Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

For the love of all that is holy...

Posts

For the love of all that is holy...

#1

For the love of all that is holy...

LJB

I started with an old desk-- original owner told me it was walnut. After paying him $200, and paying 2 men and a truck $250, I indeed started with a solid walnut desk, with only a few portions (as far as I can tell, having a wooden veneer).

FIRST TRY: I stripped. Then I scrubbed. Then I sanded. And then I applied General Finishes Water Base Dye Stain in black. Then I waited a day. Then I applied General Finishes Glaze Effects in Ebony. I had no general method to my application so it dried in a weird, unattractive pattern. I tried re-glazing after it was dry. No dice. I tried sanding and then re-glazing. It turned up with weird shades of gray streaks.

SECOND TRY: Back to square one. I stripped. I scrubbed. I sanded. And then I applied General Finishes Water Base Dye Stain in black. Then I waited a day. Then I applied General Finishes Glaze Effects in Ebony, and did so systematically-- finishing with a dry brush effect. Extremely cool.

Then, as I had been directed by the man at the woodworking speciality store who took one look at my yoga pants and Jackie sunglasses and almost called the loony bin (I think I differ from the usual clientel), I applied GF Arm-R-Seal Urethane Topcoat. After the first topcoat, I followed the directions on the can and lightly buffed, leaving behind a trail of white dust. I cleaned the white dust. It did not disappear. I waited an hour. Still there. I rubbed a damp cloth over it. Nope. I begged and pleaded with the desktop to just be black. It said no.

THIRD TRY: Back to square one (again). I stripped (again). I scrubbed (again). I sanded (again). And then I applied General Finishes Water Base Dye Stain in black. Then I waited a day. Then I applied General Finishes Glaze Effects in Ebony, and did so systematically-- finishing with a dry brush effect. Extremely cool. Then, I applied GF Arm-R-Seal Urethane Topcoat with a foam brush. I did not sand. I merely waited 24 hours, and applied again.

After the 3rd application, the meaner cousin of my sanding streaks began to show-- but now they were glossy gray streaks. So this time I called General Finishes. Dude told me he'd never used my particular method before, but that I shouldn't be seeing gray streaks. He said I should buff (shouldn't have listened). He suggested a finer sanding paper (shouldn't have listened). He said maybe I had gone through the 1st topcoat during my second go round. This time I wouldn't. I shouldn't have listened.

If anyone has some miracle advice for me, I will likely give you my first born child.

Re: For the love of all that is holy...

#2

Re: For the love of all that is holy...

FredD

LJB,

if you will pardon my comparison, your method sounds remarkably like Einstein's definition of Insanity which goes something like this " if you continue to repeat something that your doing over and over and expect different results " well you know..........;-))

I can't help you much on the problem you have, but I would stay clear of water based anything which you are applying over a old finish that still is in the wood like a sealer regardless of how mow many times you strip and sand it,

FredD

FredD

Re: For the love of all that is holy...

#3

Re: For the love of all that is holy...

LJB

Yes, excellent point. I just thought I had narrowed the wrong step, so I eliminated each respective wrong step each time I started over again.

So I need oil-based stain and finish, is what you're saying?

Re: For the love of all that is holy...

#4

Re: For the love of all that is holy...

Dick Coers

Curious why you are using the glaze. Their water based dye stain can really bite into the wood. I can't imagine why you want more dark finish on top. Usually, a thin coat of clear is applied on top of the dye, very lightly sanded with 320, then any glaze if you want some details highlighted. Then the final coats of clear.

Re: For the love of all that is holy...

#5

Ellis Walentine

Where to begin?

Ellis Walentine

I'm not sure what you're trying to accomplish but it sounds like you want to color this poor desk black, with some nifty dry-brushed glaze effect in there somewhere. It sounds like the products you used should have done the trick if applied and dealt with properly. Which brings us around to your procedure:

Could multiple go-rounds of paint stripper have introduced some nasty residual chemical effects that are affecting your stains and glazes? Maybe, particularly if you didn't get the residue off well enough after you stripped the piece.

