Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

Posts

OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

#1

OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

Steve in Phoenix

I'm currently using my Weber grill for smoking meat, and the idea of an electric smoker is pretty tempting. But charcoal smokers seem very popular too, maybe due to lower cost?

Not sure which way to go...

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

#2

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I've never used an electric smoker.

BUT, I have smoked quite a bit of various meats on a CharGrill with the side fire box. Dry wood and charcoal only (none of that wet wood chip soot...).

I don't see any need to change...it's gooooood.

Jason

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

#3

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

Steve in Phoenix

I was looking at the Weber Smokey Mountain, but that Char Griller is mighty tempting. I like the way the firebox is completely separate from the food. How much do you need to babysit the Griller when smoking?

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

#4

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

Howard Norman

Steve, I have never owned an electric smoker but I knew the guy that used to operate the store at Crescent Lake and he used one there for years smoking trout that he caught from the lake. It did a very good job. That was 20+ years ago. The big advantage to me would be that you would not have to worry about the heat source, only the wood chips. I personally have owned and used an Oklahoma Joe wood smoker for 15 years or so. It does a great job. I don't think that company is in business anymore or at least the last time I tried to run them down I was unable to locate them.

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

#5

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

Stuart Johnson

I don't know how many members log into Woodcentral but there are at least that many opinions on how to smoke the best xxxxx.

This is just one: heat cooks, temperature and duration tenderizes the meat, meat option determines degree and time, smoke adds the flavor, fuel used for the smoke determines the flavor. In a nut shell I think a good electric smoker can turn out a very good product. Use the right heat and time for the meat add foil packets for smoke with the type of wood you want. You should have good results. Not championship results but good results plus the ease might have you firing it up more often.

We don't eat much beef anymore but when I use to do briskets I used an offset smoker, real wood not charcoal that was burned to good coals before adding to the fire box. I would then spend 12 hours carefully keeping the heat just right. After 12 or more hours I would wrap the brisket in foil and put in the oven at about 180 overnight. The result was some of the best brisket you could ask for.

I now drive 20 miles to a BBQ restaurant spend a few bucks and have some that is every bit as good in a whole lot less time.

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

#6

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

paul in AZ

You will no doubt have read or heard all the pros and cons of each system by now.

I bought a Traeger. The attraction here is being able to burn wood pellets that are fed from a hopper into the fire chamber by an electric auger. Much less tending than charcoal + using 'real' wood. That was the idea anyway.

I found the pellets were pricey and there was not all that much flavor difference in the various woods. Pellet feed rate [and thus temp] was reasonably controllable and the whole thing worked but not to a level that I would call wonderful by any means. Chicken came out w/leathery skin. Pork not bad but you couldn't just set it and forget it. Beef of course better on my Weber.

On balance it didn't seem worth fiddling with it. I sold it after less than 6 months of about once a week trying.

I realize that my view will likely be in the minority and that i may have quit too soon on the learning curve. If I thought I could put up with the PITA of tending a fire I would go with a dedicated charcoal smoker for the flavor. As it is a friend has a large brick pit and I get invited over once in a while for some real BBQ.

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

#7

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers? *LINK*

Stuart Johnson

If you want a good firebox type this is the one I have. You fill the large box with your meat. Ribs can be stand on edge, brisket or roast laid flat. A pan of water or juice is in the bottom to add moisture and some flavor depending what you use. The fire is in the small box with the temp being regulated with vents on the bottom and a damper over the chimney. You don't need to stay with it every minute but you do need to be around to keep the temp within range.


Brinkman Smoker

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

#8

I like charcoal but

Dustmaker Mike

I am thinking of changing it over to gas to hold the temperature better. I have cooked beef, fish, pork, and chicken on a Little Chief cooker my kids got me 12 years ago. I like to set it up in the morning and tend the coal during the day while I work around the house or yard etc. The biggest problem I have with it is keeping the heat even when the wind is blowing. I have a few pieces of sheet metal I use to put around it to stop the heat loss it helps but it is a pain. What I am thinking is using a propane burner under the pan to keep the heat and and add the charcoal like I do now to smolder the wood for the smoke. I might get around to it this year if I ever stay home long enough.

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

#9

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

Howard Norman

Paul your review is the first that I have ever read from a real user of a Traeger. I remember seeing one at a store years ago. I thought at the time the pellets seemed expensive. Glad to see that your experience confirmed my opinion. I recently heard that Costco was selling them but I have not seen them in the Prescott store.

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

#10

Clint Searl

Make your own

Clint Searl

I converted from charcoal to an electric that I made from two giant flower pots and an electric hot plate. Easier to manage and better results than the charcoal side-box type. Never gets too hot and only needs tending every hour or so.

Clint

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

#11

Re: Make your own

Steve in Phoenix

Nice one Clint.

Probably a little cheaper than the Big Green Egg!

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

#12

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

Thomas

I had a Char griller with a side firebox. I found it took too much tending to keep the temperature low and consistent, and I also had to rotate the meat a lot, as the temperature varied a lot inside from place to place (even with various configurations of an aluminum baffle inside I made to disperse the heat). Then I bought a propane Great Outdoors Smokey Mountain smoker and now I use that. It takes very little watching. A wireless thermometer with min/max temp alarms and I check it maybe once every 2 or 3 hours. I considered an electric, but didn't want to pay the $ and I didn't want to be locked into using wood pucks or anything like that. I think we all have enough wood scraps around to use.

