Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Way OT...

Posts

Way OT...

#1

Way OT...

doug f, san clemente, ca

I know this has nothing to do with woodworking, but the range of knowledge and experience on this site is nothing short of amazing, so I'll ask the question.

I have an ICD (those of you with one know what I mean) and I'm trying to find a consensus of opinion on the advisability of passing through the new semi-Xray machines being installed at some airports. My manufacturer, Biotronix, says "No problem, better than magnetic metal detectors." but I'm wondering if anyone has heard differently.

NOTICE: Let's stay away from the politics of the situation. For the last few years I've been very pleased with the efficiency and competency of the TSA. They have a job to do and do it relatively well. What I'm looking for are opinions on the safety of the new devices for a certain group of seasoned citizens.

Moderators: If this is an inappropriate question, I have no qualms seeing it deleted.

Thanks.,

Doug

Re: Way OT...

#2

Re: Way OT...

Howard Norman

This is a case where I would trust the manufacturer of the device.

Re: Way OT...

#3

Re: Way OT...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Assuming ICD is the device that came up about second on the list when I googled that acronym, I personally would be mighty reluctant to take the chance. As emotionally awkward as the physical pat-down may be, that would seem like a safer choice until there's plenty of field experience on what, if any, effects those machines have.

Re: Way OT...

#4

Some are microwave too...

John in NM

That might cause more trouble with the ICD than Xrays would.

Re: Way OT...

#5

Re: Way OT...

Robert R. Clough

Doug, from what I have read on line and in the press, there appear to be several types of scanners in use with varying intensities of radiation. If you could find out the various types, perhaps from the TSA after explaining why you wish the information, then, with the additional information, you could talk to the manufacturer with more confidence.

I worry about that myself simply because I am an atomic soldier who took part, as a guinea pig, in Upshot-Knothole, on 05/08/53, Nevada Test Site Area 5, and got thoroughly radiated. I have as few x-rays now as possible.

Re: Way OT...

#6

Re: Way OT...

glh17

doug,

I had an ICD implanted in June. I've thought about the same thing, but haven't checked with St. Jude Medical, the manufacturer of my ICD. I'd feel comfortable with what the manufacturer says with respect to the device. As I understand it, x-rays are not really a problem, but magnets are. I have a wallet card that I carry so if I'm searched the officer is suppose to move the wand quickly over my ICD. The magnet can stop the pacemaker/defibrillator if it's kept over it too long.

Gary