Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

MDF

Posts

MDF

#1

MDF

FredD

Eletter from FWW today;

Question, "Can MDF furniture ever be fine ?"

FredD

Re: MDF

#2

Put me down for a "No" vote.

John Pappas

Re: MDF

#3

Clint Searl

Depends on one's definition of "fine"

Clint Searl

Re: MDF

#4

David Barnett

How I see it

David Barnett

Whether or not a material is fine depends on how it is used, whether structurally sound and aesthetically, historically, or stylistically appropriate. Standards of convention, perception and context matter, though, and MDF's history in mass-produced and lower quality furniture reinforces its low regard. I use it sparingly and only as a substrate: speaker cabinets, lamps, sometimes in panels with wood edges -- nothing I'd likely call fine.

But materials of low strength and low intrinsic value are often employed in successful and novel designs. Andrew Crawford uses MDF as a substrate in his highly-regarded veneered boxes, for example. While not always to my taste, I consider his work very fine indeed.

I mostly make jewelry in 22k gold. Others use less costly materials but nevertheless make jewelry that I consider ever-so fine. While I'm not a materials snob in my personal tastes and things I make for my own use, marketing requires an altogether different approach, in my thinking.

Anyway, on the MDF, generally, on balance, I'd tend to agree with John Pappas and say no. But you might find an exception.

Re: MDF

#5

Re: MDF

Bill Tindall

If it is made with MDF I would call it a jig or mock-up, not furniture.

Re: MDF

#6

Not Now, Maybe In 20 Years

glh17

Re: MDF

#7

Re: MDF

Jesse Cloud

Mostly no, but there are a some times when MDF is appropriate. In my opinion, MDF is the best substrate for veneer. So a very fine piece of furniture could have a frame and panel door where the panel is mdf covered with very fine veneer. There are a few instances, in cabinetry mainly, where one would use bending ply over a skeleton of mdf to make a graceful curved surface.

But mdf should never been seen or used structurally.

On the other hand, I seldom make a piece of fine furniture without a form, pattern or jig made from mdf. ;)

Re: MDF

#8

Sure it can ...

David Yoho

but only if it's covered in a fine veneer!!

Re: MDF

#9

Clint Searl

But a real snob...

Clint Searl

...might opine that veneer is faux, and a "fine" piece must be made of solid wood only. Diff'rent strokes for diff'rent folks.

Clint

Re: MDF

#10

Clint Searl

Who has the final word on "fine"?

Clint Searl

Re: MDF

#11

Its a narrow window...

John in NM

As others have pointed out, it certainly can if used to take advantage of its strengths and limit its weaknesses - which basically leaves you with a veneer substrate :D

A fine design could certainly be executed solely in MDF, but due to its wonderfully poor durability, I doubt any of us would call this theoretical piece fine furniture.

Re: MDF

#12

Ellis Walentine

Heckuva question

Ellis Walentine

Furniture is designed. If one of the design conditions is that the piece be "fine," then you need a definition of "fine" before you can design and build something that meets the criteria you set. In the real world, the customer dictates the definitions, so it's a good idea to know who the customer is and what they expect from you.

Personally, I've often used MDF in high-end built-ins and freestanding furniture -- mostly as substrate for veneered door or table panels that needed to be stable and flat. I once built an entire bedroom suite almost entirely of MDF -- a bed, dressers and night tables that were sprayed gloss white with some insanely expensive catalyzed color-and-topcoat system and rubbed out to a high polish finish. Unless they have a flood in their 2nd floor bedroom, I'm confident the MDF will continue to satisfy the design criteria for a long time. Actually, MDF isn't a go-to material for me unless I feel it is the best solution. If I had built that set of solid wood, the finish would eventually craze and crack because of wood movement.

So, as usual, it comes down to design intent and execution.

Ellis

Re: MDF

#13

Re: Heckuva question

Bill Howatt

It's interesting how so many WWers are ready to trash things like MDF and particle board and give the impression that real wood is just perfect where in fact it has its own set of weaknesses.

You gave the balanced view.

Bill

Re: MDF

#14

Re: Heckuva question

FredD

The question was a verbatim quote of FWW's lead in for today, definitely not mine , but I was interested in what I thought would attract a wide range of answers and it did.

Beyond that , I narrowly avoided agreeing to fix a Shrunk which is a German Kitchen cabinet that goes from house to house and acts as the Kitchen cabinets, I hesitated and said I would have to see it first , lucky me.

When I got to the house the movers were just leaving and agreed to pay whatever the cost of repair.

