Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Thoughts about purchasing 3 phase tools?

Posts

Thoughts about purchasing 3 phase tools?

#1

JL

Thoughts about purchasing 3 phase tools?

JL

Say you had a chance at purchasing some gently used industrial machines. They are 3 to 5 hp.

Where do you draw the price line and say, this is what I'll pay and no more? Is this a reasonable idea?

I figure I'll either have to get a 3 phase converter ($350-500) for one. I don't know if I could even feed enough power for one of those. My other choice is to replace the existing motor (or motors) with "regular" 220 V motors (again $300-500).

While I don't really NEED a planer (I have my DW 735), the thought of getting a nice 15" or 20" planer does appeal to me - if I could be reasonably confident that it was a rational choice. I have no idea as to how easy it would be to swap out a motor - and I am not sure if I could even power the converter. I've got a 30 amp line with 10 gauge wire.

Thoughts +/-? TIA.

Re: Thoughts about purchasing 3 phase tools?

#2

Just wander over to this forum over here *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

and listen to the experts at Old Woodworking Machines.

The one thing to guard against at OWWM is that these guys are serious gatherers of machinery. Where I am sometimes a bit embarrassed that I don't have a precise count of my hand planes (somewhere around 40-50, I think; they're cheap at garage sales, and I find the best attitude toward temptation is to succumb), these are people who will have 75-100 machines, average curb weight 500-700 pounds each, who have built three or four extra buildings to store them, and who will drive across four states over a weekend to pick up some machine bought at auction, sight unseen except for the fuzzy picture on the auction site.

A lot of them are machine collectors - that is, they're more intrigued by the machine itself than its toolness. But they can tell you more than you knew you needed to know about three-phase power and its applications in the home shop.

Lurking on OWWM actually taught me to get rid of some of my machinery and focus on a few tools that worked. I'd rather frighten pieces of wood than spiff up old iron.


http://www.owwm.org

Re: Thoughts about purchasing 3 phase tools?

#3

Re: Just wander over to this forum over here

Gerald Gibbs

i think its owwm.com

Re: Thoughts about purchasing 3 phase tools?

#4

Re: Just wander over to this forum over here

wilbur

The forum where you can ask questions is at owwm.org, as Bill noted.

The website with lots of photos is owwm.com.

Re: Thoughts about purchasing 3 phase tools?

#5

Re: Just wander over to this forum over here

Gerald Gibbs

the sites are related. if you are at .com and click on forum you get .org.

Re: Thoughts about purchasing 3 phase tools?

#6

The converter doesn't take quite as much power...

John in NM

As it is basically a three phase motor running at idle. You might be ok with a 30 amp feed, you might not, its going to depend on how much you tax the machine.

You might also look into a VFD to power the machine, if you're buying a converter rather than building one a VFD might end up being a cheaper option.

Re: Thoughts about purchasing 3 phase tools?

#7

Ellis Walentine

Re: Thoughts about purchasing 3 phase tools? *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

I've run many 3-phase machines in my shop over the years, and there's no mystery to it. In my last shop, we had a 15hp rotary converter that ran the big planer, dual drum sander, 36" bandsaw and a few smaller machines. We had static converters (Cedarberg Industries, IIRC) for a couple lathes, the 16" jointer, the Porter pin router and the mortisers. With a static converter, which is what I assume you're talking about in that price range, you lose about 25% of the power of the motor, but otherwise the machine works fine. And, if you get one that is rated for a larger motor, you can run a couple machines simultaneously, although you can't start them at the same time. In any event, the worst that can happen is that you blow a breaker.

By all means go for the heavy iron. If you plan to use a lot of three-phase machines in the future, get a big rotary converter. Three-phase motors are much cheaper than single-phase, so if you ever need to replace a motor, you'll save money there. Of course, resale value might not be as much, but heavy iron is usually worth it.

Ellis


Cedarberg Phase Converters

Re: Thoughts about purchasing 3 phase tools?

