SketchUp illustration.



Is there a better way of joining these 3 elements? I am aware that there is a fancy 3-way miter joint, which would be beyond my capability, and I don't believe would have the necessary strength. I would appreciate some hoots from the wise owls. Thank you.

Re: 3-Way Joint

#2

I avoid dowels

Bill Tindall

What you are wanting to accomplish is not different from making a table with 1 3/4 legs and an apron, except your "apron" will be 1 3/4".

Dowels just don't hold up well. There is essentially no long grain gluing surface to hold things together. Even a 1" mortise and tenon would be vastly stronger and more durable. To that end I would see if I could work out a 1/4" or 5/16" thick tenon inset from the outer edge by 1/4"to 3/8" which would accommodate a 1" long tenon on each piece.(or miter the tenon ends for an even longer tenon, but less strong post. Alternatively, the same arrangement with biscuits.

If you don't own a mortise machine or attachment for drill press this is a good opportunity to buy one with the huge saving you will be experiencing doing your own cabinets.

Re: 3-Way Joint

#3

Clint Searl

Here's an example...

Clint Searl


Clint

Re: 3-Way Joint

#4

I like that!

paul in AZ

Re: 3-Way Joint

#5

Re: I avoid dowels

Rob Scrimgeour

Thanks for the valuable input - I think my client really likes the exposed end of the full height tenon in front. Do you think this arrangement would have the strength?

" border="0" alt="">

Thanks again in advance.

Re: 3-Way Joint

#6

Re: I avoid dowels

Rob Scrimgeour

Sorry - here is the new pic


Re: 3-Way Joint

#7

don't know

Bill Tindall

Without seeing the whole piece I don' t know what loads will be on where. If looks trumps joints that have stood the test of time, give it a try. Depending on how the panel is used the panel may provide all the strength that is required..... or not.

In the case posted below the joint would(does) look exceptional in a certain style end table or coffee table. But for a table with a long leg it would not be a construction I would attempt (for more reasons than I could never get it to fit as good as it would need to fit). The only thing holding the leg in one direction would be the glue on the tenon cheeks. The short section of cross grain in the leg would provide little additional strength. But if a stretcher was part of the table then the joint would be plenty strong with a long leg. One can't offer advice, or comment, on joint strength without considering the whole piece and how it will be used.

Re: 3-Way Joint

#8

Clint Searl

Re: I avoid dowels

Clint Searl

A perhaps simpler version of this one would be to replace the blind tenon with a single through dowel, fox-wedged on the blind end and separately wedged on the exposed end, for strength and visual interest. The exposed wedges could be of a contrasting wood.

Clint

Re: 3-Way Joint

#9

Ellis Walentine

Not there yet

Ellis Walentine

This joint is actually a worse choice than your original dowel joint, because the tenon on the piece at the left seriously compromises the through tenon on the rear piece, leaving a wide area of short grain that will split out easily.

I'm unclear on the context of these joints, but if they're part of a cabinet frame that will be secured to the real estate and therefore not subjected to potentially destructive forces, such as racking, the dowel joint is probably more than adequate. I wouldn't want to use it if you're relying on the dowel joint to keep the parts from separating under strain.

Another, simpler, alternative if these are indeed to be kitchen cabinets, would be to use pocket screws to hold the left member to the open mortise & tenon joint. Either this or a dowel joint would be much more structurally sound if you secured it to a horizontal rail inside the cabinet.

Ellis

Ellis

Re: 3-Way Joint

#10

Re: 3-Way Joint

Rob Scrimgeour

Thanks to all for the valuable input - perhaps I should have included this pic to show the overall context. The brown color is the solid wood, the gray is the veneered panels, solid edged on front, and beveled for effect, and the yellow is quarter inch backing, screwed to the veneer panels. The cabinet is 36" long by 24" deep, and a number of these will be anchored together and will support a solid wood top, suitably attached with table clips. Some units will include drawers. The wood will be African Mahogany.

My concern would be possible sideways racking in the front section. Perhaps I should lose the full height tenon and go with Clint's pic of independent tenons. Would this be safer?


Re: 3-Way Joint

#11

Re: 3-Way Joint *LINK*

charlie belden

I'd go with loose tenon joinery. Simplifies things

- no Visible Length PLUS 2 X Tenon Length to deal with

- no shoulders to cut

- cut a mortise wrong, plug it and cut it again

You can make up your loose tenon stock and cut

off what you need.

You didn't say how many of these cabinets you need

to do now, nor if you plan to do similar cabinets in the

future.

The quickest, easiest and most accurate way to do

loose tenon joinery is - with the Festool DOMINO

Sets up quickly, no layout lines required and once

set up a 12 year old could cut all the mortises

- 2 on each end of the horizontal components

- 4 on each joint face of the vertical components

that's 32 mortises- in under about an hour.

The mortises are cut as easily as using a biscuit

cutter.

Yes - the DOMINO ain't cheap. The LEIGH FMT

is about the same price when you include all

the "accessories" - but the DOMINO is so much

easier to set up and use - no clamping required,

all parts cut flat on your bench top - or on the

floor.

I've got and used a mortise and chisel mortiser

(General International 75-075 M1), a shop made

router jig for cutting mortises, the TREND M&T JIG

and the DOMINO. I NEEDED the General for

cutting BIG mortises when I built my work bench.

