What a Tease *LINK*
Dustmaker Mike
Here we have a door made of wood that has survived a long long time. It used some joinery which they said made it really strong and be able to last this long. But well read for yourself.
Old Door
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
What a Tease *LINK*
Dustmaker Mike
Here we have a door made of wood that has survived a long long time. It used some joinery which they said made it really strong and be able to last this long. But well read for yourself.
Old Door
Re: What a Tease
Stuart Johnson
The remarkable joinery is mentioned twice but no photo or description of the joinery.
I am not too sure about the accuracy,
Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas
When I read "Using tree rings to determine its age", this would indicate that they had a tree-ring chronology of poplar trees that grew in close proximity to where this one grew, with indices from the present, all the way back to the time claimed.
Having a pretty good idea of how quickly poplar decays under normal conditions, I would bet they don't. Maybe carbon dating would get close, which is probably how the archeologist determined the approximate age, but the writer, had just enough knowledge to know trees have rings to get it wrong. The mention of dendrochronology would probably cause a case of cerebral overload. ha
I hope some better photos show up, that looks pretty interesting how they ran the metal strap through a protruding bulge. If that is what I was seeing.
It looks, from the photo,
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
like they used cleats across the door, sunk into dadoes in the boards; but I can't figure out the canoe-shaped pieces across those cleats at what appears to be each board - straps locking the cleats in place?
Remarkable design, perhaps, but, if I'm reading the picture right, awfully complicated. Granted, they didn't have good glues - hide glue would hardly have held through a winter - but I would think pinning the cleats would have done the job.
Re: It looks like an open and shut case
George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA
Re:I dont think glue was invented yet
Moses Yoder
I think about the earliest evidence of hide glue was in the 1500 BC area. They probably would have had to rely on strictly mechanical fasteners. It just goes to show that installing a door to impress your neighbors is not a new thing under the sun. 
It is TV news
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
In my observation, darned few network TV reporters could go back and pass high school science courses, much less college courses. There are exceptions, of course; but their training does not necessarily lend itself to understanding the current state of any given science, much less explain it in non-scientific terms.
Actually, explaining science in non-scientific terms is hard for anyone, including for a good many scientists.
I concluded some years back that what much of what people refer to as the "jargon" of a discipline is, in fact, a language developed to articulate concepts that common language can't handle; so translating concepts, regardless of discipline, into something Aunt Edie or Cousin Fred can understand can be really challenging. That said, some jargon is inevitably insider language, designed to keep the uninitiated confused.
Two points for clarity...
John in NM
First, poplar in Europe is not the same as poplar here. Or maybe it is more clear to say that poplar in lumber yards is not the same as poplar in archeology. Lumber yard poplar is tulip poplar (Liriodendron tulipifera), European poplar - likely found in this dig and definitely found in certain Spanish gunstocks (the reason I know about it) is Lombardy or black poplar (Populus nigra) more closely related to aspen and cottonwood than with what we woodworkers call poplar.
Second is how they use dendrochronology to estimate the age. They're looking at patterns of wide and narrow rings, the patterns caused by fast or slow growth due to drought or flood on a year to year basis. The patterns are roughly the same across broad geographic regions, so it is not completely ridiculous to make an age estimate on that basis. They should be able to confirm the date with carbon dating, though there are wrinkles there too.
The article makes such a big deal about how "The door is very remarkable because of the way the planks were held together" and never tell us HOW! Very frustrating!
xactly what I was talking about
Dustmaker Mike
they never showed the joinery or told us about it. I wish there was a way to find the original story from the AP and see what was cut to make this story. Maybe Popular Wood Working or another Mag could do a wood working story on this.
Suggestion
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
Goto the page again, right click on the photo, choose View Image, when it come up, hold Control on your board and scroll the wheel on your mouse. You should be able to zoom the image up to full screen and see it and the banding more.
Looks like ship-lap joints in the three panels.
Re: What a Tease
Barry Irby
I just spent a lot of time trying to find out if a Bostitch Mini Palm nailer (PN50 would drive 16d nails. I looked at them at Lowes and they were attractive because of the small size, but I wanted to be sure it was powerful. The packaging said nothing on but what size nails it would drive. Also said nothing about how much air or air pressure it took. I asked at Lowes and got a blank stare. Went to their website and all it said was drives most common fasteners. Bought another brand at a different store because I could not trust the vague packaging.
Spent time looking at web sites on tile floors. One site had a video on installing some sort of roll of material and all about the glue and the trowel and how to lap the joints and which side to put up. Just failed to mention WHY and What it did for ME.
Does no one look at these things and say "What would the viewer want to know?"
Roll
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
Barry,
What you were looking at is called a "decoupling membrane" [sold under several brands and styles. What it does is gives a controlled amount of independence between the finished tile floor and the structure. Result is settling, flex, and vibrations in the structure won't crack tile or break out the grout. Highly recommended;especially were you have joists less than 2x12 DF.
Re: Suggestion
Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas
Hey Mark, I tried your suggestion, but it didn't work for me. However I did save it, and was able to enlarge it then, although it was fairly pixilated.
I would have assumed that if it was 5000 years old, that the planks would have been riven, since that would have been about 3~ 4000 years ahead of the first saw.
I could be wrong, but there seem to be quite a few really large knots scattered around the face of the planks. If that is what I am seeing, I am having trouble getting my mind around how the ancients would have managed that kind of wood with the tools available back then.
At first, I thought the bulge in the middle of each plank which captures the straps, were part of the plank, but I think I see fasteners in the bottom closest one. I wonder what type of fasteners those are.
I don't doubt that this is an old door, but I'll bet that it is not that old.
Do you think those are knots, or something else?
Knots - Not
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
I'll bet they're whole-branch pegs as they seem to stand proud of the surface by a fair amount and the are others seemingly in the mud next to the door.
I wouldn't be surprised to find out that the straps (vertical and horizontal) are actually bronze. If the environment was neutral in acidity, the bronze could easily have lasted as well as the wood.
We do need one of the WW magazines on this
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
journalists who understand the mechanics and technical stuff involved really need to be reporting on this. In the meantime, we'll all be a little frustrated.
Re: My Guess re joinery
Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio
The joinery looks to me like they might have assembled the door from green wood - undoubtedly split planks - and gouged out a split in the middle of each board. Then, they pried the split up, and inserted the battens between the plank and the (still connected at both ends) split. That way, when the wood dried, the split sections shrank enough to hold everything in place.
Just my guess...
Routed edges and dovetail cleats, & some biscuits
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
clearly done by the space aliens from Planet Festool
Could be the Gateway to Hell
Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas
I think I would be a little leery of just opening it right up. Might be a good idea to peek under it just to make sure. ha
Echo that
Ellis Walentine
The article makes such a big deal about how "The door is very remarkable because of the way the planks were held together" and never tell us HOW! Very frustrating!
Lousy journalism.
Ellis
Hey Boss
Dustmaker Mike
Maybe you should go over there and show them how to do an Article correctly. That way you can let the rest of know how it was joined together.
What a Sighting that would be.
We need Jesper, or one of our other European
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
members, on the case here.