Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Heartpine table- what to use for finish?

Posts

Heartpine table- what to use for finish?

#1

Heartpine table- what to use for finish?

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

I'm making a 10' x 40" heart pine table. This will be a daily user table in the kitchen.

Wood supplier suggests tung oil. What would you choose?

Henry

Re: Heartpine table- what to use for finish?

#2

JL

Re: Heartpine table- what to use for finish?

JL

What's wrong with tung oil?

I like the look of an oiled finish. Another choice would be boiled linseed oil.

Re: Heartpine table- what to use for finish?

#3

Re: Heartpine table- what to use for finish?

Steve Schoene

If by tung oil pure tung oil is meant, then no. Pure oils, tung or linseed, provide very little protection. If you want the minimalist appearance of the "oil" finish, then a mix of oil and varnish would be more effective, albeit still not what I would call protective. Varnish provides more protection and stands up to household cleaners to a greater extent. Still with pine, don't expect it to remain pristine. No finish makes it harder, so it will still get dings.

Re: Heartpine table- what to use for finish?

#4

Re: Heartpine table- what to use for finish?

Nat Robison

If this will be in daily use, I think you have to top it with some sort of poly. I have a spar varnish on a daily-used pine kitchen table and it's holding up OK but the table will take some abuse as someone earlier noted so you should probably plan on re-topping every few years depending on the level of wear you're comfortable with.

Re: Heartpine table- what to use for finish?

#5

Re: Heartpine table- what to use for finish?

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Henry,

If its going to be a "worker" table, I would advise you not to employ tung oil as the finish. I would go with a polyurethane for durability. I mix poly with naptha in equal measure and apply with a soft cloth or high quality paper towel. It dries fairly fast and leaves no bubbles. For a "worker" table, I would wipe on six to eight coats, rubbing out after every third coat according to what I saw and felt. I'd also use a high gloss poly, and then rub out with 4/0 steel wool to minimize any excessive shine. Pine won't absorb the punishment you'd expect of other materials, so you might have to refinish the table every few years.

George

Re: Heartpine table- what to use for finish?

#6

Clint Searl

Re: Heartpine table- what to use for finish?

Clint Searl

For a finish that's resistant to what's likely to happen to a table top, consider a waterborne poly floor finish such as Varathane or Bona Mega. And the next time a guest wants to dance on the table, it won't get messed up.

Clint

Re: Heartpine table- what to use for finish?

#7

no toung oil  for me

del schisler

Re: Heartpine table- what to use for finish?

#8

Re: Heart Pine table- what to use for finish?

Barry Irby

I can't offer much help on the finish, but I have a hunt table i made form heart pine. Some of the teams I saw were nearly pitch ;pine or Light-a-wood (SP?). My warning to you is that I sanded mine with my Performax. The top is only about four feet long and I could get it about half way through the Sande and the abrasive was completely clogged. I spent a LOT of time soaking sanding strips in Simple Green . Might be a good Idea to consider using a scraper.

I finished mine with Shellac and its beautiful, but it might not be the best finish for a working table.

Re: Heartpine table- what to use for finish?

#9

Re: Heartpine table- what to use for finish?

Blue

use nothin', after a few years, maybe sand it a little, then put a safe mixture on it.

Re: Heartpine table- what to use for finish?

#10

Re: Heartpine table- what to use for finish?

Sgian Dubh

As Blue mentioned, consider applying no finish at all. If you do that you let it get as manky as you can stand and give it a scrub down with a stiff brush, hot water and either vinegar and/or some salt. This raises the grain of course, so you leave it to dry and knock back the fuzz with a bit of abrasive paper, usually about 150 or 180 grit.

Actually, the no finish finish is very traditional. Kitchen tables in large country houses where there were lots of staff, and even small farm worker's houses, were quite commonly made of pine and scrubbed much as already described.

Of course, this may not suit your aesthetic tastes, and the unfinished and scrubbed style probably really is best suited to stone, vinyl or lino floors, etc. If that's the case and you want a finish that's tough, forget pure tung oil, and go for a polyurethane varnish, or perhaps one of the water based floor finishes, assuming you don't have spray facilities and equipment. Both finishes will eventualy give out and you'll need to strip and refinish to effect a repair. It's either that or just let the dings and scrapes contribute to the, er, patina. Slainte.

Re: Heartpine table- what to use for finish?

#11

Re: Heartpine table- what to use for finish?

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

Thanks for the replies. Thought provoking.

I had never before considered "no finish" a choice for a kitchen table.

If it were to be mine, I'd likely use an easily renewable oil. However this is to go off to someone else's house and I doubt they want to call me back every year or two to renew the finish. I'll likely end up with a tough film forming finish and only have to refinish periodically.

Henry