Or, did these unholy failures have to do with your sanding steps? Hard to fathom, at least without seeing how exactly you sanded and with what abrasive(s). I'm having a hard time visualizing the white powder that wouldn't go away when you were sanding your urethane coat. I'm guessing that the sanding dust was getting trapped in the textured surface of your dry-brushed glaze coat telegraphing through the urethane. In any event, a light wiping with a rag and some mineral spirits should have cleaned that up nicely.

And, these gray streaks? Somehow you've tied them to sanding marks, but sanding shouldn't leave marks unless you didn't remove the scratches from the coarser grits before proceeding to the finer grits. So it would be helpful to know what grit you started with after you stripped and washed the surface clean. Then it would be good to know how finely you sanded, and if we're talking about scratches or streaks of color.

I can't blame any of your problems on the combination of the water-based stain and the urethane topcoat, unless you didn't wait long enough between all these steps to allow the stuff to dry completely, or unless there was some residual stripper lurking in the wood.

Also, you mentioned veneer, but I'm wondering if this is indeed a veneered piece or a solid wood desk? That may become a factor very quickly with all this sanding going on, as you could sand through the thin veneer and expose layers of glue under it. Then you'd have a much larger problem.

Maybe a couple more answers, and/or a photo of the streaks you describe, would help.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: For the love of all that is holy...

#6

Moses Yoder

Re: For the love of all that is holy...

Moses Yoder

My suggestion would be to carefully strip the finish off, wash it off and let it set for a week to dry. Then go get some marshmallows, Hershey bars, and graham crackers, set the desk on fire and enjoy some s'mores.

Re: For the love of all that is holy...

#7

Re: For the love of all that is holy...

Yonak

Great story, L. I especially like the vision of the yoga pants and Jackie sunglasses. I don't have any suggestion on finishing techniques to try, but I do recommend trying your experimentations on scrap pieces of wood from here on instead of on the desk. Good luck and keep us posted.

Re: For the love of all that is holy...

#8

Re: For the love of all that is holy...

BilWil

I agree with Fred. If the desk is old it had an oil base finish and may have been given a coat(s) of shellac. It is possible that the water is causing the old shellac to cloud. I have put down spit coats of shellac as thin as 1/2 pound cuts to raise grain and seal dye. If you don't want to throw in the towel, I'd suggest that you consider a light sanding after the water based dye you are using and then sealing it with a coat of fresh, and I mean fresh, 1.5 to 2 pound cut of shellac. Sand with 320 and then move one.

Re: For the love of all that is holy...

#9

Re: Where to begin?

ljb

Thank you for such a kind and comprehensive response. I was going for a black glossy (but NOT shiny or plastic-y) finish with the grain's texture visible (but not the color). Sort of like my bathroom door. It's painted and opaque white-- I can see the grain texture of the wood. To answer your questions:

To strip I used Mostenbockers Lift-Off the first time, Citristrip the second, Mostenbockers the third (it works better, IMO). I applied the gels, waited 30-60 minutes, scraped with rubber/plastic scrapers, then re-applied gels and re-scraped. Then I scrubbed with stripping pads and the Klean-Strip stripper remover (the heavy duty stuff that has likely taken my IQ down a few notches by now). Then I waited over night before sanding, rather extensively, with a 220 grit paper and my electric hand sander. Then I very thoroughly cleaned off the dust with tack cloths.

Then I stained with the dye stain, waited over night and then used a foam brush to apply the glaze, and then finished it in long brush strokes with the grain.

I think I've narrowed down the mistakes in tries 1 and 2-- I basically just sanded too aggressively and too early-- and the sanding residue got stuck in the grooves.

But it's important to note that on the 3rd try, I was getting some weird greyish streaks *before* I sanded. The 3rd try mystifies me. The only explanation I can think of is that I used a foam brush to apply the GF Urethane topcoat on the desk top (but no other parts of the desk). I wonder if I made the topcoats two thick with that brush...?

For the record, the other parts of the desk look beautiful, exactly as I wanted them-- and I know some of those parts have veneer (and others don't). I used tee-shirt material cloths to apply topcoat on those pieces.

Thank you again for your help. I am so grateful. The kindness of strangers never ceases to amaze me.

Re: For the love of all that is holy...

