Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

humidity

Posts

humidity

#1

humidity

Myra Fox

I have a basement shop which has some dampness - no water running through it but definite dampness. To keep the dampness under control, I run a dehumidifier 24/7, with a hose to a drain.

I'm having trouble finding a good, reliable dehumidifier. (Price under $500) I've tried several. The most recent, an LG, just froze up in temps of about 60 degrees. It was rated for 40 degrees.

Have any of you had a good experience with a dehumidifier?

Specs: The space I'm working with is between 12' and 15' wide and about 60' long. Garage doors at one end. Temp can drop to 50 in really cold weather. I don't put the dehumidifier near the door but toward the middle of the area.

Thanks for any help you can give.

Re: humidity

#2

Re: humidity

brent Smith in montreal

I've had good luck with Whirlpool dehumidifiers. I run 2 of them in pretty much the same setup you have. The trick is to keep them clean. I turn them off while I'm in the shop making sawdust and give them a thorough cleaning every couple of weeks. I have good dust collection and run an air cleaner for a couple of hours after I'm done in the shop every day.....I'm sure this adds considerably to the dehumidifiers life.

Re: humidity

#3

Re: humidity

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Is your garage door sealed? Are you trying to dehumidiy the whole outdoors?

Re: humidity

#4

Re: humidity

Myra Fox

It's fairly well sealed with weather stripping and also insulated. However, it wouldn't hurt for me to check on these again.

Re: humidity

#5

Re: humidity

Myra Fox

a thorough cleaning is one thing I have NOT been doing. I need to start.

Do you happen to know, without a lot of checking, the model number of your dehumidifiers?

Thanks.

Re: humidity

#6

JL

Re: humidity

JL

With such a long narrow space, you probably need to move some air. I would probably go for two dehumidifiers. I tried Hampton Bay - it died. I tried Whirlpool - it died. I'm currently running a Kenmore - it seems to be holding it's own.

Even though you only have 900 sq. ft. - the narrowness of the space really interferes with air flow. Are you running an air filtration system (such as Jet, JDS or a shop made one)? This will cut down on the cleaning of the dehumidifiers and improve the shop air flow.

Re: humidity

#7

Ellis Walentine

Kenmore

Ellis Walentine

We've been running a Kenmore dehumidifier in our basement for years now with no problems. I can't say how often it would need to be cleaned if you run it in a dusty environment.

Ellis

Re: humidity

#8

Heating...

charles in mtl.

is it possible the space needs to be heated to drive away humidity?

Re: humidity

#9

Re: humidity *LINK*

brent Smith in montreal

I run 2 of these, along with shop air cleaners.


Dehumidifier

Re: humidity

#10

Dale Lenz

I've always been told...

Dale Lenz

it's cheaper to heat than to dehumidify the air(??). If you could raise the temp 10-15 degrees it should knock the RH down several pts.

Re: humidity

#11

Clint Searl

I second the motion

Clint Searl

Re: humidity

#12

step back.....

Bill Tindall

I dehumidify 40 x 30 divided basement with two units and a circulating fan and the dehumidifiers have lasted for many years. The only time I need them is in the summer when the basement is cool and outside is hot. I probably average 1-2 gallons a day collected, at most. The soggy air in the house settles into the basement, cools and the humidity goes up. The basement is very dry in winter because dry house air is the only source of moisture.

I would be looking at preventing the moisture problem rather than trying to totally fix it with dehumidification. Where is all this moisture coming from? Have the walls been sealed? Are the doors a source of air leakage? Can the space be divided and only part dehumidified? What is your target humidity level? "Normal" on my units will take it to less than 50% which is unnecessarily low. I keep humidity in range of 50-60%. What is the source of heat in this area?

Re: humidity

#13

Thanks for the ideas!

Myra Fox

I'd like to thank all of you for the ideas.

Questions that make good points

1. source of moisture: The cement block of the basement, at least in the workshop area, is below grade. It was waterproofed in 1963 but not since then. I have re-routed downspouts, etc., to eliminate as much of the ground water as possible and painted the inside of the block with UGL Drylock. What I get is really seepage, and some actual water during downpours. I think I'd rather buy a new dehumidifier annually than have someone in to tackle the foundation.

2. heating the space: I'm going to give that some thought. It would be nice because, in addition to helping the moisture issue, it would also make the workshop more comfortable during the winter.

3. air filter: Yes, I do have one which I run on an as-needed basis.

4. moisture target: I am paranoid about mildew (allergies) and rust so I have targeted about 40%. I know that's really low but what can I say - I'm paranoid.

Tomorrow I'm going to investigate the Kenmore dehumidifiers which have had positive comments from 3 people in this thread. I'll also make sure that it stays clean. Then, as I've said, I'll give some serious thought to adding a little heat.

Thank you all for your help.

Re: humidity

#14

comments on your new information

Bill Tindall

You will not get rust of mold at 50% RH. But you will need a fan, probably two, to circulate air in the long space. It is no wonder you are wearing out dehumidifiers. It must run constantly. My shop is totally below ground and I get no moisture from the surrounding dirt. In the winter I run 40-50% in the shop with no dehumidification.

See if you can find the source of seepage. It does not sound like there should be any if the house is graded properly and the roof is not dumping water on the foundation. Most soggy basement problems are a result of improperly dealing with water that lands on the roof. I have fixed several soggy basements, often for trivial amounts, just by getting water away from the foundation.