The DOMINO is all I need for ANY future furniture

sized mortises and loose tenon joinery.

I have no connection to Festool other than being

a very satisfied DOMINO owner/user.

Under DOMINO Projects check out the

Floor to Ceiling Linen Cabinet by a Newbie.

If you have any questions feel free to e-mail me.


Plenty on the DOMINO

Re: 3-Way Joint

#12

Re: 3-Way Joint

Rob Scrimgeour

Thanks for the suggestion Charlie - and for the comprehensive info on the Domino - I have salivated over it in the past, and now might be a good chance to see if I can justify it for this job. Here in South Africa we usually have to trade in arms and legs for the good stuff, but I will certainly go into it.

Re: 3-Way Joint

#13

easy fix... and a risky opinion

Bill Tindall

Corner brace it and it will be fine what ever joint you use.

The quest to be novel often leads to strange. To be blunt, I don't like the looks of it. There is nothing conventional about the exposed joinery, panels, nor rails and stiles. A rare few can come up with an effective new design for something conventional, for example the Maloof rocking chair, but most of us can't.

There is going to be a pile of money in this project for it to not turn out looking attractive (which I am aware is in the eye of the beholder).

Re: 3-Way Joint

#14

Re: easy fix... and a risky opinion

Rob Scrimgeour

Thanks for your input Bill, and I appreciate your point of view - my client is German and is very fond of a "straight and square" look. The effect we are aiming at is similar to this "Hansen" design. The island unit will come later.


Re: 3-Way Joint

#15

Sliding Dovetails

charlie belden

Sliding dovetails for the top corners would work. A router with fence and two router bits (straight & dovetail) would work. And since the drawer unit is a slip in, it'll hide the necessary overcut for the lower joints - or you could inlay a patch.

TWO routers, one for each bit, would be preferable since getting the "show faces" flush is critical with this design. A MicroFence on the router with the dovetail bit would let you "dial things in" very precisely - both the distance from the "show face" as well as the fit of the sliding dovetail joint (this is one joint you DO NOT want to "beat to fit". You'll find a thousand uses for the MicroFence - especially if you do inlay work. Add the trim router precision router base and you've got one hell of a versatile system.

About those drawer pulls - they make wonderful DUST & CRUD Collectors, especially in a kitchen. And all those sharp corners - the pose two problems - they hurt when you bump into them - and they ding really easily. And any ding will show - glaringly. A small roundover or bevel solves those problems without being too obvious.

The real challenge of this design it the Box In A Box thing. Even if everything is straight and square, fitting a box this big into the outer box requires more than a fair amount of precision. A Cock Bead - as an integral part of the outer "box" would simplify things since it's easier to fit a drawer than to fit a box inside a box. Has the advantage of adding more strength to the outer box as well.

Re: 3-Way Joint

#16

Re: 3-Way Joint

David Hay Denver

One thing to consider is that the joint for the front and back rail doesn't necessarily have to join into vertical post. You could make the front and back rail extra wide, or glue on a block at each end that contains the joinery.

What I'm trying to say is that, if you make the ends of front and back rail extra wide, you could make a tenon that goes into the body of the front-to-back rail, rather than through the corner of the post and the tenon of the front-to-back rail.

David

Re: 3-Way Joint

#17

Objection mostly withdrawn

Bill Tindall

The stuff in the photograph is attractive though I would use a slightly smaller post. In the photo there are no "shelves" for dirt to accumulate.

The drawers will be a problem in a kitchen that is used. Over time the hand hold cut-outs will become finger grunge stained.

Re: 3-Way Joint

#18

flummoxed

Bill Tindall

On the web site look at the maple dining table leg joinery. What ever joint they are using for these corners they believe is sufficient to use on a full length leg with no additional visible support in the form of a stretcher or whatever. The only thing I can think of is that they are using a robust corner brace to lock the table aprons together and to the leg. This joinery would then carry over to the cabinets that have more support in the form of panels that the drawers hang from. Is it possible that one of the through tenons is phony such that there could be a hidden tenon on the other apron piece? They brag about tenons on the web site so it is a good guess that only tenons are used, somehow, on these corners.

The legs are not in fact as fat as they seem in your posted picture as there is a panel edge showing along most of their length.

These look to be very high quality cabinets so I would be confident in copying them. However I would like to crawl under a table to confirm the apron to leg joinery. You might post the question, "has anyone ever seen a Hansen piece" and get them to crawl under it to investigate.

Also note that in your drawing you have a horizontal piece running across the bottom of the panel which will be a dust catcher and in my mind doesn't look good. The Hansens do not have this feature.

Re: 3-Way Joint

#19

I'll bet that's it

Bill Tindall

Not an extra wide rail but separate pieces behind the rail that shows mortised into the massive top rail along the sides. So the rail that shows ( which could be just 3/4" lumber) is just for show and could be fastened in with a shallow M&T. Behind it is the real structural member M&T into the side rail behind the leg.

Re: 3-Way Joint

#20

Re: I'll bet that's it

Rob Scrimgeour

Thanks Bill and Dave - I reckon I need to re-design accordingly. Thanks also for pointing out the unnecessary lower side rail - I hadn't given that part much thought yet, just concentrating on the 3-way corners. I will also reduce the thickness of the posts a bit. I will be starting this job in January, and thanks to everyone's input, I feel a lot more confident in doing a good job.