Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Solid wood panel question

Posts

Solid wood panel question

#1

Solid wood panel question

Wayland

Hi Everyone-

I'm building a Murphy bed around a hardware kit that I bought online. The directions that came with the kit call for a plywood face (which becomes the bottom of the bed when it's opened) that is glued to a solid-wood frame that also has plywood on the other side to support the mattress. The whole bed-platform assembly is structurally similar to a hollow-core door (which inspired my previous posting about using such a door for the bed in the first place). Anyway, I'm now thinking I'll use solid wood for the front panel instead of plywood (just because I have a lot of it).

My question: should I glue the solid wood panel to the frame as per the directions, or should I just screw it so the panel has the chance to move a little, just like a table top against its apron? BTW, the plywood on the other side (the one against the mattress) has to be screwed, to allow access to some hardware that's on the inside. So if I screw-only, I will not have either side glued.

Thanks

Wayland

Re: Solid wood panel question

#2

Re: Solid wood panel question

Jesse Cloud

Interesting question. Here are some thoughts:

- I built from a kit several years ago. There was a support phone number in the manual. They were incredibly helpful and knowledgeable. If you have a number for support give these guys a try.

- If you are doing a hardwood panel, break it down into two or more panels in the movement direction. One big panel will move a lot. I have a 40 inch tabletop that moves about 1/4 inch annually. You can cover up the gaps with trim.

- You can glue the middle of a panel and force the movement to go from the middle to the edges.

- I think screws will provide as much support as a glued joint would, but the whole the will be a little looser and noisier - which can be a problem for a bed (nuff said ;) ) .

Keep the panel the same thickness as the plywood the design calls for. The functioning of the bed depends on correct thickness of the assembly - including mattress. When in use, take out pillows and bulky quilts, etc. If you overstuff it, at best it won't close, at worse it will break. I broke my light switch when the BIL forced it shut with pillows in it.

This is a fun project. Hope you enjoy it!

Re: Solid wood panel question

#3

Re: Solid wood panel question

Bill Earl

If it is structurally similar to a hollow core door, then the face panel is structural. It will provide rigidity to the assembly because it is glued around the perimiter. A solid wood face panel needs room to expand, so it can't be glued around the perimiter.

Multiple smaller panels might work, because the rails & stiles will add some rigidity to the structure.

Re: Solid wood panel question

#4

Clint Searl

No problema

Clint Searl

Keep the boards to about 6" wide and loose lap them with around 1/16" gap between adjacent boards. Double pin each board top and bottom with 2" between pins. The boards on the perimeter can be firmly attached on the outsides and in a couple inches top and bottom. Put a molding around the whole thing to hide the attachments.

Clint

Re: Solid wood panel question

#5

Concur, entirely on theoretical grounds

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

that is, no experience.

The stresses on a bed that folds up into the wall have got to be serious and in several directions. I would talk with the factory before proceeding with solid wood, even with frame and panel construction using solid panels.

If your concern is with the appearance of a huge plywood panel looming over the room when the bed's closed, you might consider veneer; or veneer with applied molding. Molding applied over plywood never looks right because you can see the grain traveling from "panel" to "panel." But if you veneered panels on, then covered them with molding, you might be able to face true frame and panel pretty well.

Re: Solid wood panel question

#6

Re: Solid wood panel question

FredD

I have done a couple of these in the past and by your using solid wood boards , you lose the structural strength of the plywood which is one of the reasons plywood is recommended for the front panel and in addition to that , if your bed comes with gas struts for lifters , you may find you have overloaded their lift capacity and you would need to get stronger struts.

FredD

Re: Solid wood panel question

#7

Clint Searl

Re: Solid wood panel question

Clint Searl

I can't comment on the struts, but but any loss in strenght, which is speculative at best, is incidentally superfluous.

Clint

Re: Solid wood panel question

#8

Re: Solid wood panel question

FredD

Clint , the strength I was referring to was the very high resistance to racking that plywood has , while in the case of individual boards that your trying to estimate the ebb and flow of has next to none, but depending on the wood , like Oak for instance , are much heavier then the plywood.

But Wayland can do as he wishes or follow the manufacture's recommendation for the front panel .

I suspect if he felt entirely comfortable with the solid wood boards approach , we wouldn't have anything to argue about ......

FredD