Re: OT - I don't know anything about modern TVs
Dave Paine
As another reply stated, the TV world has changed and so 16:9 ratio is now the normal aspect ratio.
As you shop around, consider the power consumption. LCD and Plasma TV's consume more power than you may appreciate. You state you do not watch often, but the wattage could exceed the old TV.
Some companies, such as Vizeo, claim their power saving. Plasma used to consume more than LCD/LED.
I have a 52in Sony LCD and was surprised at its 300 Watt consumption at maximum brightness.
You asked a very broad question, and no easy single answer.
Today's TV's are expected to be integrated into Home Theatre and the Internet.
My Sony has ethernet connection, but it needs to be connected to a router. Latest models like include the wireless connection.
My Sony also has a useable PC connection. I used this initially for streaming Netflix movies. Now I have the PC connected to a wireless Bridge and so can stream movies and TV direct from Netflix.
You mentioned not having good reception, if you also do not have broadband connection then your viewing choices will be limited to the DVD's you rent.
These days 1080p is considered the normal pixel depth for DVD's, although in order to enjoy this feature, your DVD player needs to support.the pixel depth.
True 1080p is available only with Blu-ray DVD players. Other players may "scale" to this pixel depth, but they are converting lower resolution.
I would get the largest screen you can afford. As my eyes age, I appreciate larger screens more every year.