Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Tenon problem. Why does this happen

Posts

Tenon problem. Why does this happen

#1

Tenon problem.  Why does this happen

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I was cutting tenons on a few table aprons. The surface around the shoulders is not consistent. Hopefully you see what I am talking about in the pictures below. I've had this happen in the past, not sure why.

Any ideas on why. I will need to trim off a hair to get them to sit flush in the mortises. Not sure of the best approach to correct and salvage these aprons. Taking a little off and making them (a tad bit) shorter is not a problem.

I did these tenons on the table saw. I used my Freud stacked dado set. I had the height set based on scrap and a nice fit to the mortises. I had a block clamped to the rip fence so the piece was not against the rip fence while being cut. I did all the pieces this way. Nothing moved. The only thing that moved was the blade height for the top and bottom shoulders.

Oh, and I believe the rip fence is parallel to the blade, the mitre gauge is square, and the blade is square to the table.

One of the aprons came out fine, two did not.

Thanks for any suggestion/help.

#1


#2


Re: Tenon problem. Why does this happen

#2

Re: Tenon problem.  Why does this happen

Barry Irby

A couple of thoughts.

You are not clamping the aprons to the miter gauge and they are creeping a little.

The end of the apron was not square and as you cut the shoulders, it cuts away the long point and changes your reference point. (My best guess.)

Or, your saw is not set up as accurately as you think.

Re: Tenon problem. Why does this happen

#3

Re: Tenon problem.  Why does this happen

Neal in San Jose

Another guess is that your miter gage is not tight in the slot, and it is moving back and forth a little. Do you have some way to tighten up your miter gage or, better yet, a sled?

Re: Tenon problem. Why does this happen

#4

Re: Tenon problem.  Why does this happen

Jim Toews - Walla Walla, WA

Seems an easy way to fix it is to knife a line around the piece at the level of the greatest discrepancy and pare it to that line with a chisel. You would need to pare the same amount off the tenon on the apron opposite this one to keep the table square. DAMHIKT.

To prevent the problem you might want to check your set-up for square, and clamp the parts to you miter gauge to prevent creep.

Cheers!

Jim

Re: Tenon problem. Why does this happen

#5

and

Bruce, a MN Galoot

the face of the fence is not vertically square to the table surface.

Re: Tenon problem. Why does this happen

#6

I agree with Barry's second suggestion...

John in NM

"The end of the apron was not square and as you cut the shoulders, it cuts away the long point and changes your reference point. (My best guess.) "

I've had the same problem often enough, not a huge problem to cope with, but annoying. I've seen it as less of a problem when cutting all the shoulders first, then making the cheek cuts. If the rail end is not square you still get the effect, but to a lesser degree.

Re: Tenon problem. Why does this happen

#7

Re: and

David Hay Denver

Or the block you have clamped to the fence doesn't have parallel faces. (e.g. the face of the block is not square to the table)

David

Re: Tenon problem. Why does this happen

#8

Check if the stock is Four Square

charlie belden

A cabinet maker friend gave me a sage piece of woodworking advice

You CAN'T maker rectangular furniture out of trapezoidal parts.

Stock prep is where everything else comes from. Join a face, square and edge, plane the face opposite the joined face, rip the unworked edge - and you get Four Square stock - top and bottom faces flat and parallel, edges straight and square to the faces. Cross cut an end square and then cross cut to length - square.

Check your parts with a square and a straight edge

Re: Tenon problem. Why does this happen

#9

Re: Tenon problem.  Why does this happen

FredD

By looking at the end of the tenon in the picture , one can see that your first shoulder cut tapered because the Apron moved, which means to me that the cut was farthest in at first and either the end of the Apron is not square or it moved as you completed the cut, giving the ledge effect.

Check your Miter gauge setup and the apron stock for square , if necessary glue a strip of fine sandpaper on a sacrificial fence for the miter gauge to eliminate creep and hold the stock against the rip fence all the way thought the cut.

I seldom run into problems cutting Tenons with a sharp Dado set and don't use a cut wider then a 1/2 inch and run the first cut at the shoulder all the way around the stock before cutting out the rest of the Tenon ,doing the shoulder cut first, keeps wood on both sides of the cut which is the only cut critical and helps to eliminate creep, the rest just cleans up the Tenon.

Therefore once you have the depth and distance established for the length and thickness of the Tenon , that's all you need, don't move the rip fence again until your done with the all of the Tenons that size.

This means pay close attention to the speed of the crosscut and positive pressure against the rip fence for a clean Tenon.

One last thing, I see the end of the Tenon is chipped out , this can be avoided by making your second cut on the end of the Tenon and work back toward the Shoulder cut.

Doing the setup on a piece cut from the Apron stock will give you best results.

FredD

Re: Tenon problem. Why does this happen

#10

There are lots of possibilities,

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

and it may help if you gave more information, like what kind of saw, and fence.

Was the block clamped to the fence in contact with the table top? If so, a bit of sawdust could have kept the end from butting up tight, on that closest long side. Fences can move due to different amounts of pressure, etc.

I usually try to clamp the indexing block above the table, so it indexes only from the center of the tenon.

Besides the problem that you ask about, it appears that there is a good bit of grain run-out in that tenon, which is not a good thing. It will break from a lot less pressure than one with the grain running straight down the board. I could be wrong though, due to the quality of the pic, and apologize if I am wrong and know better.

Re: Tenon problem. Why does this happen

#11

a far easier way to get good results

Bruce, a MN Galoot

is to use a sliding table or sled on your table saw and a stop block that is absolutely square in both directions - face and edge. It is much, much easier to hold a work piece motionless on a sled than it is on against a miter gauge, no matter how good the gauge is.

