Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Variable Frequency Drive

Posts

Variable Frequency Drive

#1

Variable Frequency Drive

Thomas Norton

Looking at a tablesaw that has a 3ph motor and would like some input on a VFD.

You help would be great!!

Re: Variable Frequency Drive

#2

Re: Variable Frequency Drive

Phil Joines

Running a 3PH motor from 1PH with a VFD you loose about 20% of the HP. The VFD needs to match the HP and the motor and line voltages. On most I've seen it's a bit hard to hit the start and stop buttons so they need a remote switch. Some of the older units produce a high pitched squeal. I have 4 of them from 1/2 to 3 HP on lathes and a grinder/sander and haven't had any problems. Got them surplus of EBAY.

Re: Variable Frequency Drive

#3

Re: Variable Frequency Drive

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

De-rating the hp of a motor running on a VFD is a common misconception. When you run a VFD on single phase, you don't de-rate the motor, you de-rate the VFD. A 2 hp motor will still develop 2 hp whether the VFD is powered by single or three phase power.

The de-rate issue revolves around the fact that in a three-phase input situation, you have THREE bridge rectifiers... all piling their DC power onto the link-voltage 'rails'.

If you run a three-phase inverter from a single-phase source, the input rectifier might be carrying a very substantial current... because all of it's equivalent power is being drawn through smaller rectifiers... not to mention a few 'other' things.

When you rectify a three-phase power source, the output voltage from the rectifier never drops below 50% of the peak voltage. This makes it real easy to filter and provide pure DC to the rest of the equipment.

However, when you rectify single-phase power, the output voltage of the rectifier drops to zero 120 times a second. The task of filtering this to provide pure DC is much more difficult.

The standard rule-of-thumb is to derate the VFD by 50% when operating from a single-phase source. Thus, if you want to run a 5 HP motor, you need a VFD rated for 10 HP.

The "rule" is basic 1 phase / 3 phase math. Power in a 1 phase circuit is V * A * pf. Power in a 3 phase circuit is V * A * pf * 1.732 (sq. root of 3).

So a 3 phase 1HP VFD probably has components rated for 2.34A, but when connected to a 1 phase source, the input will draw 4.05A from the supply. If the diodes used in the rectifier section are not capable of taking 4.05A through them, they fry. The ripple issue is also important, that's why we round up to 2.0 (50% de-rate) instead of 1.732 just to allow for extra capacitors that will come with the larger size.

Many small VFDs however are using components on the rectifier side and the DC link that are so cheap that they can afford to oversize them without much cost. So up to 3HP (typically), they don't need de-rating. But those are usually the ones that SAY they can have 1 phase or 3 phase input. If they don't expressly say it, then they may not have the oversize components and you run a risk of frying the rectifier. In addition if you don't have enough capacitance to smooth out the extra ripple in the DC link, you can end up damaging the transistors on the output side. The net effect is the same to you; the magic smoke is released and it is never worth trying to shove it back in.

Re: Variable Frequency Drive

#4

Re: Variable Frequency Drive

Bill Howatt

I'm in general agreement with your post but I find the last paragraph a bit confusing. Surely, if a VFD indicates it is rated for X HP with single phase input, it will perform the task.

Bill

Re: Variable Frequency Drive

#5

Kneale Brownson

I read Alan's message to say exactly that

Kneale Brownson

I took it to mean you need to be certain the drive SAYS it's set up for single phase input. Otherwise, you need to get the larger size.

Re: Variable Frequency Drive

#6

Re: I read Alan's message to say exactly that

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

The point of my final paragraph in my rather wordy treatise (sorry about that) was that you really need to check the specs on any unit before you use it with single phase input, unless the VFD is oversized to begin with. I have a number of Ebay units, but was lucky enough to find manuals for all of them after extensive INTERNET searches. You also need the manual to set all the programmable functions that these units typically have.

Most VFD's have both hp and kW ratings. Some won't say, some will say they operate on single phase with no de-rating- heavier duty components- while others will tell you to de-rate anywhere from 20% - 50%.

There is no restriction (other than cost!) on using a VFD rated for 5 hp with a 2 or 3 hp motor! There are other gotcha's however- like never put a switch between the motor and the VFD- if you open the switch then (for some reason) close it while the motor is still running down, the reverse current created by the motor will likely cause the magic smoke to be released from the VFD! Also, you need to be careful when running a motor below its rated nominal RPM, especially with a load, over extended periods, and if it is not an inverter duty motor (which has higher temp windings and often better cooling). Due to the way VFD's work by varying the frequency the magnetics of the coils are not the same and it is easy to overheat the motor. That is why most lathes equipped with VFD's still retain mechanical speed ranges. The one exception is the Oneway DVR. That should be problem with a tablesaw.

Lathe w/VFD and tach:



Drill Press w/VFD (with remote run switch and speed pot) and tach: