Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Plywood chairs and plywood quality *LINK*

Posts

Plywood chairs and plywood quality *LINK*

#1

David Barnett

Plywood chairs and plywood quality *LINK*

David Barnett

Portuguese designer Marco Sousa Santos has an interesting new line of plywood chairs (link below), which I like, but would not dare sit on.

Context Furniture has some clever designs, too:

http://contextfurniture.com/wmsidechair.html

I guess I just like the look of stacked plywood edges. I've used it to encase the stereo power amp I built and sliced it and glued it into sheets of veneer to cover floor-standing speakers. Anyway, now I want seating for my own use. Not only does plywood satisfy my aesthetics, it allows me to address some personal structural issues, as well. But I've run into a problem.

Lately, all the so-called Baltic Birch plywood I've found is poorer quality than what I used to buy. Voids, while small, are much more frequent and the veneers seem less dense. Edges seem more porous than ever and do not finish as nicely as I'd like. Anyone have a good source for top quality BB (Euro, not Asian)? Preferably East Coast?

I've called several Woodfinder sources but no one seems to acknowledge the quality issues and trends, so if someone has personal experience with this product from a supplier who will ship, please let me know, either here or by PM. I have what I need for now but anticipate needing more by April.

It suddenly occurs to me that Wood Central has not yet had a chair contest.

Anyway, while most BB plywood will adequately intercede between my considerable avoirdupois and terra firma, it would be nice to use the better quality stuff.


img

Marco Sousa Santos for Branca-Lisboa

Re: Plywood chairs and plywood quality *LINK*

#2

Re: Plywood chairs and plywood quality

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

No answer to your east-coast sources. However, my supplier distinguishes between Russian, Euro, Chinese, and USA sources of plywood; he wants to be sure I know not all "Baltic Birch" plywood is the same and that I'll get what I pay for.

Re: Plywood chairs and plywood quality *LINK*

#3

Lee Grindinger

"Those who cannot learn from history are doomed...

Lee Grindinger

"Those who cannot learn from history are doomed to repeat it." - George Santayana

Wendall Castle tried this technique 30 years ago. It bombed in every way it could.

I tried it on a small scale 29 years ago..., and it bombed in every way it could.

On top of that, it's one of the most miserable ways to work wood there is..., no fun at all.

Lee

Re: Plywood chairs and plywood quality *LINK*

#4

FLW tried and failed too

Joel

I saw some Plywood chairs at Taliesin West, made by Frank Lloyd Write. There were uncomfortable and sad...really, can you imagine such a thing from some one every one thinks was a genius... I am not so impressed either.

Joel

Re: Plywood chairs and plywood quality *LINK*

#5

David Barnett

Naysayers! You know that just encourages me.

David Barnett

Actually, I don't doubt you one bit. I've seen hideous and shoddy attempted plywood furniture and can appreciate your caveats, Lee. What I have in mind is a bit different, however (I know, they all say that), and besides... it will go with my magnificent 8-foot long stacked workbench slab (edges facing upwards) atop its ebonized oak trestles.

Despite the two angle grinders dedicated to Kutzall Extreme carving wheels, there will be no excessive retro organic sculpting. These seats will be rather rectilinear and quiet looking. I'm currently in a terrazzo, plywood, aluminum state of mind, but eventually I'll go back on my medication. For now, though, I must follow where my path leads me.

I assume when you say "it bombed in every way it could", you meant aesthetically, structurally, and commercially. Am I missing any, or does that pretty much cover it?

Re: Plywood chairs and plywood quality *LINK*

#6

David Barnett

Re: FLW tried and failed too

David Barnett

I've heard that FLW chairs were not only horribly uncomfortable, but also highly prone to tipping and guests had to be assisted to get them close enough to the table. When anyone complained of this, it brought great ire and invective from the designer. Supposedly, he would not allow his brother Russell, who was rather tall, to sit on them or be photographed near one because it sabotaged the scale of the piece.

Re: Plywood chairs and plywood quality *LINK*

#7

Lee Grindinger

In EVERY way, Hah, hah, ha

Lee Grindinger

Alright, first I'd say go for it, but on a small experimental scale. I'd never want to stand in the way of artistic exploration. :)

Here is the problem. The inescapable truth is that half the grain is running opposite to the other half. Wood moves. What you complete as smooth and silky and wild in color soon becomes wild in texture. You can't keep a finish on this surface and it becomes very rough as the veneers cycle a few times through their seasonal movement. This movement also spits out fillers which you will need to handle the voids.

This use of materials fails due to wood movement, plain and simple.

As to working it, half is end gran, half is longitudinal..., this makes machining and sanding tough due to the vast difference between the respective grains.

I'll be happy to fill in any blanks you may have concerning this style and if you choose to go for it we can add your name to the list..., Castle, FLW, Grindinger..., it's good company. :)

Re: Plywood chairs and plywood quality *LINK*

#8

David Barnett

So you're saying...

David Barnett

... and it does seem especially daunting... due to the ever-encroaching corrugations between moving cross-layered veneers (something I had not considered), as seating goes, one should likely avoid Toby-scooting in one's Speedo due to possible splintering? Inasmuch as this is truly "bombing" in the worst way, I might be prone to actually take your advice. Then again -- Castle, FLW, Grindinger -- fame is tempting. Regardless, I can assure you, no pictures will be forthcoming.

Re: Plywood chairs and plywood quality *LINK*

#9

Lee Grindinger

If I can save...,

Lee Grindinger

If I can save but one Speedo from destruction my work here is done. :)

Re: Plywood chairs and plywood quality *LINK*

#10

Another FLW

Gary Smyth

quirk. At Fallingwater the furniture is designed for a person 5'8 +1/2". (Incidentally that was his claimed height.) Anyone taller than him was "not worth architectural consideration". He also did not much care for guests so he made the mountain spring fed guest swimming pool a straight 6' deep --no shallow or incline parts only cantilevered steps in.

Re: Plywood chairs and plywood quality *LINK*

#11

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: FLW tried and failed too

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

I also toured through Taliesin West and saw the plywood chairs. I have to say they were the most uncomfortable things I have ever sat on. He might have been an influencing force in design, but from what I have read and seen he had some basic failings in execution, he never has been a favorite of mine.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Plywood chairs and plywood quality *LINK*

#12

Frank Lloyd Wright was a great self-marketer

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Every few years Fine Homebuilding used to run an article on the restoration of a Frank Lloyd Wright house. The bulk of the article was always how they corrected serious - egregious - design flaws that did things like encourage rainwater to enter structural members.

No question, the man could draw. But his understanding of actual, functioning architecture appears to have been minimal. In spite of this, he gets way more attention than other architects who designed inspirational buildings that work: just in Northern California, two obvious names are Julia Morgan and Bernard Maybeck.

Were I offered a Frank Lloyd Wright house, I'd take it just long enough to sell it, and put the money into an abode that wouldn't drive me crazy for maintenance, or get me shot by his fans for changing it.

Not that I have strong opinions on the subject or anything.