Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Electrical Question

Posts

Electrical Question

#1

Electrical Question

Keith Inscho

Getting a new dust collector. 1 1/2 horse, 110/220, prewired for 110 with a 14g cord. The spec calls for a 30 amp breaker. Is 12g wire heavy enough for a 75' run or should I put in 10g just to be safe?

Re: Electrical Question

#2

Re: Electrical Question

David Yoho

If you plan to fuse the circuit at 30 amps, you must use #10 wire no matter what. That said, I use my 1 1/2 HP dust collector on a dedicated 20 amp circuit with #12 wire with no issues.

Re: Electrical Question

#3

Re: Electrical Question

Keith Inscho

The motor rates an 18 amp draw at 110v but specs call for 30amp circuit. After the initial start up shouldn't the draw be quite a bit less? Just seemed like a bit of overkill when the cord the machine comes with is #14.

Re: Electrical Question

#4

Re: Electrical Question

Bill Howatt

There will be a higher startup surge which can last longer with fan loads than starting a table saw because the fan provides a high load on the motor all the time - I am speaking in loose terms, this is not a in-depth analysis.

Then there is likely an electrical rule that says running an 18A load on a 20A circuit it cutting it too close even though it would likely work assuming the starting surge doesn't trip the breaker.

I personally like to keep the current low if possible and given you are 75' from the panel, I'd rewire the motor for 240V and use #12 wire with a 20A breaker. The current draw at 240V would only be 9A. In fact, you could use #14 wire and a 15A breaker. The breakers have to be double breakers for the 240V and you should change the DC plug to the correct one for 240V.

Bill

Re: Electrical Question

#5

Re: Electrical Question

John in NM

Whose "spec" is calling for a 30 amp circuit? How do you know they know what is what?

It is probable that they are following the practice of de-rating by 25%, so for an 18 amp draw you would need a 22.5 amp capacity. The short cord of 14 awg wire works because the circuit sees a total impedance that is the sum of the parts for each individual wire. So you can get away with a short bit of lighter wire if you have a heavier long run and thus keep the overall impedance low. Increasing impedance will increase the current draw, eventually exceeding what the lighter bit of wire can carry. So in using a 14 awg lead, the manufacturer could be following acceptable engineering practices, or they could be cheaping out a bit. Hard to say without doing all the math. Fourteen and 12 awg wires are de-rated a bit anyhow as the authors of the NEC (or whoever started that practice) expect consumers to overload things.

So, to actually answer the question, if you've even made it this far :D....

I would use a 20 amp circuit myself, but I'll probably get piled on for saying it. If you're a compulsive spec oriented type of guy, run a 30 amp circuit. Or get a unit that will run at 220 and avoid the whole mess (half the current you see).

Re: Electrical Question

#6

Step 1- rewire motor to 220

Bill Tindall

then the rest is easy. 12 ga wire and 20 amp breaker. If you can follow directions rewiring to 220 is trivial. If I recall correctly you can't/shouldn't put a 30 amp breaker on 12 ga wire.

Re: Electrical Question

#7

Re: Electrical Question

Dan Donaldson

The issue is that the breaker is based on wire size, not draw. 20 amp is 12 gauge and 30 amp is 10 gauge per code.

Re: Electrical Question

#8

Re: Electrical Question

Dan Donaldson

I won't pile on because I would probably use a 20 amp also. The only concern I would have is the 75'. That might cause too much loss, do not have the figures at hand to calculate.

Re: Electrical Question

#9

Yeah, hard to say without running the numbers...

John in NM

I tend to think it would be ok as a dedicated circuit, but I would definitely do the calculation rather than use a look up table. Best thing in the pocket ref book is that formula :D

I also was writing my post when Bill wrote his above it. The difference in motor loading between a DC and say table saw is definitely something to consider and look into.

Bottom line though, running it at 220 just makes so much more sense, as many have pointed out.

Re: Electrical Question

#10

Re: Electrical Question *LINK*

Keith Inscho

My info is based on Grizzly's web site. I would hope they know what is what, but you can never tell.

They call for a 15 amp circuit for 240, would it then be safe to assume I would need #14-3WG for this?


Grizzly Spec Sheet

Re: Electrical Question

#11

Re: Electrical Question

John in NM

14-2 WG is what you need if you go the 220 route.

Re: Electrical Question

#12

Thanks Everyone! 220 it is!

Keith Inscho

Re: Electrical Question

#13

Almost forgot!

John in NM

Mark the white wire on the 14-2 with black tape or some black heat shrink to denote a hot rather than common.

Re: Electrical Question

#14

Re: Thanks Everyone! 220 it is!

FredD

Becasue you have a long wire run , the larger conductors in #12 AWG will give you less heat caused by resistance and less of a voltage drop.

That said ,I have never seen a motor wired for 240 , using 14 AWG regardless of the run.

In Residential construction # 14 AWG was always used for lightning circuits, any 240 V. appliance in that field requires a dedicated circuit, so play safe don't skimp on wire size purely for economic reasons.

FredD

Re: Electrical Question

#15

good point

Bill Tindall

be rid of that 14 ga motor cord. I have many 1-2 HP 220V motors on 12 ga wire. Works for me.

Re: Electrical Question

#16

No worries....

John in NM

I calculate the voltage drop on 14 awg at 220V to be 8.5V, or about 4%, well within the 5% spec for branch circuits. Of course, I'm not an engineer or electrician, and this is not meant to sway Keith's decision, its just the reasoning behind what I would choose to do myself. The cost difference between 12 and 14 awg is probably not a big deal anyhow, if I were in the store looking at two rolls, I might just spend an extra $10 on the 12 awg so that I wouldn't have to rewire if I later upgraded to a larger machine on that circuit.

The reason that the manufacturer can get away with the 14 awg cord is that the total voltage drop is the sum of the drops over individual pieces of wire. So by recommending a huge capacity circuit, they've covered all their bases and can safely use thinner wire even if the end user is putting it on a fairly long branch.

For example, say that the plug was 150 feet from the panel (a 300' circuit) and you ran 10 awg wire for the circuit, and the machine has a 6' 14 awg cord. You'd get a total voltage drop of only 3.3% over the whole mess. The calculated drop over the lighter cord in this case is one tenth of the drop over the rest of the circuit - and that's why manufacturers do it this way - they can and it saves them money.