Cabinet saw - left or right tilt
Scott
What drives the preference for a left or right tilt saw? I'm finally going to move away from my radial arm to a table saw. Alright.....let me have it!
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Cabinet saw - left or right tilt
Scott
What drives the preference for a left or right tilt saw? I'm finally going to move away from my radial arm to a table saw. Alright.....let me have it!
Re: Cabinet saw - left or right tilt
JL
I like a left tilt. My table is on the right side. My blade leans away from my table. If I am cutting an angle other than 90 degrees, my off cut (or waste) is under the blade and the piece I'm cutting is on top. I'm not "trapped" between the fence (which is on the right) and the blade. All of my previous saws have been left tilt.
My $0.02.
Re: Cabinet saw - left or right tilt
Ron Jones
I have used both on the job. I have a left tilt Shop Fox at home. It seems safer to me; maybe just because is feels more natural to me and I am more comfortable with it.
Re: Cabinet saw - left or right tilt
FredD
I agree with the posters about left tilt saws.
I have a Unisaw bought new in 74 and a PM 66 bought new in 2002 .
I made the Unisaw into a dedicated rip saw with power feed and I much prefer the left tilt PM 66 for general use. It is I believe less prone to kickback , therefor much safer and far easier to gauge where the tilted blade is relative to the desired cut , when you set up the cut.
FredD
Re: Why a cabinet saw ?
Chuck Lenz
If you know how to setup a Contractor's table saw with a good fence, the apropriate power and good dust collection theres no need to spend the extra money, unless you plan on runing a full time shop 8 hours a day and 40 hours a week.
I agree
paul in AZ
Re: Why a cabinet saw ?
Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI
Well, for one thing, it has a significantly smaller footprint than a contractor's. For another, it's easier to align the table's miter slots to the blade. I'm sure there's more and I don't even own one although I'm satisfied with my JET contractor.
Re: Why a cabinet saw ?
Moses Yoder
The main difference between a cabinet saw and a contractor saw is the way the blade arbor is mounted. In a cabinet saw the arbor is attached to the base and not the top. This makes it easier to align the blade with the miter gauge slots in the top. In the contractor saw the arbor is attached to the top. I used a contractor saw for a long time building cabinets for a living but when I had the opportunity to buy a 3 phase Powermatic 66 left tilt cabinet saw for $80 cash and a nice compound bow in trade for the saw I was very happy. I got the saw running and am very pleased with the smooth powerful hum it makes while operating it. I gave away my Delta contractors saw because it had such a negligible value.
Re: Why a cabinet saw ?
Chuck Lenz
Neither are really an issue in my shop. I use a outfeed table with my saw, so basically the footprint is about the same. I've never had to realign the made in the USA Delta Contractor's saw that own. And even if a person had too, a $20 set of PALS I would think would solve that problem for good. I've never been a big fan of crosscuting on the table saw anyway. Most of the Contractor's saw bashing that I see is from someone trying to justify their purchase of a Cabinet saw, or it's a sales pitch. I guess it's like a Harley or a Corvette, if you can afford one, well good for you. Left tilt, right tilt, it doesn't matter to me either, I have a right tilt, and I can work just fine with it.
Good points but
Dustmaker Mike
he wants a cabinet saw. That is enough of a reason for me to buy things.
Re: Why a cabinet saw ?
FredD
Well said Moses and accurate, though I suspect you wasted your time in saying so.
For the people who run Cabinet shops and serious woodworkers, a Cabinet saw is the choice of saw.
For hobby shops a well tuned Delta contractors saw serves the purpose.
I have a 10" Delta on a stand I used on job sites when I actually worked and use now only to cove drawer fronts, I offered it to somebody here for free and didn't get interest.
FredD
Re: Cabinet saw - left or right tilt
Hoa in Alameda
I can never understand the argument that there is less chance of kickback with left-tilt saw.
