jointer question
Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)
The safety rules for my jointer say: Never joint a workpiece that is less than 10" in length. I'm not about to test the wisdom of the manufacturer but I'm curious as to why 10". Why can't I joint a 6" board?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
jointer question
Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)
The safety rules for my jointer say: Never joint a workpiece that is less than 10" in length. I'm not about to test the wisdom of the manufacturer but I'm curious as to why 10". Why can't I joint a 6" board?
More difficult to control
Dale Lenz
I learned the hard way, lucky was not hurt. Small length of lumber will tend to kick-back, with your hand try to go forward, during a kick back on a jointer, scary to even think about it.
Re: jointer question
Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas
Oh, You can do it, but there is a reason why they suggest that, and you don't want to learn the hard way why.
My first job in a shop was down in Dallas back in the late sixties. I tried running a nice block of Genuine Mahogany about 4 x 6 x 6" over the jointer. I was lucky that my learning block was so tall. Before the leading edge made it to the outfeed table, I let it tip up at the back by applying to much pressure over the gap. As you might imagine, it grabbed it away, shooting it down the infeed table.
Of course, I jerked my hands back, and happily could still count to ten. If it had been 4/4 stock, I might not have been so lucky.
Even when you think you know all the hazards, and have done something like this a lot, there can always be some little irregularity that will get you.
Thanks for the reminder
David Yoho
This question and my anticipated answer reminded me that I've been needing to order a couple new push blocks for use at my eight-inch jointer. I just put the order in and they're on the way. Thanks for jogging my memory!
The answer to your question is - possibly. I can do it on my own jointer partly because the cutterhead opening size allows enough of the wood to land on the out-feed table before leaving the in-feed table. The other part that allows this to work is the use of a push block to not only push the stock but to exert downward pressure on it as it travels onto the out-feed table. Should a kickback occur, the push block will keep your hand clear of the cutterhead.
As to push block preference, I have mine. Others own and use all types from shop-made to aftermarket. The blocks that came with my Delta jointer were wimpy at best and didn't provide enough distance from the cutterhead should things go wrong. For years I've been using a pair of push blocks from Shop Smith and love them. The grip on the stock is good, the blocks are beefy and have a solid feel to them, and they're larger than the standard issue blocks that come with many new jointers.
I'm replacing mine because the rubber/foam material is wearing away. While I suppose it's possible to repair them myself to save a few bucks, it's more cost effective to me just to get new ones. I can still work with what I have until the new ones arrive.
Yes, it's possible to joint a 6-inch piece of wood, but I'd never try it without using a good safe push block!!
Re: Thanks for the reminder
Doug Ridley
Maybe you should ask my high school friend who lost 3 fingers and half his thumb in shop trying to joint a 6" long board.
Re: jointer question
Barry Irby
My High School Principal had been a shop teacher. His students asked the same question. He demonstrated on a short piece of wood and it kicked away and jointed off the tip of his pinky. I met him years later, but the demo was stuff of legend. I think he was better suited for Administration. He ran the place with something less than an iron fist.
push blocks
Bruce, a MN Galoot
I don't have a tailed jointer, but I use my router table a lot, and push blocks are an absolute necessity for me. I made them using the rubber-backed mouse pads that computer stores give away. They've worked really well, and the price is right.
Re: jointer question
Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)
Wow! Scarey answers. Thanks for the info everyone.
Re: Thanks for the reminder
David Yoho
Doug, was your friend using a push block or just his hand? No way I'd attempt it without a good push block for obvious reasons. That's why I like the Shop Smith blocks. They're larger and beefier than most and keep your hands well away from harm. Have a look at item "B" in the link -
http://www.shopsmith.com/ownersite/catalog/mvsafety_safetykit.htm
Same here...
John in NM
Push blocks for almost all jointer operations.
I do face joint pieces down to about 6" length, but I wouldn't recommend it to anyone not already comfortable enough with their machine to make the question moot. Very light passes, straighten up the face on the bandsaw first if necessary.
I rarely take more than 1/16" on a face cut with any board, rarely have kicking problems either.
Re: Thanks for the reminder
Doug Ridley
David he was just a kid and was in the shop just before class started and turned on the jointer, grabbed a scrap and bingo, he recoiled and I saw him and away we went to the hospital. Obviously we shouldn't have even been allowed in the shop until the teacher got there but rules were pretty lax in 1950 and we all did pretty much anything we wanted to. I think about it nearly every time I use the jointer and I too use the Shopsmith push blocks left over from the days when I had the Shopsmith.
What's the problem?
wilbur
I never have a problem jointing a 6" long board with my #7 hand plane. 
The Danger...
David Yoho
Posting responses here, and anywhere else online for that matter, where the subject of safety is concerned requires one to bare the weight of giving their answer a deal of thought. The danger is that because I write that I do something that may be questionable and get away with it, someone could always decide it should work for them equally as well. We should all know what feels comfortable to us regarding safety in our shops and I always work by the rule - "if it doesn't feel comfortable to my mind, don't do it".
That said, I want to clarify why I personally feel comfortable jointing a 6-inch board on my jointer even though the warnings against it are known. I may or may not have made all these points clear in my original response.
1. The throat opening between the in-feed and out-feed tables on my jointer is only 1 3/4", which allows a 6-inch board ample area on the out-feed table before the trailing end exits the in-feed table.
2. My Shelix cutterhead is set for a 1/16th-inch cut.
3. I assumed the question referred to face jointing but edge jointing would work for me the same unless the width was less than I felt comfortable with.
4. I always use push blocks while face jointing, primarily because they grip and help feed the stock over the jointer better than using my own hands. My hands tend to dry out, thus losing their grip, after running a bunch of wood through the jointer and I never liked the idea of wearing gloves in the shop. However, there's no way I will use the factory supplied push blocks that came with my jointer and many others. For me the main issue with them is they are small and cause the operator's hands to be too close to the action. I apply downward pressure on the front end of the push block to keep the wood flat on the out-feed table as it feeds across the cutterhead. A larger and more substantial push block makes this possible for me.
In the end, I think it's up to each person reading a response such as this to look at their own situation and determine how they compare. Too much of a throat opening and it would be a no-go for me. Too deep a cut - the same. No proper push blocks - no again.
No matter what someone writes about and says works for them, if it still doesn't feel safe - don't try it. It's always better to error on the side of caution than not. I think the memory of your friend's accident will always be a constant reminder to you while working in the shop and will help keep you safer. Sadly, hard-learned lessons are often the best teachers!
jointing on 6" board
del schisler
I run a 6" or so upright with out push stick's. Hand's or finger's aren't close to the cutter. Now the wood is thicker than 5" maybe 6" so it is safe. or at least . I haven't had any problum's . Now when i flat joint i use push stick's ONLY . Measure the opening between infeed and out feed and see what it is. This will give you a idea if 6" can go thro with out kick back. Use good judgement Only. If you don't have that maybe a different hobby ???
Re: The Danger...
Doug Ridley
I should add that I do NOT joint any thing that is less than about 1 foot. Just what I do.
I vote for a #5, :")
Dale Lenz