It was a beautiful ,tall and wide Veneered cabinet which was a first class job , until the movers dropped it , when it's tremendous weight over powered them carrying it across the lawn and it just exploded , yup you guessed it , MDF 3/4" thick and completely destroyed.

The lady was married to a Army officer and they had bought it in Germany , she was in tears and all I could tell her , was I could make a similar one from wood and Veneered Plywood, but it would be expensive.

I couldn't do it by the time she needed one , so I managed to avoid a job I didn't really feel good about doing.

Never have used the stuff except for closet shelves and shoe cabinets and like that , that were fixed in place permanently and painted by someone else .

FredD

Re: MDF

#15

Re: Heckuva question

Robert R. Clough

I agree it "can" be used, but . . . . I admit it, I am a snob -brought up that way about houses and furniture (and grammar!!!) And I do prefer solid wood, non veneer.

However, with the FWW question, yes it can be a fine piece. But, as MDF is heavy w/no intrinsic strength I would not use it. Tindall is correct in that solid wood has problems also. However, a top quality veneer over a substrate of solid wood, perhaps the same species, of excellent design and construction, is definitely "fine". Europeans have used this process for generations with excellent results.

Re: MDF

#16

Re: MDF - Yes - but not woodworking

ThomD

First off, I once bought a sheet of MDF that was made with "Green" glue. Every other type of MDF that smells like mushrooms every time you turn the heat on etc... Is just beneath contempt.

That out of the way. I have an example. I built my wife a spinning wheel. If you listen to wives who spin they all crouch in fear that their woodworking husbands (for the most part) will get the whim to build them a wheel. They rightly believe that this is a bit as if Danica Patrick had a husband who built horse drawn coaches, and decided he should take a shot at making her next Indy car. Aware of these concerns, I decided to make sure the wheel I built was both Fine and a great wheel. During my research I came across the fact that some of the better wheels are made of MDF. They have greater weight than other wood products, do not vary dimensionally at all, and the shape is such that the material is also durable in this application. Really MDF isn't ugly or anything, steel is also a pretty homogeneous material of drab colour. It is up to the craftsman to make it look good when used for hinges or whatever .

A secondary aspect would be to ask whether working MDF is woodworking. There I would say no. MDF is a composite material of which wood is only a part. So working MDF could be Fine, but not Fine Woodworking.

Re: MDF

#17

Re: Heckuva question - Wrong, wrong, wrong...

ThomD

"In the real world, the customer dictates the definitions, so it's a good idea to know who the customer is and what they expect from you."

In the real world "ironic" is synonymous with coincidental. So I'm not letting that influence me. Fine Woodworking, if it is/was anything, is by definition not driven by the customer at all, except where use is concerned. He has the right to say he wants a chair, possibly that it needs to be comfortable, maybe a rocker. I don't see Maloof having let the customer decide much else. Which is why, for the most part, the world has little use for the stuff.

"Personally, I've often used MDF in high-end built-ins and freestanding furniture -- ... If I had built that set of solid wood, the finish would eventually craze and crack because of wood movement."

So on what basis other than cost would you justify using MDF over the highest end plywood? Not fine furniture- Or I am about to learn something about mdf I didn't know.

Re: MDF

#18

Ellis Walentine

Plywood vs MDF

Ellis Walentine

Cost may or may not be a factor, but I wouldn't trade function or longevity for cost voluntarily. In my opinion, high-end plywood, or any other kind of plywood, isn't suitable for painting (I don't trust it to not telegraph through the finish -- maybe I'm wrong) so I used MDF. I have also used MDF for a veneer substrate because it is flatter than 90% of the plywood I've used, and it will likely stay that way longer. To me, it has legitimate uses, despite its weight and outgassing and hygroscopic qualities, and the definition of fine furniture shouldn't be so categorical as to include only solid wood or "high-end" plywood, which has its own outgassing and quality control issues.

Regarding woodworking, I believe that we are, first and foremost, designers and makers of things. Woodworking is probably the biggest part of that for most of us. But, when it comes to the product of our mind and hands, it is more important that we solve the design problem in the best way possible, whether it involves other materials or technologies other than just cutting, joining and finishing wood -- unless the design problem is "Make this thing using only wood." That may or may not solve the problem in the best way.

Ellis

Re: MDF

#19

Re: Plywood vs MDF

FredD

Ellis , I have made many a set of "Paint grade" cabinets using"Paint grade Birch" plywood and telegraphing grain through the paint never was a problem.

Paint properly prepped and sprayed by a experienced Painter looked like the finish was on sheet metal

On the other hand when Doug Fir ply was used for a substrate for counters (before PB came along) if you used White Formica with out any other color or pattern in it , you could see the D.F. grain the next day.

FredD