Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Need advice with Jet motor noise

Posts

Need advice with Jet motor noise

#1

Need advice with Jet motor noise

Gerald

I have a Jet 10" Table Saw with 3 hp 230v motor.

When the motor is powered off and winding down I hear a click, which I assume is an electric(?) brake, then the table saw rumbles for about two or three seconds and stops.

The table saw runs and cuts just fine when powered up, but sure sounds scary when powered off.

I removed the three belts from the motor and when powering down the motor it makes the noise but thankfully not as loud. I guess the table saw cabinet was amplifying the noise through the belts.

It seems to me that the electric brake is the culprit. The cost of a new motor from Jet is over $500 bucks. Yikes!

Is this something that can be fixed by ordering a kit of parts or is a new motor necessary.

Your comments are appreciated and thanks in advance,

Gerald

Re: Need advice with Jet motor noise

#2

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Need advice with Jet motor noise

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

I don't think that motor has a brake.

What you're hearing is the centrifugal start winding switch clicking back to 'start' mode as the motor winds down. If that's the case, it's normal operation...

Re: Need advice with Jet motor noise

#3

Re: Need advice with Jet motor noise

Gerald

Good Morning Jim,

It's not the click I'm concerned about, it is the rumble or chatter that follows after the click. It's definitely in the motor as I removed the belts.

Gerald

Re: Need advice with Jet motor noise

#4

Re: Need advice with Jet motor noise

Phil Joines

With the belts removed, see if you can move the arbor either sideways or back and forth. If you can the bearings probably need replacing. There may be a motor repair shop in your area but they are getting hard to find.

Re: Need advice with Jet motor noise

#5

Re: How long have you had the saw ?

Chuck Lenz

And how old is the saw ?

Re: Need advice with Jet motor noise

#6

Jim Rahbe, Bedford Texas

I suspect loose arbor set screws. *LINK*

Jim Rahbe, Bedford Texas

Gerald,

I think the click in the motor is normal. It sounds to me like you have the same problem I had a couple of years ago.

My four-year-old Jet Cabinet saw developed a clatter when shutting down. Definitely a metal on metal sound, but nothing I could duplicate when moving things by hand.

I remembered reading on WoodCentral that this type of noise could be caused by loose set screws on the arbor pulley. Sure enough, that is what it was.

I decided to take it apart and replace the bearings while I was in there. I documented my adventure in case you are interested in doing the same thing.

Jim R.


Jet Motor Clatter on shut down

Re: Need advice with Jet motor noise

#7

Re: Need advice with Jet motor noise

Gerald

Well, I pulled the belts again and checked the shaft on the motor, but there isn't any play. I checked the fan to see if that was loose, nope.

I checked the set screws on the arbor and any other screw or bolt I saw and all were tight.

Rats.

Re: Need advice with Jet motor noise

#8

Re: How long have you had the saw ?

Gerald

The saw is about eight years young.

I called Jet service and let the tech listen to the noise on the phone and he said he ain't heard nothing like that before. He didn't realize it was as loud as it was.

He also suggested I take it to a motor repair shop. There was a good repair shop about 15 miles from here, but I see they closed up.

That 3 hp motor must weigh close to about 60 or 70 lbs. No easy job to remove. I'm not looking forward to that!

Thank you for the suggestions, I do appreciate it.

Gerald

Re: Need advice with Jet motor noise

#9

Re: I suspect loose arbor set screws.

Gerald

Jim,

Your article was a good read and very well documented. Thanks for the link.

Yes, the click is normal. The chatter I get is also with the belts off the arbor. The noise is not as loud, but it is definitely in the motor and it is always after the click is heard, every time.

The saw cuts perfectly fine glue ready surfaces. The saw starts up normally and it also purrs along nicely when in use.

Gerald

Re: Need advice with Jet motor noise

#10

Re: I suspect loose arbor set screws.

Galen Vetterick

Gerald

Did I miss if you checked the pulley on the motor? If the rumble is when the motor is running and no belts it would not be the arbor pulley for sure.

Key gone or partially sheared or set screws loose. Bore have sloppy fit to shaft?

There are times when the armature ends up slipping on the shaft but hope it is not that.

Just asking.

Re: Need advice with Jet motor noise

#11

Check the Motor Bearings, then

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

You can actually do this right on the saw if you have a good micrometer.

1. remove the pulley on the motor shaft.

2. Clean the shaft.

3. Crank the the elevator either all the way down or all the way up. Just make sure you've got it locked against the stops.

4. Turn your motor on, then off.

5. Same rumble or quiet?

6. a) If noise is present, take your mic, carefully put it on the motor shaft away from the keyway, and read and note the measurement.

b) If no rumble, skip 7. and 8.

7. Holding the mic in place, start the motor then turn it off.

8. If the mic reading has changed more than a 10Kth, you've likely got a bearing going.

OTH: Ff starting and stopping the motor when locked against a stop eliminates the sound, you have an issue with the motor pivot arm, the trunnions, or the motor mount. Check all of the bolts on the motor mount as well as the on the pivot bar yoke and the trunnions. All it takes is one of those to work a 1/4 turn loose to generate a harmonic rumble as you describe. In fact, while your at it, check the bolts holding your top in the base.