#10

Re: For the love of all that is holy...

ljb

Good question. Does anyone live in a retirement complex at age 30 and have white painted doors?

Anyone, anyone?

Ok, just me. Well anyway, my doors appear to be solid wood, high quality and molded. They are opaque white with a slight satin finish. However, I can see the grain of the wood (the texture, I mean). And it is cool.

I used the glaze primarily to enhance the texture of the wood. It's cool-- very. I like it.

Re: For the love of all that is holy...

#11

Revelation: the dye didn't penetrate

ljb

It occurs to me that this might be relevant information:

When I stripped and sanded after tries 1 and 2, I noticed that the dye had not penetrated the wood as the dude at the store told me it would. The wood was a bit darker, but certainly not black...

So if the dye should have colored the wood permanently, then perhaps there is something in the wood resisting my efforts?

This is way harder than pretty much anything I've ever done, in case anyone's wondering. The Federal Rules of Evidence were cake compared to this.

Re: For the love of all that is holy...

#12

Re: Where to begin?

Steve Schoene

It appears that your stripping has not been effective. The strippers you have used are among the weaker varieties out there. The most effective strippers are those containing methylene chloride. It's a hazardous chemical so you need good ventilation and serious gloves, etc. Not just an open window or two but real air movement. But, MC strippers are much quicker and will do a more complete job. Follow the directions on the label about neutralizing the stripper chemicals before refinishing.

If properly stripped, dye should penetrate and a concentrated mix should get to a dark shade. (note: when dry it may look dull and grey, but when coated with a top coat it will darken considerably. You can judge the final shade and color by wiping with mineral spirits, while wet, it will look almost the same as the final appearance. For really black, a second application of dye after the first has dried can be helpful. But, in general, if dye isn't dark enough the best solution is to use a stronger concentration.

Your next step should not be a "glaze". Glazes are, essentially by definition, applied over wood already sealed with a film finish top coat. Dye doesn't seal the wood. Glaze is not designed as a good sealer coating.

With the dye getting to a sufficiently dark color I would then seal it with a coat of dewaxed shellac. Zinsser Seal Coat is the most available.

Then a couple of coats of varnish should give you a sealed, durable finish.

Another approach to achieve the look you want would be to thin a black colored oil based enamel paint. It won't take much thinning to ensure that it will reveal the grain of the walnut and still remain opaque. Even two coats shouldn't fill the pores of the walnut.

Re: For the love of all that is holy...

#13

Stated Simply

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Fed Rules of Evidence "Do we let it in?"

Wood dye "Did it get in?"

See? cake :D

Re: For the love of all that is holy...

#14

Painting walnut .. it makes me queasy

Yonak

Re: For the love of all that is holy...

#15

Re: Stated Simply

ljb

Haha, yes. Exactly.

Re: For the love of all that is holy...

#16

OT - any given area of law is incomprehensible

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

until you've studied it long enough to grasp the underlying concepts, at which point, if introduced to a new area of law, you will find that almost everything you learned in mastering the first area has no applicability whatsoever.

Bill, not a lawyer (though I've been mistaken for one), but once had the pleasure of stunning a rather talkative lawyerly colleague into silence with a ten-minute exposition on California Worker's Comp law, with which he had never worked.

We were good working partners and even friends, and he did have the grace to thank me and to mention to others that he'd learned a lot about Worker's Comp from me that day.

Re: For the love of all that is holy...

#17

Re:me too but he asked for black

Steve Schoene

Personally I love walnut. I'm making walnut countertops right now, trying to give them a bit of the rich ness you would get with some age. Fortunately the wood wasn't steamed so it has color variation.

My schedule begins a dilute dye of lemon yellow. (Really looks awful when it dries.) Then a seal coat of dewaxed garnet shellac, followed by oil based pore filler tinted with a mix of burnt umber and raw umber pigment. (If not filling just use a pigment stain in the same colors.) I added one more coat of the dewaxed garnet and am now wiping on a number of coats of Waterlox Original/Sealer. With the shellac, and the pore filler or stain taming the yellow the end result is walnut that has some years and pretty much hides the fact that it has been dyed and stained. My guess is that the pigment will help keep the walnut looking rich, offsetting the tendency for walnut to fade over time.