Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Another Shaker Chair Question

Posts

Another Shaker Chair Question

#1

Another Shaker Chair Question

Thomas Norton

I have another question for those who have built from a kit or started from scratch a Shaker Chair. I was reading a Thos. Moser book and it showed the leg/rung joint and he "pinned" the joint with a 1/8" pin.

Did you guys do anything to the joints when you built your chairs?

My wife and I are going to take a quick trip up to Shaker Workshop in a few weeks and check out the different chairs before I order. Since I am remoldeling the LR &DR it is the time to replace the 35 year old dark pine Ethan Allen table and chairs.

Re: Another Shaker Chair Question

#2

Re: Another Shaker Chair Question

John McGaw

I have not done so. The back leg/slat assembly in the Shaker Workshop kits comes pre-assembled (I presume to assure square assembly of the most critical portion) and the top slat is pinned to the legs in the manner you describe. When you get to the lower part of the chair the tension of a properly-woven tape seat effectively places the whole chair inside a permanent clamp that, combined with modern glue, seems destined to prevent any damage there. I guess that one could pin other joints in one of the kit chairs but I don't think that much would be gained by doing so.

Re: Another Shaker Chair Question

#3

Re: Another Shaker Chair Question

doug f, san clemente, ca

Thomas - I have built 2, 3 and 4 slat ladderbacks from scratch and have not pinned any of the joints. As noted above, the seat weaving, which must be really, really tight, functions as an excellent clamp to hold the entire chair together. If you joints are well made and glued, pins would be redundant and probably unnecessary. My chairs have gotten a lot of use and are holding up rather well.

It's really a fun project and well worth the time.

Doug

Re: Another Shaker Chair Question

#4

Re: Another Shaker Chair Question

ThomD

Pins are a bad idea, they will just increase any damage that might occur if the joint fails. If you want to know how to minimize joint failure read all the John Alexander stuff, or use epoxy.

Re: Another Shaker Chair Question

#5

Re: Another Shaker Chair Question

Larry Barrett

I sent this thread to Jennie Alexander, who asked me to post this response:

Jennie Alexander formerly known as John Alexander reports she has not yet seen yet a pinned original Shaker chair or any traditional post and rung chair with pegged tenons. She has seen:

!. Differential moisture joints where slightly oversized dry tenons are driven into moist posts

2. Glue, mostly in later chairs

3. Interlocking tenons, particularly on seat rungs

She recalls a Sid Ceaser routine where Professor Glockenspiel, a famous Mountain climber, was asked what to do if one fell off a mountain. �Two things,� he answered, �flap your arms (maybe you�ll fly) or scream (so they�ll find your body). �Me?�, he continued, �I�m a flapper and a screamer!�

Alexander says she uses all three joint techniques in every joint. She is a dry-moister, interlocker and gluer. She doubts that pegging would assist. It would oppose the natural seasonal expansion and contraction of the depth of the mortise up and down the tenon throughout the life of the chair. Wood is wonderful, but it never stops moving.