Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Do we have an English Major?? OT

Posts

Do we have an English Major?? OT

#1

Do we have an English Major??  OT

Barry Irby

Heard a commercial. Woman says "I've worked here for thirty years. That went by quick." Wouldn't it be more proper to say That went by "quickly"?

Re: Do we have an English Major?? OT

#2

Yup.

paul in AZ

Re: Do we have an English Major?? OT

#3

Jim in Burlington Ont.

It Depends

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Was she speaking American or English?

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Re: Do we have an English Major?? OT

#4

Yes

Nat Robison

Re: Do we have an English Major?? OT

#5

I Was An American Major for Awhile

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

But then I turned over a new leaf. :D

George

Re: Do we have an English Major?? OT

#7

Lee Grindinger

She probably eats healthy too.

Lee Grindinger

Adverbs and adjectives are commonly confused.

Re: Do we have an English Major?? OT

#8

Re: Do we have an English Major??  OT

Dave Paine

Quickly is an adverb of time, and so perhaps a better response. The person could also have said "Fast".

American English and UK English are similar, but not the same.

As someone, perhaps Churchhill, stated two countries, divided by a common language.

Re: Do we have an English Major?? OT

#9

At least he's not chicken to talk about it

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Re: Do we have an English Major?? OT

#10

Poor thing

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

She didn't have the benefit of serving under several of my English teachers, who might not have allowed me to make it to adulthood if I was that easily confused about parts of speech. Certainly, I'd never have passed the courses.

I can't remember their names, but I can sure remember and respect their teaching.

Re: Do we have an English Major?? OT

#11

You can't look to commercials for grammar lessons

Yonak

Remember, "Us Tareyton smokers would rather fight than switch" ?

Re: Do we have an English Major?? OT

#12

Re: You can't look to commercials for grammar less

Robert R. Clough

I agree on that. Remember that most everything we read or hear in written for an 8th grader. In any case, grammatical usage tends to follow spoken speech, and spoken speech is easy to follow and understand. I was brought up by a Grammarian!!! Believe me, knowing all of the grammatical rules, all the proper parts of speech, and the "correct" accent is a burden no child should have to carry. If followed slavishly, it can kill a language. A good example of that is what happened to Latin which was a living language until, roughly, the mid 1400s. Unfortunately, the late Medieval and early Renaissance literary people discovered Cicero. If any of you took Latin in school you were taught, most probably Ciceronian Latin instead of Church Latin, the last bastian of "living Latin", which stopped being used recently. Shakespeare uses that in Julius Caesar when he has a character ask what Cicero was saying in a speech to the Senate. The person replied that Cicero had been speaking Greek whereupon his respondent stated that no, he'd been speaking Latin. Well, the man replied, it may have been Latin to you, but it was Greek to me. Ciceronian Latin was highflown and used locutions and pronciations which were unknown to most Romans. (Kickero instead of Cicero)

Re: Do we have an English Major?? OT

#13

Excellent !

Yonak

Excellent, Robert. I especially enjoyed learning that the Latin I took in Jr. High School was Ciceronian Latin, and not commonly-spoken Latin. I wish now I would have known that then so I could have used that argument against my parents who insisted that I took Latin.

I tend to disagree with you, however, when you say we should leave correct grammar sitting on the shelf instead of using it, and opt for "conversational grammar" instead. It breaks my heart when I see people dismembering good grammar (and spelling and punctuation) and desecrating my language.

I understand, however, that languages develop through misuse. I read recently that in the future many of our unique past-tense verbs will disappear due to ignorance and laziness. (Such as, we now say, "We ate dinner." In the future they will say, "We eatted dinner.")

Re: Do we have an English Major?? OT

#14

Won't That

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

be funner tho? ;) ;)

Re: Do we have an English Major?? OT

#15

Advertising gets a pass.  English is

Gary Smyth

not what they're selling. As a pup working on ad copy for American Express I was hoping to get brownie points for researching and writing a paragraph pointing out the shortcomings of new copy that contained statements ending in a preposition like "...what trip are you going on?" and "...who do you want to go with?" I was certain that this would get me praise and put me on the advancement track so I sent upstairs well above my pay level.

What I got back from the VP of of Creative, was a blunt note quoting Winston Churchill. "This is a situation up with which I will not put". Do not place proper grammar in the path of impact.

Never again did I.

Re: Do we have an English Major?? OT

#16

Re: Excellent !

Robert R. Clough

I did not mean that grammar must be forgotten. Not at all! There must be, however, a decent method of teaching it than either the hammer method, as I had at home and in private school (secular), or the slipshod method I had in public HS. What you call dismembering good grammar I call degrading and corrupting the language: it follows closely the same path as indicated by the chaos theory. Unfortunately good language usage is almost completely gone. Admittedly it is easier to write correctly than to speak correctly. It is also very easy to become a pedant, as was Cicero. Nevertheless, it behooves us to do the best we can in speech and in writing. When I started out in teaching I used to practice lecturing so that proper phrasing and word usage became second nature but was not pedantic (I hope). When writing, I always have my wife edit the copy prior to it being sent out.

Most people simply do not care!

Re: Do we have an English Major?? OT

#17

Re: Excellent !

ThomD

I was raised by two Latin and Greek professors, not that it rubbed off on me. My mother also had her masters in English. Tough crowd. Worth considering, though, that the period of standardization and caring was a short lived blink. Somewhat like the dominance of the percussion cap.

Re: Do we have an English Major?? OT

#18

Barb Siddiqui

Re: You can't look to commercials for grammar less

Barb Siddiqui

Has anyone else noticed the misuse of 'less' and 'fewer' in many advertisements? "You'll have less accidents using our product" absolutely grates on my ear. No one used 'fewer' anymore, and it sounds so darned Ignorant. Drives me crazy.

Re: Do we have an English Major?? OT

#19

Re: You can't look to commercials for grammar less

Robert R. Clough

Less Accidents. Is that someone's name? Lester Accidents. Hmmm. Perhaps we should delete the s at the end and substitute an i. Then the name at least appears to be Italian. OK? Father's family, at some point, came from Italy. The Mother was something else again. (Did I say that?)

Re: Do we have an English Major?? OT

#20

Barb Siddiqui

LOL As long as we never lose a sense of humor!

Barb Siddiqui

Re: Do we have an English Major?? OT

#21

Agreed, Barb, but the problem is

Henry Higginbotham

Too many people are disinclined to put any thought into what they're saying. If you were to get anywhere at all with your quest, it would probably result in the same people saying fewer when they (should) mean less.

From grade school on, I remember teachers scolding us for saying "Me and John (did something or other)." Seldom did they add that it would be correct to say "The principal paddled John and me."

I suspect that many students concluded that me was almost slang and to be avoided. This may be what leads to silly usage like "The cops took John and I to jail." Usage like that probably deserves a little jail time.

Sadly, changes in language are usually driven by the most ignorant among us. But keep up the fight!

Re: Do we have an English Major?? OT

#22

Re: You can't look to commercials for grammar less

FredD

Barb , you must really grit your teeth reviewing this Forum , I see the term usage you describe leaking into here, for instance one reader had described something as "vastly less" which tempted me to wonder out loud if this was anything like "hugely small "? ;--))

Have a good one

FredD

Re: Do we have an English Major?? OT

#23

Barb Siddiqui

;-) I grit my teeth a lot!

Barb Siddiqui

But I'm not perfect either. I still misuse 'effect' and 'affect,' though it Seems simple. 'Fewer' and 'less' really bugs me, though. And I'm hearing it everywhere!