Re: Tenon problem. Why does this happen

#12

and furthermore,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I'd be willing to bet that every one of us who answered this question BTDT and got the T-shirt. :D

Re: Tenon problem. Why does this happen

#13

And what does the T-shirt say on it?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Re: Tenon problem. Why does this happen

#14

common problem, don't do it that way

Bill Tindall

I was never successful in doing what your are trying to do. Got the same result. For perfect fitting tenons scribe the depth of the tenon with a marking gauge. By whatever means you find handy remove waste to as close to the shoulder line as you can. With chisel pare to line. Result is perfect shoulders.

What I do, as I learned in Headley shop and most recently from Steve Hamilton in the class they taught here: Cut cheeks of tenon (tenon thickness) by holding piece vertical on table saw (using a tenon jig or a tall fence and push piece, Steve just free-hands it). Trim to within a whisker of scribe line on band saw. With one cut of chisel pare to scribe line.You can undercut the chisel cut a tiny amount so that the outside of the shoulder butts first. Fast and reliable and that is how they do it for the stuff they build.

Re: Tenon problem. Why does this happen

#15

"How is my tablesaw not set up right?"

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Let me count the ways!

Re: Tenon problem. Why does this happen

#16

Re: Tenon problem.  Why does this happen

paul in AZ

I cut the shoulders on my miter saw with a stop block for tenon length before I cut the tenon itself either by hand or on the bandsaw. The only thing to be careful of is the setting for depth of cut. The shoulders come out even on all 4 sides as long as the stop block doesn't change position.

Re: Tenon problem. Why does this happen

#17

Re: Check if the stock is Four Square

Allan A Campbell

This problem used to drive me crazy. Charlie has the answer. If you refrence off the two surfaces made true and perpendicular by your jointer (the reference face and reference edge) your cuts will line up.(assuming your tablesaw is set up accurately.) If you reference the cuts off the other face or edge, errors compound and the cuts don't align. For a good explanation and drawings see The Essential Woodworker by Ronert Wearing on pages 42 and 43 under "squaring."

Hope this helps.

Re: Tenon problem. Why does this happen

#18

Re: Check if the stock is Four Square *LINK*

charlie belden

Reference Face, Reference Edge and Reference End - you need to use two to locate anything on the other.

On the following link, scroll down to the bottom - "How To & Other Stuff" and click on STOCK PREP and when you're done with that go back and click on "Mortise and Tenon Primer". Should answer your "why question".


In "HOW TO & Other Stuff

Re: Tenon problem. Why does this happen

#19

Re: fixed link Check if the stock is Four Square  *LINK*

Bob Entwisle in NJ


http://web.hypersurf.com/~charlie2/AlternateMainMenu.html

Re: Tenon problem. Why does this happen

#20

Re: Tenon problem.  Why does this happen

FredD

I agree Paul and it is even faster , less stress and bending over , doing it on a table saw with a miter gauge and sacrificial fence , with maybe a piece of sand paper glued to it , if you have trouble holding the work with just your finger pressure.

Properly set with the rip fence for a stop block , I routinely cut oops and gobs of Tenons with a dado set , sometimes I stand the piece on end and do the cheek cuts , but for dead on accurate cuts , laying flat on the saw is the way to go and I never touch a handsaw, or a chisel and leave my lucky tee shirt for bowling and get Tenons that slide together with just hand pressure and a whoosh of air.

I won't lie to you and say this is a automatic operation , like most operations in woodwork , it takes practice.

FredD

Re: Tenon problem. Why does this happen

#21

Re: Tenon problem.  Why does this happen

Jim Dillon

Joe,

Late to the parade, but I come down on the side of Charlie and Allen. When I have had this happen, it usually turns out that the stock was not as perfectly squared as I thought it was. And, as others have suggested, secure clamping/holding is also mandatory. My 2 cents.

Jim

Re: Tenon problem. Why does this happen

#22

My Bad - You're Good - Thanks

charlie belden

Re: Tenon problem. Why does this happen

#23

Keith Tompkins

Re: Tenon problem.  Why does this happen

Keith Tompkins

Hi Joe, I don't often post on the flat side, but I suspect your stock is tapered....it will measure "square' from one edge, but not the other. Easy to tell, measure the width of the piece at one end, then the other.

If seen fence deflection cause this as well, esp. if you are using the miter-gauge in combination with the fence. clamp a piece of wood behind the tail-end of the fence to stop movement.

Re: Tenon problem. Why does this happen

#24

Re: Tenon problem.  Why does this happen

Jim Dillon

Another take on this is that, even if the stock was well prepared and your TS technique superb, the stock "equilibrated" a tad after you prepared it. That is, it twisted or cupped a smidgen (engineering term :) ) before you had a chance to cut the tenons. I've sometimes suspected this after cutting a set of tenons on identical stock with no problems, then suddenly had a bad one. Sure, it could have been me losing focus on what I was doing (seems to happen more often with age >( ), but I wonder... . Anyway, more food for thought.

Jim

Re: Tenon problem. Why does this happen

#25

Re: Tenon problem.  Why does this happen

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks everybody who replied with suggestions and so on.

I rechecked everything. My stock and everything was/is square. I think what might have happened is a little slop in my miter gauge caused the problem.

I decided to take the time and (remake) a crosscut sled. After doing that, and checking and rechecking (repeatedly) for square, I was able to clean up the shoulders and it all looks good now.

Thank you.

Joe