Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

bandsaw ?

Posts

bandsaw ?

#1

bandsaw  ?

andrew nistock

hello all, My question for the day is, what make of bandsaw would you prefer if you wanted a unit to be used mainly for resawing stock. Am asking for a friend that doesn't have internet access. He would prefer American made if possible. Thanks , Andy

Re: bandsaw ?

#2

When this one dies . . .

steve mackay

and it can't happen soon enough (Craftsman) I'm get'n me the Griz G0555 14". I KNOW in my soul it'll last, it'll do anything I ask of it AND I can afford it.

Re: bandsaw ?

#3

JL

Re: bandsaw  ?

JL

I like my 18" Rikon (10-345).

It has 12" of resaw capacity and cuts quite well with a Wood Slicer blade.

Re: bandsaw ?

#4

Ellis Walentine

I'd ask a couple questions

Ellis Walentine

How much stock is he planning to resaw? I mean, is this a commercial shop where the saw will be resawing daily or weekly? Or a hobbyist shop, where it will be used only once in a while?

How wide a board must it be able to resaw?

What's his budget?

Also, don't count on finding an American-made bandsaw.

Ellis

Re: bandsaw ?

#5

Re: bandsaw  ?

paul in AZ

You will likely get a favorite model 'you-gotta-have-this-one' or a 'don't buy that one' reply from anyone who has a bandsaw. I happen to love mine but the fact that its a Jet and how I use it has no relevance to someone else's use or preferences.

Before getting too confused with recommendations on make and model or specific features I'd suggest that your friend buy a book or two on bandsaws. Dugin and Bird each have a book that helped guide me. Have him define his needs, then read about what it takes to execute those ideas. Cheaper to buy two books than buying the wrong machine. Search the bookstore section on this site. From there you can shop somewhat intelligently. Everything in life is a trade-off so budget will rear it's ugly head.

Great tool to have. Good luck.

Re: bandsaw ?

#6

If I May Be Permitted to

Gerry In North Surrey

do a little flag waving here. Not the Stars and Bars but the Red Maple Leaf. General Woodworking Tools manufactures a complete line of power tools that are second to none in quality, craftsmanship, and customer service. Just ask the man that owns one. Stuff is made in the, so far, Canadian Province of Quebec, just across the St. Lawrence. This speaks for power saws also, re the cabinet saw thread of a few days ago that lamented the fact that there were no more American power saws available. FWIW

Gerry, who has no connection to the General folks other than being a satisfied customer.

Re: bandsaw ?

#7

Re: I'd ask a couple questions

andrew nistock

Thanks Ellis, Many good points. It will be a hobby shop. The reason he wanted resaw capacity is that I saw material for him (with my bandsaw sawmill) and he will be wanting to resaw some of the thicker material to make bookmatched material. Probably nothing ove 10 inches in width. Don't know his budget limits. I kind of thought that it may be hard to find something american made but one can always hope. Thanks for the help. Andy

Re: bandsaw ?

#8

Re: bandsaw  ?

Barry Irby

I agree with those who say think before you pull the trigger.

I have a Delta bandsaw (American made) with a riser block. I added the riser, and a tension release, and a spring, and dust collection, and several different sets of guides, and a fence. It seems I bought a small underpowered band saw and spent a ton trying to upgrade it. I have enough money in it to have bought a larger bandsaw to start with. If I knew I was going to resaw I would seriously look at buying a larger saw to start with and not have to make all the upgrades. I don't know what that saw would be, I have no experience with larger saws, I'm just sayin'.

I have a love/hate relationship with the saw anyway. I saw a panel or two and then want to cut a circle or a bowl blank. 20 minutes to change the blade. Then want to resaw, 20 minutes to change the blade back. Got a wall full of partially used blades. Need a nice fresh sharp one to resaw with and an old raggedy one to cut bowl blanks. Clearly need better labels. I would really like to have two saws, one for resawing and one for other stuff.

You can buy American made, just not new American made.

PS. the author of the book is Duginski, not Dugin.

Re: bandsaw ?

#9

Given the expected use

Steve Schoene

I'd seriously think about looking for a used, made in USA, Delta 14" bandsaw, preferably with the riser block to give 12" resaw capacity. This is the design that almost all of the import 14" saws have directly copied. Unless abused, it can be easily be retuned to work as well as any of the similarly sized machines made today. It's pretty straightforward to rehabilitate. You might need new tires, a new tension spring, and perhaps some bearings and Cool Blocks. If the one you find is old enough you might also want to upgrade from the 1/2 hp motor that some came with. But the castings were good, and the design made it the most widely used saw in it's class with appliations in both home shops and many commercial operations.

Re: bandsaw ?

#10

Re: bandsaw  ?

Doug Ring

DoAll still manufactures their saws in the US. They market primarly to the metals industries, and the pricing is going to be high, but the build quality (based on the two that I've used) is excellent.

http://www.doall.com/doallsawing.aspx

Re: bandsaw ?

#11

Ellis Walentine

Permission granted

Ellis Walentine

Right, Gerry, General makes excellent bandsaws, and at least three (15" and 20") of them are made in Canada, which I suppose qualifies them as "American," at least in the sense of North American (or not Asian, if you prefer). They'll set you back more than similar-capacity Asian machines, and only your friend can decide whether it is worth it to him. I personally feel that the country of origin isn't in itself a deciding factor, as long as the engineering and quality control are good. General International, General's offshore-sourcing division (and a WoodCentral major advertiser), is backed by the same corporate engineering pride and customer service bona fides as the Canadian parent company, so you should certainly consider them among your choices.

Ellis

Re: bandsaw ?

#12

Re: bandsaw  ?

andrew nistock

Thanks for all the help. As usual the folks at Woodcentral came through. Andy