Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

dumbwaiter findings

Posts

dumbwaiter findings

#1

dumbwaiter findings

Gary Smyth

Several days ago I posted asking about how I might install a dumbwaiter. Several suggestions were provided. One response mentioned to be aware of the possibility of fire traveling up the laundry shoot. I stopped in at a local fire station to ask about building the dumbwaiter and was referred to the building inspector. Today was Veterans Day (Hoo Rah) and no one was working but the fire guys told me several things. 1. The old laundry shoot has to be removed and in its place a metal self-contained duct where the car will fit has to be installed. The new duct has to have a top and bottom and wiring openings sealed. 2. The �doors� at the end of the floors have to be metal and must close. The duct has to be isolated from the wall framing. 4. A smoke detector has to be at both ends of the duct. 5. The motor for the car has to be a fire rated motor. Then they told me I would also need a permit and inspection. Basically they treated this as a small elevator.

I shouldn�t have asked. Another person will do the dumbwaiter. relative of mine or not I just don�t want to take the chance.

Re: dumbwaiter findings

#2

Understandable

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Funny how these projects have a way of expanding.

The requirements they describe make a lot of sense, as frustrating as it must have been to hear them. But code exists to reduce hazard.

Re: dumbwaiter findings

#3

Re: dumbwaiter findings

FredD

Gary,

I know your heart was in the right place for just considering the project, but believe me it is far better to know now , then later how far out you could have run your neck.

FredD

Re: dumbwaiter findings

#4

Understand

Neal in San Jose

I was in construction for many years, and my ex is a fire inspector (still on good terms, btw). Every time I got frustrated by some fire code costing extra money or time, she'd remind me that someone died for every code in the book. Believe me, you are better off letting someone else handle this so you can sleep well.

Re: dumbwaiter findings

#5

You really only scratched the surface

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

On the requirements and codes for Dumbwaiters. DW's are licensed and permited just like elevators, at least in Oregon. Of all the trades and codes I deal with at work, elevator codes are the most restrictive and the trade seems the most closed.

Re: dumbwaiter findings

#6

This is incredible.

Yonak

I'm not generally one to gripe about government expropriating individual freedoms, but this overreach is incredible.

Re: dumbwaiter findings

#7

I agree...

John in NM

I understand the motivation for building codes to attempt to anticipate and prevent every single eventuality, but at some point it gets rather absurd. Parts of what Gary relates make good sense to me, other parts have the stink of bureaucracy. But then I never was a hoop jumper, so its not surprising that I'd think this way :D

Re: dumbwaiter findings

#8

Moses Yoder

Re: On the other hand...

Moses Yoder

Just carry the stuff upstairs. You would get some good excersize while doing so. I suppose some people are in such bad shape they can't go up stairs but I guess then it's time to move into a single story apartment.

Re: dumbwaiter findings

#9

Similar

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Look at an arborist's wood chipper. Things are covered with little stickers with warnings. One guy pointed out to me that every one of those stickers represented a lawsuit, most concerning someone who died.

Re: dumbwaiter findings

#10

Re: On the other hand...

George Koch

Is there a difference between a dumbwaiter shaft and a stairwell acting as a chimney vent between two floors?

Re: dumbwaiter findings

#11

There comes a point, though . . .

Yonak

I'm thinking of the warning label on the toaster that says don't use in the bathtub.

Re: dumbwaiter findings

#12

Re: On the other hand...

Barry Irby

Yes, there is a difference, The stairwell is part of the main egress route and you need to be able to flee down it in the event of a fire. A dumb waiter shaft on the other hand makes a poor escape route. So, the shaft of the dumb waiter needs to be lined with fire proof material and have automatic dampers and doors. (???)

Was not the laundry chute pre-existing and already lined with sheet metal? How does changing it into a dumb waiter increase the chance for fire to rise through the shaft? Are dumb waiters an ignition source? Are they highly flammable of materials that generate noxious fumes? It seems to me a dumbwaiter would be less likely to spread fire than a laundry chute.

Re: dumbwaiter findings

#13

How fast

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

How fast would you call a lawyer if your child playing hide and seek hid in that unlicensed dumbwaiter and got seriously hurt or killed or if the lift motor caught fdire and burned your house to the ground?

Lee

Re: dumbwaiter findings

#14

I've heard

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

more than one attorney express the Darwinian notion that limiting products liability suits might be beneficial to the gene pool.

Re: dumbwaiter findings

#15

Chutes

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Acted as draft chimneys that would suck CO and other toxic combustion gasses out of the basement / laundry area [think dryer fires] putting the gas right into the top floor sleeping areas far faster than otherwise, and can kill before anyone knew there was a fire. Last I heard in my area, they're just prohibited, grandfather or pre-existing doesn't matter. "Want a CofO? Tear it out and close the holes."

Re: dumbwaiter findings

#16

Faster

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

than it took to write the question.