Good Luck

Re: Need advice with Jet motor noise

#12

Re: Centrifugal start winding switch ?

Chuck Lenz

From your description of the problem, and what Jim DeLaney says, I wonder if it doesn't have something to do with the centrifugal start winding switch.

Re: Need advice with Jet motor noise

#13

Ellis Walentine

Another reply

Ellis Walentine

Gerald, I put your question to Scott Box, who has been an executive with Delta, Jet, Powermatic, Steel City, and now General. Here's his take...

Hi Gerald,

Not being sure exactly which model saw you have, It sounds like a full size cabinet saw.

The symptoms you are describing are in fact quite common on saws of that type. It is most likely motor regeneration.

The click is a centrifugal switch going from run mode to stop. It will cause the shudder you experience as you are quickly stopping the blade, arbor and all three belts as well as both pulleys. That is a lot of mass when added together. (It still occurs when you remove the belts but you are only stopping a two pound motor pulley)

I have seen this on all manner of saws of this type, nothing uncommon, Just keep your belts properly tensioned and be sure your motor mounts are tight. It is not hurting anything.

Scott

Re: Need advice with Jet motor noise

#14

Re: Another reply - Thank you

Gerald

Ellis,

That is excellent news! Thank you for passing my help request on to Scott and posting his reply.

I just got home and was going to try Mark's check list on the motor before I made arrangements to have it pulled from the saw. I found a motor shop about 20 miles away who agreed to give me an estimate (for a fee) before starting the repair. I sure am a happy guy I don't have to do that now.

Thanks again to Jim R. for the link to your article and to the other member replies with helpful suggestions.

Mark, thank you for your excellent detailed check list, I appreciate your taking the time to do that.

Gerald

Re: Need advice with Jet motor noise

#15

Re: Another reply Your Welcome

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Gerald,

I have the same saw. When I first got it, I quickly found that I had a problem with what was called a "bang start" where the saw would start with a loud thump. Jet was having a bunch of these, and it was assumed to be a motor problem. They replaced my motor, put in a softer start capacitor; made no difference.

They were about to send me yet another motor when I tried starting the saw fully elevated. No Bang.

I then tried it fully lowered. Silent and smooth.

We then found that the pinion arms for the motor carriage were just slightly over-bored so the play, when translated to the end of the "lever", allowed the whole deal to jump when the motor was started. When it was locked against the top or bottom stops, the tension negated the "play" and the saw started smoothly.

They sent me a whole new saw.

Point here is that just a very slight amount of play in any of the mountings will cause a sound that will be amplified by the cabinet. While Ellis may have, indeed, found the answer, my JET doesn't do what you describe, so before you go further, check all your motor mounting bolts and such. Won't take but a few minutes, and you might just get lucky. :D

Re: Need advice with Jet motor noise

#16

Update on my JET table saw noise

Gerald

The noise is gone! Curiosity and dumb luck fixed it.

I was going to ignore the noise and just use the saw, but the noise just seemed too violent to do that. Besides, my wife would come out to the shop thinking something was wrong when she heard it in the house. It was that noisy.

I reached out to Ellis again and after he heard the noise over the phone, he agreed something was wrong. He said he would contact someone at JET.

In the meantime I was going to remove the motor to take it to a motor repair shop. But before I did that, I was curious if maybe I could eyeball a bad or broken part on the motor.

I removed the motor fan cover (three screws) to inspect the fan more closely. The fan looked OK so I removed it. I noticed there was another cover behind the fan held with two screws. I removed the cover and I was now looking at the centrifical switch. There was very fine dust, a lot of it, in that small area, so I blew it out with an air hose.

Everything looked OK as far as I knew, so I decided to put everything back together on the motor. I don't know why, but I thought I would try running the motor (the belts were off). The motor sounded different, quieter. I figured what the hell, I put the belts back on and started the motor. I turned the saw off and I couldn't believe it, the noise was gone!

I must have turned the saw on and off a dozen times, no noise. I still couldn't believe it.

I spent the rest of the day putting the saw back together. I was a little apprehensive about turning the saw on after all this work, feeling the noise would be back. I tried the saw several times again, no noise.

My wife is happy and I certainly am. Curiosity and dumb luck. Perhaps I should be saying Curiosity and keen troubleshooting fixed it.

My thanks again to Ellis who never hesitates to offer his friendship, kindness and support however he can. You are a good man, Ellis.

I received a lot of good information and suggestions here on WoodCentral and I am thankful for that.

Hopefully, my problem and solution would be helpful to some one here in the future.

Gerald

Re: Need advice with Jet motor noise

#17

Ellis Walentine

I passed this advice along to Jet

Ellis Walentine

They had never heard of this particular problem either, but now they have. Sorry you had to be the test case, Gerald, but I'm glad you found the solution. Blowing out the motor housing sounds like a good item to put on our routine maintenance checklist.

Ellis