Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

How thin can you practically build a torsion box? *LINK*

Posts

How thin can you practically build a torsion box? *LINK*

#1

How thin can you practically build a torsion box? *LINK*

Scott in Montana

I'm considering building a vacuum press frame as described on the Joe Woodworker website (see link below). With floor space being at a premium in my shop, it would be my hope that I could hang this torsion box veneer table top high on the wall or even suspend it from the ceiling when not in use. Anyhow, weight would be a major consideration.

I've made torsion boxes before but they have always been at least 4" thick. Can I build a 3' x 5' torsion box table top using 1/2" baltic birch ply on one side and 1/4" on the backside with a 2" thick interior frame work on maybe 12" centers? Maybe thicker skins of 3/4" and 3/8"? The article states that a flat table is a necessity.

Thanks for your input.

Scott in Montana


Vacuum press frame instructions at Joe Woodworker

Re: How thin can you practically build a torsion box? *LINK*

#2

You might look up some of Ian Kirby's work

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Kirby was big on torsion boxes for a time. He did an article in Foine Workwooding way back in Issue 32 on torsion boxes, and, as I recall, he went on at some length about design parameters and limits. If I recall correctly, the thinner the box, the closer the spacing on the web; but don't rely on my memory, which has the porosity of a spider web without the grippiness. I have that issue, but it's in a rather inaccessible location, and I'm up against an inspection deadline on a project on our house, followed by another deadline; maybe someone with a better organized collection can help.

Googling "torsion box construction" brought me 110,000 results, some of which are no doubt about the suspension system on VW microbuses and other subjects related only vaguely to your question - but still, you might find something of value that way.

Re: How thin can you practically build a torsion box? *LINK*

#3

Re: How thin can you practically build a torsion b

Barry Irby

The thinner the box, the less strength. The thinner the skins, the less strength. The wider the spacing on the ribs, the less strength.

I have not looked at the instructions on the Joe Woodworker site, but it seems to me that the box needs to be really flat and able to withstand the vacuum. (I am lusting after a vacuum setup myself). Based on nothing more than instinct, I don't think a 1/2" skin over ribs on 12" centers would be good enough and I am certain 1/4 would not be enough. I think if you put that in a vacuum bag the 1/2" would be somewhat concave between the ribs and the 1/4" would come close to failing.

There would be less force trying to twist the box out of a plane. I would start with a box with 1/2" ribs on about ten inch centers each way and make the about 1 1/2" wide. once I got the squares set up I would insert an 'X' of 1/4" plywood in each square to support the skin more uniformly and I would make both skins out of 1/2" or 12mm baltic birch. There is no mathematics supporting this, its a design done on the fly based on experience and nothing more.

Re: How thin can you practically build a torsion box? *LINK*

#4

JL

Re: How thin can you practically build a torsion b

JL

Can you test a hollow core door section? I'm not saying purchase or anything. You can often find used/damaged doors. I figure if you could test one to "destruction" so to speak, that would give a basis for comparison.

I've used hollow core doors to act as "structural" members for sets before. I've been surprised at their toughness. They are basically really thin skins over a cardboard and thin lumber frame.

Re: How thin can you practically build a torsion box? *LINK*

#5

Bob

Re: How thin can you practically build a torsion b

Bob

I made my frame press out of 1/2" particle board with ribs at 6" centers. The sides are about 3" high and the whole box was topped off with a sheet of 3/4" mdf with polished lamintate top and bottom. The laminate makes for a very nice seal for the vacuum and not much glue sticks to it. As for the thinness of your torsion box I have made them down to 1 1/2" thick with 1/4" mdf skins for desks and they work quite nice but wouldn't work for a vacuum press with a thin top layer. You could add the mdf/laminate top to a thin torsion box as long as the ribs in the box are close enough together to prevent deforming the top under pressure but you might end up with so many ribs that the box gains enough weight to not be as useable.

The Joe woodworker site is correct that the top layer you are pressing against must be flat and must stay that way under pressure, i.e. not deform into the spaces between the ribs.

You might want to start with just a vacuum bag setup that you can roll up and put away when not in use. They aren't as handy but do the same job. Then all you need is a flat workbench or table to setup on.

Bob

Re: How thin can you practically build a torsion box? *LINK*

#6

Try it and see

Jesse Cloud

Build a small, say 2 foot square sample and crank up the vacuum, see what happens...

Re: How thin can you practically build a torsion box? *LINK*

#7

Ellis Walentine

Agree with Bob *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

Ian wrote a torsion box article for AW in the good old days, and he explained that a denser grid with thinner skins is actually stiffer and lighter. In the case of a vacuum table, you don't want any deformation in the flatness of the reference (top) surface at all, so the ribs should be close enough together that whatever thickness of top skin (+/- any additional platen material), it should be supported on a grid that doesn't allow deflection under maximum working stresses. The calculations here would be quite involved, but if I had to make a gut recommendation, it would be something akin to what Bob has recommended here.

