Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Need advice

Posts

Need advice

#1

Need advice

Greg Muller


I was asked to try to perserve this piece of 600 year old black oak. It is a oval approx 27"x24" and 4" thick. I am looking for advice on how to stablize the rot and what type of finish to use to after sanding both sides. I was thinking about useing some type of aerosol spray sealer to spray inside the crack to stop further rot but I am open to anything. I do not have hvlp equipment so will have to use what I can get in a can. Also for the final finish I was thinking 3-5 coats of poly. This request is from the Mayor of the town I work for so I am very concerned about doing this right. This tree was a huge part of the town and when it fell during a storm it was a huge deal. Thanks in advance for any advice.

Re: Need advice

#2

Re: Need advice

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

You don't give any information on the intended use of the "saved" piece. I would try the MinWax wood hardener to beef up the rotted area, followed perhaps by a couple of coats of finish the type of finish would depend up what the final use for the slab will be.

Lee


img

Re: Need advice

#3

Re: Need advice

Greg Muller

The piece is going to be displayed on end on a stand like a plate would be.

Re: Need advice

#4

Dale Lenz

Short answer to rot

Dale Lenz

The wood disease will become inactive once the disk dries out. The disk is going to crack, let crack and hopefully you can work with it. Have the disk mounted so it can not fall, could bust it, the wood in a cross grain situation as yours is relatively weak.

Have fun and enjoy

Re: Need advice

#5

Re: Short answer to rot

Greg Muller

The disk should be dry. It was cut from the trunk about 5 years ago and has been leaning on its side in a closet since then. My biggest concern is not letting it crack anymore and what to use to finish it.

Re: Need advice

#6

I can't tell from this photo,

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

But are you sure this tree was 600 years old? Have you actually planed a smooth surface and counted the annual rings, or are you just taking someone's word, that may not know that a tree puts on a new ring each year.

If what I thought I was seeing were actually annual rings, I am betting less than 150. What I like to do, is to count ten rings, then make a mark, and note every decade, back to the pith. This will show up any events, which may note big storms or long drouths etc.

I would suggest that you keep it in a cardboard box most of the time, or it may start checking more. And you may want to think about Peg 1000 or pentacryl to stabilize it.

Re: Need advice

#7

Date of tree

Greg Muller

The age of the tree is pretty well documented. I don't believe it will check at this point. I really trying to get ideas on how to stablize it so when it is on display it will not rot anymore. Also can I use a obit sander on it or should I sand by hand. I am thinking maybe the vibrations from the sander might do more damage.

Re: Need advice

#8

Rot will not be the issue; skeptical about age

Bill Tindall

As everyone has said, dry wood won't rot. The issue is mechanical. It is already nearly falling apart from cracks which will only get worse as it dries. I don't have sure fire fix for it falling apart from cracks but that is the issue to worry about. Sand it any way that won't vibrate it apart. End grain sands very slow. I doubt you will ever smooth it by hand sanding.

And, I am skeptical about the age. It looks to be about 20 inches in diameter? At 600 years, that is 1/64 of an inch of radial growth each year! Where will a black oak live that it will only grow that amount in a year? If you can distinguish growth rings its not 600 years old. The picture seems to show growth rings. Are the features that look like growth rings indeed growth rings? If so before this artifact gets displayed, keep someone from looking foolish by pointing out that the tree folklore is wrong.

Re: Need advice

#9

age not  an issue

Greg Muller

This piece may have been from a branch from the tree. I was not there when they cut it. At this point though age is not my problem I need to know what to use on the inside of the crack to seal it up before sanding and finishing.