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

#13

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

BrianA

I use a Weber bullet. Have used it for years and love it. Usually do pork butt. Put it in about 8 PM and at 7 in the morning come back to add charcoal for the last few hours of cooking. Very little need to do anything for around 12 hours. The Weber hold a steady temp for a long time. Use it all year round with great results. I think the holding of a constant temp is one of the benefits of the well constructed with heavyer metal than many of the cheaper smokers I have seen. But... a green egg would be fun to have but cost a bunch.

Brian A

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

#14

I have a weber smokey mountain cooker... *LINK*

Grant in Iowa

I have a Weber Smokey mountain cooker, which was around $200 back when I bought it 4 years ago or so. I find it very easy to control cooking temps using charcoal.

There's and entire community at The Virtual Weber Bullet web site to show you how to use it and many delectible recipes.

I went Charcoal because it seemed to me to be the classic way to smoke foods. You can also use wood in it instead of charcoal. I use wood scraps (Cherry, hickory, oak, etc.) as smoke woods. I keep a small bin of wood near my grilling stuff.

It is fairly efficient, using 1-2 chimneys of charcoal for an average 5 hour cook. There were days when I first got it that I was wishing for an electric model, but then I discovered the web site dedicated to cooking with it. Once I learned from following the examples of others, I am now very happy with the unit.

Check it out and make your decision after informing yourself.

By the way, people hound me asking when I will be making "Best Ribs in the Universe" again using the cooker.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa<---just smoked about 4 lbs of jerky today.


The Virtual Weber Bullet

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

#15

Re: I have a weber smokey mountain cooker...

Steve in Phoenix

Thanks Grant,

I use that website myself, though I use a Weber Grill at the moment.

I will probably end up with a Smokey Mountain. But I was wondering if charcoal produces a better end-product than electric, because the electric seems more convenient.

By the way, the brisket from that site is amazing. I smoked a flat cut (no point included), and it was the best we'd ever had. Added rub, smoked it at 225 (w/mesquite, big dry chunks) for 8hrs+/- until it hit 165, then wrapped it in 2 layers of foil, popped it in the oven at 300 until the meat was at 205. Awesome.

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

#16

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

Steve in Phoenix

Sound like the Weber is a great bet. There are cheaper Kamados than The Big Green Egg, but still pretty expensive. There are some really nice freestanding tiled ones. Maybe if business picks up next year...

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

#17

Re: I have a weber smokey mountain cooker...

Grant in Iowa

Steve,

I think an electric smoker is easier to obtain and hold a given temperature for a long cook. If you are not able or willing to spend an hour readying your food and the cooker, and able to check on the temp and make adjustments hourly, then I would suggest an electric smoker.

For me, I have come to greatly enjoy the art of creating a good fire, and tending it and the cooker vents for the duration of the cook. The process forces me to slow down my busy body routine and focus on a relatively simple task, which also results in enjoying the day. I place my cooker on a patio about 8 feet from the kitchen window from which I can easily observe a thermometer poking in through the top vent to ensure I am on track.

I cooked 3 racks of ribs a week ago and the temperature was stable enough that I felt comfortable leaving for the final 3 hours of the cook. Came back to the temperature still in the butter zone and some wonderful ribs.

You will find that there are days when wind or rain will cause a difficult time in holding a given temperature, however. On these days, you can carefully position the cooker or a wind baffle to help minimize the issue.

I would say that if you want a hands off cooker, then go electric, but if the art of cooking appeals to you, then you will be very happy with the WSM. If you do go electric, try to find a unit that doesn't require proprietary smoke biscuits or pellets, as you may want to use woodworking scraps to flavor the meat.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

#18

Oh, and you CAN have it both ways

Grant in Iowa

There are WSM owners who also use a hotplate as a heat source. Just clean out the charcoal pan and place a hotplate in the bottom with a smokewood tray atop of it and viola!, and electric WSM cooker.

I would say that in Pheonix you will have no trouble with the charcoal and maintaining a steady temp. Indeed, in the sun, you may be able to dry jerky with no fire at all... just smoke for the first hour using charcoal and then close it up and let the sun do the rest.

I should add that I had a similar Charbroil version before I got the WSM, and I would never go back. The build quality on the Weber is such that it is a much more tightly sealed unit.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

#19

Re: I have a weber smokey mountain cooker...

Steve in Phoenix

Grant,

All good points, thanks.

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

#20

Re: Oh, and you CAN have it both ways

Steve in Phoenix

Good idea about the hotplate. You're right about Phoenix. I've had trouble keeping the temp down in the summer.

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

#21

Re: I have a weber smokey mountain cooker...

BrianA

1-2 chimneys of charcoal? Do you ever try filling the ring with charcoal then dump 1 chimney on top of that and cook low and slow. I get about 12 hours out of it. I start a cook about 8-9 at night and about 7 AM I dump a chimney of lit coals in and get a few more hours out of it.

MMMMMMMMMMMMMM BBQ

Brian

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

#22

Re: Make your own

Brian Aust

Good Eats! :)

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

#23

Re: Make your own-lead in the glaze???

Tom Dunlap

Some pottery glazes have lead in them. I sure wouldn't want that in food! The heat from cooking could vaporize the lead into the food.

Tom

Re: OT - Electric vs Charcoal Smokers?

#24

Clint Searl

The pots ain't glazed

Clint Searl

But the meat gets delectably glazed with a half-inch smoke ring.

Clint