Ellis


Kirby article

Re: How thin can you practically build a torsion box? *LINK*

#8

THE solution!!!

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

I did a lot of research for the two articles (Adjustable Assembly Table and Torsion Boxes) I wrote last year for the Dec/Jan 2010 issue of American Woodworker. Frankly, you just need a flat torsion box that will stay flat. It doesn't need to be thick or heavy.

Correct me if I am wrong, but you will only be vacuuming pressing veneer on flat surfaces directly on the torsion box. Anything curved will have a curved "mold"?



Stay with me until the very end.

First, here is an 8' long X 18" wide X 3" thick wide torsion box I made as a demonstrator for my article- The skins are 3/16" hardboard (Masonite) which was smooth on one side and fuzzy on the other. I was short on hardboard so I made the 2-1/2" tall cross web pieces from 1/4" pegboard. I used yellow glue and no mechanical fasteners to assemble it. In the pic it is supporting over 300lbs of bricks at mid-span! It deflected less than 1/2" at mid-span. It was light too- it weighed less than 30 lbs! I used it for a scaffold for awhile until I used it to wash the ceiling on my wraparound porch. By the time I was done the hardboard was so saturated the glue joints eventually failed.

Load test:


Glue-up in progress:


My article provides complete construction info, including how to make a flat construction platform (you gotta start flat to end up with something flat), how to cut the web pieces accurately, quickly, and easily (MUCH EASIER than the method used by David Marks and the Wood Whispers!!!), and a complete discussion of how a torsion box works and what makes it so strong.

Now, here is the secret to success in your application. If your vacuum bag will seal against the top surface of the torsion box, not the bottom, all you need to keep the vacuum from collapsing the torsion box or deforming it, is to drill a small (1/4") hole in the bottom skin in each void/cell. That will allow atmospheric pressure into the voids so the force will now be pressing on the underside of the top skin and not trying to squash the torsion box, all the while the table will stay flat with no stress on it at all! Simple, huh?

Re: How thin can you practically build a torsion box? *LINK*

#9

That's pretty neat Alan...

John in NM

And here I've been lugging scaffold planks made of 2x's around for going on 5 years :D

I've no immediate plans for a vacuum bag set up, but I am working on a duplicating machine and I'll likely use a torsion box for the base.

Re: How thin can you practically build a torsion box? *LINK*

#10

Any used resin impregnated honeycomb? *LINK*

Scott in Montana

All of these answers have been of great help! I'll go to the library today and check out your article Alan. Thanks again.

Now just to add another twist to my question; I stumbled across this resin impregnated honeycomb. (link below) The price isn't bad if the freight isn't outrageous. I would think that it is a cardboard-like material that is stiffened and strengthened using a resin. I have read about thicknesses up to an inch. Does anyone know about the weight of this material?

So I was thinkin' (did you smell the smoke? :b )... How about a 3' x 5' sandwich of 1/2" mdf or baltic birch, 1" of honeycomb, 1/8" door skin, 1" of honeycomb, and finally 3/8" baltic birch? Rolling glue on all interior faces. I'd probably use maple for the exterior edges and top this with a smooth piece of Formica or some other countertop veneer. This would be about 3 1/8" thick, but shouldn't be horribly heavy.

I'd sure welcome all of your input as I'm sure I am overlooking something obvious.

Scott in Montana


resin impregnated honeycomb

Re: How thin can you practically build a torsion box? *LINK*

#11

Re: Any used resin impregnated honeycomb?

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Honeycomb is great stuff, and very lightweight. It is used heavily in aircraft construction. There are two problems with using it in your application-

1. Gluing and getting a good bond with the skins can be difficult (requires good clamps, sandbags, or vacuum press, and the right glue.) A good bond between the skins and web is essential!

2. You are back to the same issue of putting pressure on the entire torsion box since you won't be able to effectively drill holes in all the voids.

Do you want a dance floor or a vacuum bagging table? I think you are over-designing this. The only reason to have a thick skin is to prevent local surface deformation caused by mechanical clamps or hammering!!! If you vent the voids, the vacuum won't cause the torsion box to deform- the vacuum will not put any pressure on the torsion box at all!

Don't be put off by making all those halved joints in the web- my article shows how to do it really quickly! You need to decide on your spacing and make a simple jig, similar to a box joint jig, then you can cut an entire tables-worth of full length web pieces (not short pieces!) with perfectly spaced notches in about 5 min. And assembly is easy- slip tab "A" in slot "B" No piecing, no brads, no cutting the last row to fit!!




Re: How thin can you practically build a torsion box? *LINK*

#12

Re: Any used resin impregnated honeycomb?

Scott in Montana

I think you're right Alan. We engineers are usually a bit paranoid and hence the often used "over-engineer" term. It's a well deserved term. 8)

I will have to refer to your article to view your method of creating the flat reference surface to build the box on. On previous torsion boxes I've built I have partially relied on the thicker surface sheet material to make achieving true flat easier.

Your method of cutting the core webbing looks far superior to my cutting bracing to fit.