In order to have kickback, the workpiece has to wonder into the trailing edge of the blade. For a right-tilt saw, the "dangerous" part of the board being cut is trapped between the fence and under the blade. It can't go anywhere. For a left-tilt saw, the "dangerous" part is between the fence and above the blade.
IMHO, if there is more chance of kickback, it is in the latter case.
I understand that on a right-tilt saw, the blade tilts toward the fence. That leaves less room for the operator's right hand to guide the workpiece along the fence. But this is different from kickback. I use a Unifence, and I hook my little finger in the slot on the other side of the fence. My hand doesn't wonder anywhere.
Of course I assume the saw and the fence are set up correctly. If they aren't, e.g. the fence is not parallel with the blade, you're in trouble regardless of the tilt direction of the blade.
I choose to install a sliding table with my saw. A right-tilt saw gives me more choices.
Re: Cabinet saw - left or right tilt
Ellis Walentine
My first several tablesaws were right-tilt models, but my current one is left tilt. I prefer the left-tilt saw every time I have to make a bevel cut, as the workpiece is less likely to become wedged between the blade and fence.
The merits of contractor's saws versus cabinet saws is a separate discussion.
Ellis
Kickback concerns
Ellis Walentine
Reasonable concerns, Hoa. I'd be interested to know if a right-tilt saw is statistically less likely to kick back. I had several holes in my walls in the old shop that seemed like evidence to the contrary. My own, possibly flawed, reasoning is that one of the main causes of kickback is reactive wood closing up on the blade. That can happen on left- or right-tilt saws, whether the blade is tilted or straight up and down. Splitters and riving knives can help prevent this.
I suspect that beveled cutoffs are more likely to get bound up between the blade and fence on a right-tilt saw, partly because of the fact that it can be difficult or impossible to push the cutoff past the blade if there isn't enough room between the tip of the blade and the fence to run a push stick. But, narrow beveled cutoffs can be dangerous on left-tilt saws as well.
I suppose I should be more familiar with the stats on this issue.
Ellis
Re: Cabinet saw - left or right tilt
Chuck Lenz
( I prefer the left-tilt saw every time I have to make a bevel cut, as the workpiece is less likely to become wedged between the blade and fence. ) Am I missing something ? I would think that if your worried about the blade pointing towards the fence on a right tilt, you could put the fence on the left side of the blade ?
Re: Shhhhhh Hoa
Chuck Lenz
This seems to be a good place to wait for someone thats going to give away their right tilt Cabinet saw.
Fence on left?
Hoa in Alameda
"you could put the fence on the left side of the blade ?"
It's not always possible, Chuck.
With the fence on the left side of the blade, the capacity is pretty limited, probably about 10". On my Unisaw, with the fence cut flush with the left side of the tablesaw top to accommodate a sliding table, the capacity is almost nothing.
Then if you can move the fence to the left, the cutting operation is awkward, at least to most people. I wouldn't want to do it.
I like right tilt...
John in NM
Most of the bevel cuts I do have been on panels large enough that I need a vertical jig, or on a narrow piece that gets a 45 to make a mitered post or leg. For both these cases its easy enough to move the fence over to the other side of the blade and avoid the kickback question. Right tilt then allows me to stand on the left side of the saw if the cut is making me too nervous or if a big awkward panel needs closer control.
My first saw was a left tilt, and old 8" Craftsman contractors saw. As I recall, I tended to run the fence on the left side of the blade on that one. Go figure 
Fence on left changes alignment
Terry Alexander
I have a Delta Contractor saw. I have it tuned to (almost) perfection. There's not much I can't do on it. However, in the tuning process, I have the fence out 5/1000 at the end. If I were to move the fence to the left of the blade, I "assume" I would have the fence turning in 5/1000, which would increase the chance of pinching and the associated kickback. Nope....I haven't tried it and do not intend to. I try to review all the safety precautions prior to a cut, make sure I have my push stick at the "ready" and, most important to me, LISTEN to the wood.....it'll tell you you're getting into trouble before it happens.
My $.02 worth.
Terry Alexander in West Texas