Re: I have a weber smokey mountain cooker...
Grant in Iowa
Steve,
I think an electric smoker is easier to obtain and hold a given temperature for a long cook. If you are not able or willing to spend an hour readying your food and the cooker, and able to check on the temp and make adjustments hourly, then I would suggest an electric smoker.
For me, I have come to greatly enjoy the art of creating a good fire, and tending it and the cooker vents for the duration of the cook. The process forces me to slow down my busy body routine and focus on a relatively simple task, which also results in enjoying the day. I place my cooker on a patio about 8 feet from the kitchen window from which I can easily observe a thermometer poking in through the top vent to ensure I am on track.
I cooked 3 racks of ribs a week ago and the temperature was stable enough that I felt comfortable leaving for the final 3 hours of the cook. Came back to the temperature still in the butter zone and some wonderful ribs.
You will find that there are days when wind or rain will cause a difficult time in holding a given temperature, however. On these days, you can carefully position the cooker or a wind baffle to help minimize the issue.
I would say that if you want a hands off cooker, then go electric, but if the art of cooking appeals to you, then you will be very happy with the WSM. If you do go electric, try to find a unit that doesn't require proprietary smoke biscuits or pellets, as you may want to use woodworking scraps to flavor the meat.
FWIW,
Grant in Iowa