Thanks again for all of your input. It's really appreciated.

Scott

Re: How thin can you practically build a torsion box? *LINK*

#13

Rick L

Re: Better info

Rick L

http://books.google.com/books?id=cjAnhBR2kLAC&pg=PA88&lpg=PA88&dq=torsion+bars+workbench+top&source=bl&ots=ak3pMDiUZu&sig=ajvR14s5hKrRN-8SsavnMRx0vuA&hl=en&ei=vE3wSqThAseUtgeGvdH6Bw&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=3&ved=0CBQQ6AEwAg#v=onepage&q=torsion%20bars%20workbench%20top&f=false kirby bench

http://www.woodworkersjournal.com/uploads/imports/PublicationsArticle/ian_kirby_torsion_boxes.pdf - shows the kirby tricell core

http://steve68steve68.blogspot.com/2008/02/torsion-box.html - for the math

http://www.amazon.com/Woodworkers-Essential-Facts-Formulas-Short-Cuts/dp/1892836211/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1289233180&sr=8-2-spell

I've been making torsion boxes since Reading the early Kirby articles in FWW 30 years ago. I've seen so many bad articles over the years making a simple prcess more complicated and with no understanding of the process. These links should help. Horners book is one of the best resources you can get. I find the nothing method just slows a quick process down and if you want to make quick curved torion boxes the method used by Kirby with butt jointed frame parts and a simple staple gun can't be beat. The idea is to male the frame fast and it's the glue on the skins to hold it all together. Beware of the many articles on making torsion boxes...

Re: How thin can you practically build a torsion box? *LINK*

#14

Better info??

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

I might take exception to the "better info" title- maybe different info. From somebody who has an engineering background, who has also made many torsion boxes, and whose article research included actually reading both books which are on my shelf, I think both books miss the point of what the OP needs.

Kirby's book is a bit dated and his WWJ article is dealing with the architectural use of TRICELL which is great for curved and compound surfaces. Kirby's veneer presses are mainly mechanical and as such need a two torsion boxes that have flat AND strong surfaces and strong structure since they are placed under considerable compressive loads. If you understand the principle of a vacuum press, you know that one designed like I described is under zero compressive load, so therefore only needs to provide a reference surface that stays flat.

Horner's book (actually just a chapter) jumps right into the engineering and associated math as if it were something a typical woodworker would or could use to compute required dimensions and strength for a given torsion box design or to make one. When in fact, without a lot of missing data such as strengths of materials tables, etc., etc. and a knowledge of stress and strain, it is impossible for him to do that. In fact, if you look at the Engineered Wood Product's Association literature you will find a nice little statement that says detailed engineering, math, computer analysis, etc. only gives them only very a general idea of the strength of a particular design, for realistic data they test many, many samples, often testing to failure. There are just too many variables that are hard to control - materials (thickness, density, compressive modulus modulus, modulus of elasticity, bending, etc. etc.), glue (properties, method of application, compatibility with structural materials, etc. etc,), just to name a few. And those are in controlled facilities not a home shop.

Then you get into design issues- what is important- size, weight, performance? They are not all mutually exclusive, but there is a relationship between all of them!

The bottom line is, though there is a lot of info in Horner's book, I frankly don't see it useful for a woodworker wanting a "cookbook" solution to building a torsion box. That is one reason why you won't find any articles that do so. They tell you how they made ones that worked for them, in their application. I agree, not all articles are based on sound engineering. Those that are, provide enough engineering theory so you know why the skins can be thin for some torsion boxes (like an airplane wing), but must be thicker for others, and what function the web serves, why web height is important, and why it must be securely attached to the skins, etc. etc.

What is the "nothing method"? If you mean "notching method" don't knock it until your tried my way, especially if you use pieces, glue and a brad nails to put the web together. My way requires one non-critical setup of a scrap wood fence, requires no precise measuring, always results in a square table and just simplifies assembly.

Re: How thin can you practically build a torsion box? *LINK*

#15

Question

Bill Tindall

I think I recognize a "better mousetrap".

If one doesn't subscribe to the magazine referenced is that information currently available elsewhere, anywhere?.

Re: How thin can you practically build a torsion box? *LINK*

#16

Re: Question

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Bill, much of the info is contained in posts I made on North Carolina Woodworker, but I don't think the theory/engineering info is there. You can always order single issues from their website- it is in the Dec 2009/Jan 2010 issue #145.

I have a PDF of the proof copy I can email, if you send me your address.

When I was looking I ran across a more recent first page so there must have been a few last minute edits, so I can send both. It is tough to convince a magazine editor that engineering is interesting, they want nice photos of chips flying, fancy planes, and sexy power tools. I had a significant amount edited out.

I actually had a companion set of articles in that issue- there was too much material for one. One article covered torsion box design/making the torsion box while the other one covered how to make adjustable legs to turn the torsion box into an adjustable height assembly table- a total of 12 pages! I even shot a video tour of the table legs in action which is on the AWW website.