#8

JL

I went, I read...

JL

So there are several of options. Static conversion, rotary phase conversion, VFD as well as switching out the motor.

Is it worth buying though? I'll ask.

Re: Thoughts about purchasing 3 phase tools?

#9

As far as thickess planers go.....

Dick Coers

Usually, you will be getting into some big hp with an industrial planer. My Yates American 24" planer has a direct drive, 7.5 hp 3 phase motor. I use a home-made rotary phase converter, and a 30 amp circuit is not enough for all that. I can take a 1/4" pass on a 20" wide panel if I want to. Planers like this are made to run a couple hundred board feet through them at a time. It does a good job on surface quality, but not as good as the high speed "bench top" machines with new blades. Then you have to consider the weight. I've moved this thing twice, and it has never been on the floor. It sits on the 4x6 stock that the shipper brought it to me. I had no way to get it off the forklift, all the way to the floor without some major effort on a long bar. So I gladly let it sit on the beams, taking up a ton of room in the shop.

You can't beat the heavy iron for production, but I suggest you match your machinery to the work you do.

Re: Thoughts about purchasing 3 phase tools?

#10

JL

Re: As far as thickess planers go.....

JL

I would basically like to have a 15" planer. I want something heavier than my 13" Dewalt. I found some used 15" and 20" planers - but they were 3 phase. I can get a new 15" for $1700 (single phase). Obviously I don't want to spend that much on a converter and a used planer.

I figure a new Dewalt would run me $500-600. My old DW 735 is over 5 years old. It is in relatively good condition - but I would like to plane wider boards on occasion. I also realize that it is not getting any newer. I've had to replace the shroud. Ideally I would replace the bottom plate (but not at the prices that Dewalt charges). When I saw the auction listing for the cabinet shop, I thought - how about their planer - then I saw that it was 3 phase.

If I'm going to bid, I want to make an informed bid.

Re: Thoughts about purchasing 3 phase tools?

#11

Suggestion

Bill Tindall, E TN

Find an old Powermatic or Delta 18" machine. There are lots of them out there. A 5 HP motor will run them just fine. It will not cost a fortune to buy a new or used 5 HP single phase motor if you need to replace a 3 phase. The machine will never loose value, in fact what you could sell it for will go up over time.

As far as surface quality, I have never seen a "home shop" bench top machine that will match the finish I get off our Powermatic. When properly adjusted there is no detectable snipe and no detectable knife marks. We have put tens of thousand bdft of lumber through it and it still is essential in new condition.

Re: Thoughts about purchasing 3 phase tools?

#12

Moses Yoder

Re: Thoughts about purchasing 3 phase tools?

Moses Yoder

I bought a VFD from Ebay to convert my 1-1/2 HP Powermatic 66 table saw. I read the instructions and wired it myself then had my brother who is an electonic engineer look it over before I turned it on. I had everything wired right and hit the power button and it has purred real nice ever since. A larger motor would need a larger VFD but the principle would be the same. The VFD is pretty simple and relatively inexpensive.

Re: Thoughts about purchasing 3 phase tools?

#13

VFD's

Bill Tindall, E TN

They are wonderful on a grinder or lathe as they provide variable speed.

Re: Thoughts about purchasing 3 phase tools?

#14

Sale on Phase converters *LINK*

Galen Vetterick

I was directed to ENCO for a possible group order and see they have phase converters on sale. Know nothing of this brand but you might just use for rough price if you go three phase equipment.

Also

Don't know your location but I could get three phase power when I lived rural and the city here says you can pay to get three phase. Price subject to how close it is they have to run to your shop.


http://www.use-enco.com/CGI/INPDFF?PMPAGE=22&PMKANO=270&PARTPG=INLMPA&PMCTLG=01

Re: Thoughts about purchasing 3 phase tools?

#15

JL

Went to the auction - bids got too high

JL

The total for a converter and a machine would have been more than a new single phase machine. So, I didn't bid any further.