Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

What now?

Posts

What now?

#1

What now?

Gary Smyth

After letting it sit for a several life intervening weeks I got back to the chest on chest on chest. Mistake. I forgot what I was in the middle of and clearly didn't cover all my bases when I returned. The top chest has a 2-2-1-1 arrangement for the drawers. I checked and rechecked the jig, ran a test then routed out the stiles for the 4" rails You can see the result with rail test pieces. Because the rail is only 4+" the alignment at the cross is critical. The 4" high test rail in the pic is 1/64 shy of 3/4" thickness so I can recover a tad. However, the mismatch in the center lntersection is 1/16". Apparently when I flipped the stile to do the routing I compounded a problem and doubled some error. Now what? I'm looking for suggestions as to how to recover from, or cover, the error. Do I use a slightly wider than 3/4" rail board and then "cheat" the dado? If so what tool do I use for that? Can I fit a sliver in the gap and make it look decent?? Only the outer edges of the joint will be somewhat covered by the yet unmade drawer lip. I'm not up for cutting and tenoning and grooving (for wood drawer slides and dust panels) all new stiles. Since losing the past three weeks I need to beat the weather and if possible make what I have here work. Otherwise, no finish until spring. Am I now relegated to painting the cabinet (not necessarily a bad thing). I have options and compromises to recover, but I'm looking for suggestions.

Re: What now?

#2

A.J. Hamler

Re: What now?

A.J. Hamler

I've done that before.

What I did is what you suggest -- redo those vertical members in slightly thicker wood, something that matches that extra wide center dado. Then just sand the vertical members to fit where they go into the upper and lower slightly-smaller dados. It will never be visible, at least it wasn't on the one I did that way.

A.J.

Re: What now?

#3

Various considerations

Bill Tindall, E TN

First, let my applaud your efforts in tackling a complex, and useful, piece of furniture. What you learn in its execution will serve you well in future projects. When it comes to furniture making it's "nothing ventured, nothing gained". The kind of mistake you made haunts me every time I leave a complex project and come back too it.

Your terminology and lack of the "big picture" in the picture has me confused. In a chest of drawers, presuming that is the project, the horizontal members are typically called "drawer blades" or "drawer dividers" . The vertical dividers must have an accepted name but I have not encountered it nor could I find it in any of my references. I call them "vertical dividers". So, as I understand the problem, the dadoes for the vertical dividers are too big by 1/16". Furthermore, you intend to use lipped drawers.

The lipped drawers makes it unlikely that anyone is going to notice a uniform 1/16" difference in vertical divider thickness. If you are going to succeed in making this kind of stuff you need to learn to sharpen (the key to success in using) a hand plane. Then coax, by planing, a vertical divider into fitting. If you are confident to do so, make the dado for the top and the bottom of the vertical divider the same size. I would do it with a chisel but a table saw would work. A 1/16" taper on the vertical divider will be noticed.

The flash has obscured the wood in use. If it is plain grain it will be very difficult to hide the joint if a filler piece is added to fill the gap. The way to proceed here is to tightly fill the whole dado whilst matching grain orientation (tedious) and re-cut it. Then make horizontal cuts with a chisel across the joint line and skillfully fill these to simulate horizontal gain lines. A skilled repair person could pull it off. I probably couldn't.

Philosophically, I avoid exposed dadoes in this kind of application. I like to stop the dado 1/4" from the front of the divider, then notch the vertical divider to fit.

Re: What now?

#4

Finishing problem?

Bill Tindall, E TN

What prevents you from finishing any time of year? Don't answer weather. I need details because they can be overcome.

Re: What now?

#5

Re: What now?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I'm gonna bet you knew the answer before you asked the question. Whenever something like this happens to me (and it does) I start looking for any solution other than remaking the parts. Eventually I always face reality....that the problem will drive me nuts if I don't do it right. Replace the vertical elements.

PS....remember, scraps are your best friend when it comes to test cuts and fitting.

Tom

Re: What now?

#6

Shop is unheated garage/ "barn".

Gary Smyth

I could move all into my house but not a viable option. I'm still a way away (drawers need to be made and soon the cold will set in and from experience hands will freeze, glue will not glue, tools and wood will be too cold, and finishes won't stick. Building a plastic sheetedntusernt "room " with a heater (my two options, kerosene heater or a propane heater) is not safe.

The wood is maple, exterior, with the dust panels, backs plywood, and the drawer runners and supports poplar and maple.

Re: What now?

#7

A point worth repeating

Bill Tindall, E TN

I never pay much attention to the exact thickness of the wood I prepare for a project so long as it all gets planed the same time. All my cutoffs from a project go in a waste basket. When I need to fit something out comes a scrap piece to make test cuts upon, or use as a gauge block. When I need a repair morsel, out comes a scrap to match grain. When I need to practice a cut, out comes a scrap. Etc.........

Re: What now?

#8

This is exactly why

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I ALWAYS buy extra wood.

Re: What now?

#9

Re: What now?

Fred Davis

Since these are drawer openings , I would put a Dutchman in the front of each gap and remember to layout dadoes more carefully next time..

If you install a thicker piece like A.J. suggests it looks like you will be making different size drawers which is a PITA.

I would suggest if you insist on dadoes for this operation, learn to lay out your dado's on center , rout a 5/8Th's dado and using any thicker stock like 3/4" take a little off both sides or all off one, this gives you a chance to remedy small errors in manufacturing.

FredD

Re: What now?

#10

Re: A point worth repeating

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I save cutoffs and scraps from the wood for each project. I mark each scrap as to what it was cut from and put them all aside until that project is completed. The time I spend doing that and the time it takes for me to use them for test cuts later is small. But the time it saves me from making mistakes is great.

Another lesson....mill all your wood a little longer than needed. Never mill or thickness any part already cut to finished length if you don't have to. Even a small amount of cutoff can be valuable later.

T.

Re: What now?

#11

Ellis Walentine

Design your way out of it

Ellis Walentine

I'd ask myself the question, what do I want here? The answer would be four dados that line up with each other and square to the rails and the cabinet. Forget about the dividers. I'd toss 'em. Take a framing square and a layout knife and mark the left and right shoulders for all four dados. If you haven't glued all that stuff together, take it apart and re-dado to the new lines. If you have, clear out to the new lines with a paring chiselThen make two new dividers that fit the new width. Make the dividers a tight fit and plane to finish thickness to achieve gap-free joints.

In the future, you might want to consider stop dados for this joint, as the through ones look pretty funky.

Ellis

Re: What now?

#12

Re: Design your way out of it

Gary Smyth



Big improvement. Not perfect but getting good enough for the girls I date. I need to sand and clean up. Bonus, the wider divider (1") will provide some additional visual space between the lips of the drawer fronts (necessary in order to match what are already on the other bottom two portions of the chest) when they are closed.

Re: What now?

#13

Ellis Walentine

100% better, Gary

Ellis Walentine