We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Still working on the built-in bookcase; now cutting drawer parts. In his book "Building Doors and Drawers," Andy Rae writes:
"Rather than widening a typical 1/4-inch-wide groove to accommodate a thicker drawer bottom, it's better to bevel or rabbet the edges of the bottom to fit the groove."
Unfortunately, he doesn't explain WHY it's "better." For this newbie, cutting a 1/2" groove for a 1/2" drawer bottom seems decidedly "better" -- but I thought perhaps this group could shed some light on the subject - ?
IMO, a 1/4" groove is a silly restriction, especially if the bottom is 1/2" ply, which is a convenient and often appropriate material. Cutting the groove to accommodate the bottom thickness isn't illegal, it's smart.
The only reasons I can think of is that if you turn the drawer bottom into a "raised" panel you can drop the raised part into the space that is normally lost or wasted under the bottom.
If you decide the lower edge of the groove must be 'x" up from the bottom of the drawer sides, then to install a thicker bottom by cutting a wider groove would take the additional thickness out of the interior of the drawer. Rabbeting the edge of the bottom or cutting it like a raised panel takes the space from under the bottom.
Another reason is that plywood these days is inconsistent in thickness. some "half Inch" plywood is more like to be 12mm. Or whatever it came out to be at the factory. By rabbeting the edges you can cut the grooves before you buy the plywood or mass produce drawer parts and adjust the thickness of the plywood bottoms later.
Still nothing wrong with making a wider groove if you have the space and can match the thickness of the bottom.
Historically drawer bottoms were made of solid wood and they were fashioned into raised panels, often crude raised panels, and let into approximately 1/4" dadoes. It makes a sharp looking drawer, with a classic, quality look. My guess is that drawer bottom material was not precisely hand planed to thickness in those days (in fact in many cases only one side was planed) and it was easier to establish a constant panel thickness to engage the groove only around the edges....by means of beveling the panel.
With modern machinery, dado blades capable of cutting any size groove, and plywood it would make no sense to raise a panel from plywood with the only benefit of gaining a 1/4" of drawer height.
But, if you are building a fine piece of furniture, eschew the plywood and do a traditional drawer. It, along with the hand cut dovetails, will enhance the perception of quality in the piece.
Agree with the suggestions that others have made. One additional thought is that Mr. Rae wished to keep the interior depth of the drawer the same. Assuming the groove for the drawer bottom was near the bottom edge of the sides/rear/front, the only option (other than using drawer slips) is to widen the groove in the upward direction, hence slightly decreasing the interior space. IMHO, I don't consider that a deal breaker and would simply widen the groove to accommodate a thicker drawer bottom. And I don't think I have ever found it necessary to rabbet a drawer bottom as he recommends although that approach might be useful for the bottoms of small drawers/boxes with thin sides. For me, it is easier to sneak up on the appropriate groove width in the sides etc. than rabbeting the bottom. Stylistically though, a paneled bottom is a nice touch that conveys another level of craftmanship and attention to detail.
I have sworn off of manmade materials for drawers that I store clothes in. I have a couple of things I built and one that I bought that use plywood and hardboard. They make my clothes smell funny! I tried sealing the storebought piece with shellac and it didn't fix it. I ended up getting rid of that. The chest that I built has plywood bottoms and my tshirts have a chemical smell. I haven't gotten around to sealign those with shellac yet. On the other hand, I built a lowboy with pine drawers and they smell really good every time I open them!
Tony wrote: On the other hand, I built a lowboy with pine drawers and they smell really good every time I open them!
In 1994, I bought some furniture made by Henkel-Harris. The story I was told by the salesperson was that the wife of one of the company founders (Mrs. Harris, if I remember correctly) hated the smell of newly completed case goods because of the smell of the glue. So she went out and procured a couple of drums of vanilla extract and had them soak the drawer sides (or maybe the bottoms, or . . . ?) in the stuff.
Whatever the true story (anyone else know anything about it?), sixteen years later I can open a drawer that's been closed for a few days and that wonderful vanilla scent is still there. I didn't get the dresser at the time (and now it's over $5k, so I guess I never will), so I haven't stored clothing items in a vanilla-infused drawer and have no idea how that might work out for someone.
I bevel drawer bottoms when it is a reproduction or in the time that process was commonly used.
Plywood bottoms get grooves that fit the plywood thickness.
That being said , it seems to me that the thickness issue has gone beyond silly for drawer bottoms.
Case in point; I have a set of plans of a Lingerie Chest of drawers designed by a above average nationally known Furniture Maker where the drawers are slightly less then sixteen inches deep front to back and about two feet wide.
He calls out the drawer bottom stock to be 5/8ths inch thick beveled down to a 1/4inch groove in the side.
Way over kill folks , we are talking Lingerie here , not nuts and bolts.
All of the drawers I make for Kitchens for instance have quarter inch bottoms , even the pot and pan trays, they do not sag and last as long as the Cabinets do.
Anything thicker then that is not required and is overkill and a waste of expensive material in my opinion.
But I also capture the bottom in a groove on all four sides and the bottom is glued in place which holds the drawer square among other things.
Thanks. I'll try that. I picked shellac just becuase I've read that it is good for sealing and it dries fast and "odorless." I'm pretty sure I have some water based poly in the shop though.
I totally agree with not using shellac in that particular application. I once did, and while it did "dry" initially, it softened and became stickey and gummy. Also a bit maloderous. My mistake was confined to only one small drawer in a client's sewing machine cabinet, but I had to strip it out and do it over.
I've never used vanilla on a drawer before, but I often put a drop or two in my varnish. The vanilla extract will overpower the varnish odor and clients love the smell. Another shameless trick is lavender scented cabinetmakers wax. Kudos to Terry Masatchi for the vanilla idea.
Only finish related do-over I have had was one time when I carelessly mixed my shellac in an old pickle jar. Even though the jar had been washed, enough pickle essence remained that my client called me up and said "You may think I'm crazy, but the cabinet smells like pickles." Boy was I red-faced!
I haven't asked Andy what he meant by that statement, but I have a few reasons of my own to recommend you follow his advice. First, it allows you to keep the drawer bottom lower in the drawer. Say your bottom is 1/2" thick. If you make a 1/2" wide groove and add another 1/4" of solid wood under it to support the bottom, the inside face of the bottom will be 3/4" up from the bottom of the drawer front and sides (and back, if you're using plywood and gluing it in all around.) If you make the groove 1/4" wide, with 1/4" of solid wood under it, your bottom will be roughly flush on the bottom and the inside face will be only 1/2" up. If you aren't scrounging for maximum depth, it probably doesn't matter.
The other reason is that grooves are easier to make if you can do them in one pass, like with a router bit or dado blade. That bit or blade will have a certain kerf width, which may or may not be the same as the nominal width. It's easier to thickness (or bevel or rabbet) the bottom to fit the actual width of the groove than it is to get the groove to fit some arbitrary thickness of drawer bottom, especially if it's plywood. You can rabbet the bottom with just a simple adjustment of the saw or router fence (and possibly blade/bit height, if you don't plan for it).
Thanks, Ellis, and to all the others who replied (including those who gave tips on flavoring cabinetry... ). Since my drawer openings are 5", 7" and 12" high (the last for hanging file folders), I'm not going to sweat losing 1/4" of interior drawer depth.