Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Sub-woofer in cabinet?

Posts

Sub-woofer in cabinet?

#1

Sub-woofer in cabinet?

Hoa in Alameda

I'm designing an entertainment center. The dimensions are 46"W X 32"H X 18" D.

My question is related to a sub-woofer.

In the bottom compartment on the right (looking at it) side of the cabinet, I'd like to keep a sub-woofer. The sub-woofer's speaker fires to the right, with a vent port in the back. The right and the back sides of the compartment are totally open. The front of the compartment is a solid door.

When everything is in place, the back of the sub-woofer is 4" from a wall and the right side of the sub-woofer is 5" from the wall. There is about 2" of space on the left and the top of the sub-woofer.

Is this OK? Or will I mess up the acoustics big time?

Thanks.

Re: Sub-woofer in cabinet?

#2

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I wouldn't.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

The acoustics as related to the transmission of the sound from the sub-woofer to your ear would likely be fine. Low-frequency sound is non-directional--your ears can't determine its origin, so placement relative to listening position doesn't matter.

However, you will possible have other problems. Putting the subwoofer in the cabinet will cause anything in or on that cabinet that is even remotely loose to rattle, which will detract immensely from the listening experience. I look forward to the day when someone blasting their car stereo with overwhelming bass loses several parts off the car in a dramatic fashion. I will laugh. And point.

Just my thoughts. Worth what you paid for them. ;^)

Jason

Re: Sub-woofer in cabinet?

#3

Thanks for reminding....

Hoa in Alameda

Jason,

Thanks for your thoughts.

You just reminded me of an option I'm considering: cutting a hole on the bottom shelf of the cabinet so the sub-woofer will be sitting on the (wood) floor. This way the sub-woofer does not touch the cabinet.

-- Hoa

Re: Sub-woofer in cabinet?

#4

I wouldn't either...

Grant in Iowa

As a woodworker who got his start building dozens of subwoofers for people, I know a thing or two about combining cabinets and subs.

Here are some considerations:

-While it is true that the frequencies that emanate from a sub are non-directional, it is NOT true that room placement has no effect on a subs performance. For example, a subwoofer in a corner will sound very different from one in the center of the room. Often, you can improve the overall sound and balance of a system by moving the subwoofer a short distance within a listening room.

-A subwoofer is often designed to be placed directly on the floor. This allows the low frequencies to benefit from coupling directly to the plane of the floor.

-The port, or ports on your average home theater subwoofer should be about 2 feet or more from an adjacent wall or significantly sized plane. Closer will likely cause a peak in the speakers response at some point and thereby degrade fidelity.

-Rattles can be an issue, though that can be minimized with a robust structure.

In closing I'd like to say that due to the transitory and quickly changing nature of home theatre, I would try to design the unit to have more than one function, lest it be viewed as a finely crafted console TV cabinet in the future.

All of that said, I HAVE indeed incorporated a sub into a commissioned piece I did a few years ago and the customer is very happy. It really comes down to the customers priorities and if fidelity is more important than aesthetics. In that unit, I built the area for the sub quite robustly. I used 1" BB ply for the back of that compartment and screwed it into place. Wiring for the sub went through a 1" hole, and I made a piece of open cell foam that fit tightly into that hole with a small hole in the center for the signal cable to go through.

It can be done, but consider if it should be done, and if the appearance of the space is more important than the fidelity to you.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Sub-woofer in cabinet?

#5

Sure you can... *LINK*

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

I did, and have had no problems with rattling see my link below. The big difference yours and mine, is my sub fires forward. Hence the construction of the door. Also I'm no audiophile but it sounds good to me.

Scott who has built a few speaker systems himself over the years.


G&G side board, ent. system

Re: Sub-woofer in cabinet?

#6

Re: I wouldn't.

steve mackay

I WAS the 18 year old GI (in the barracks) WITH the $8,000.00 stereo. I know whence I speak. ANY speaker (from a giant Marshal to a little Bose 301) moves around (however little) with vibration. ANY speaker ! And it conducts said vibration to what ever its connected to, laying on or butted against.

I'll bet it would take a hundred years for the speaker to vibrate the TV (or Grandma's picture) off of the shelf.

But then again . . .