Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Making REALLY sturdy small tables?

Posts

Making REALLY sturdy small tables?

#1

JL

Making REALLY sturdy small tables?

JL

I went to Homecoming at my old college. I asked the boys at the Frat house what they really wanted/needed in ways of furniture.

They requested a couple of coffee tables.

My first thought is to have deeper aprons - instead of 3" aprons make them 4.5-5". This would also mean that the tenons and mortises would be larger.

I was then thinking about the tenons depth inside the legs. One thought was mitered tenons. Doable, but what does it really add in terms of strength? Another thought was interlocking tenons. Making the long sides tenons with two "tabs" and the short sides tenons having a single tab. The tenons would interlock inside the leg. Again, doable, I can see that it adds strength and still is easy to do. My next thought was an interlocking tenon and "pinning" the tabs of the tenon with a dowel. That way the tenons would interlock within the leg and be secured.

Any other thoughts/options to consider? Do ya'll think an interlocking, pinned tenon would last for a "reasonable" time in a frat house?

TIA.

Re: Making REALLY sturdy small tables?

#2

Re: Making REALLY sturdy small tables?

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

I agree that the miter wouldn't offer much. I have done the finger joint thing plenty times before with no problems. Or you could have the long tenon going through, with the short one reduced in height, pinning it, and protruding out the leg. But at some point, whatever you do to increase the strength of one part may be to the detriment of another part, like taking away too much of the leg.

Then it becomes a mater of choosing the best toughest wood for the parts. So what fraternity is this, Animal House?

Re: Making REALLY sturdy small tables?

#3

Re: Making REALLY sturdy small tables?

Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ

You might include stretchers around the bottom as well.

Re: Making REALLY sturdy small tables?

#4

engineering data on M&T joints

Bill Tindall

I have a publication for Franklin glue company that reports on the factors that affect mortise and tenon strength. Tenon length and width as well as wood species are most important with fit and glue also being significant.

Brief summary: a 2" long tenon is nearly twice as strong as a 1" tenon. A 3" wide tenon is about a third stronger than a 2". Strength in decreasing order: maple, oak walnut, poplar, with maple 50% stronger than walnut. The best glue is PVA, being 25% stronger than the passionately promoted hide glue. A perfect joint (+/- 0.002") is 10% stronger than a sloppy fit (-0.008")

Summary for ultimate strength, likely more than is needed: strive for a 3" wide maple tenon at least 2" deep. Get the best fit you can and glue it up with PVA glue.

Frankly, I don't see that there is any problem making a sufficiently robust coffee(beer) table that will even accomodate table dances. Dining tables can be made that hold up just fine and they have longer legs that put vastly greater load on the joint. Addition of a stretcher will enable you to make smaller legs(shorter M&T joints).

Re: Making REALLY sturdy small tables?

#5

Re: Making REALLY sturdy small tables?

John McGaw

Strong furniture for a frat house. From what I know, the safest in the long run might be break-away balsawood furniture suitable for a fight scene on a movie set. Putting that aside if you want something strong enough for this duty you need to start thinking outside the proverbial box.

Really thick pieces of hickory are essentially unbreakable. 4" hickory legs will hold up a truck. 4"-wide 2"-thick hickory aprons would be suitable for holding them together. Forget nice traditional M&T joints and start thinking about bolt-together corner brackets similar to those used for knock-down furniture but using at least 1/2" hanger bolts at each corner.

Or, if you have the resources, a table with an apron of 1/4" steel straps as wide as possible and held rigid by multiple "X" bracings which will also support the top. Add 1-1/2" thick-wall steel legs and weld everything together. Then your task is to pretty everything up with nice wood applied to camouflage the metal structure beneath.

All of this leaves out what one would use for the top on such a table. Any kind of wood is going to be susceptible to even the simplest burning, hacking attack during the next drunken brawl, errr, tea party so it would likely have to be made sacrificial. Some material like composite quartz might be a good choice for a more durable top if it can be obtained in sufficiently thick slabs. Large-radius bullnose edges and rounded corners might alleviate some GBH.

Offered with tongue only half in-cheek...

Re: Making REALLY sturdy small tables?

#6

Box

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I agree with John McGaw that a steel table structure topped by stone would probably be the strongest movable table; a cast-in-place concrete table might be a little stronger, but it would be hard to vacuum under it.

If you're staying with wood, though, how about a box structure? Build the "corners" of the box from hardwood - a perimeter frame - rout a rabbet around the vertical faces of the assembled frame, and glue-and-nail plywood panels in place.

The other issue you might consider is repairability. If the fraternity is as hard on furniture as you're implying, you might want a design that could feasibly be repaired when it gets broken.

Re: Making REALLY sturdy small tables?

#7

Re: Making REALLY sturdy small tables?

Gary Smyth



Sturdy, does the job, fits with any club house decor, suitable for abuse.

Re: Making REALLY sturdy small tables?

#8

Re: Making REALLY sturdy small tables?

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

How about a couple of old wooden cable spools? :D :D :D


img

Re: Making REALLY sturdy small tables?

#9

M/T fitting

wilbur

One of the things that Frank Klausz mentioned in his talk on mortise and tenon joints that I think is underappreciated is how well the tenon is fitted to the end grain sides of the mortise. This part of the joint will have a far smaller role in the strength of the glue up, since it's long grain to end grain, but from a mechanical standpoint, it's important for resisting racking forces.

The commercial woodworking old timers in our woodworking club have mentioned the same thing, which lends credence to this idea.

Re: Making REALLY sturdy small tables?

#10

Ellis Walentine

Rack resistance

Ellis Walentine

The things that make a good mortise & tenon joint -- tall rails, long tenons, good fit -- are all important for strength and rigidity, but for racking and tipping resistance, there is a lesson to be drawn from such items as Windsor chairs and sawhorses: splayed legs. The reason chairs and sawhorses have splayed legs is to distribute forces outward from their origin where the legs/base meets the top. When you do that, the outer edge of the leg or base becomes a fulcrum. To tip the piece, you must actually lift the top so that the whole piece pivots on this fulcrum. That's pretty hard to do, although I wouldn't underestimate fraternity people.

Two common ways to spread out the footprint are by adding trestle feet and by angling the legs outward in one or both directions.

Ellis


Re: Making REALLY sturdy small tables?

#11

Moses Yoder

Re: Cement

Moses Yoder

I think one way to build a coffee table sturdy and economically for a frat house would be to make a form and cast a cube of cement. You would want the top edges and outside corners to be beveled or rounded so that when they get drunk and fall on it they only cause temporary brain damage and not permanent.

Re: Making REALLY sturdy small tables?

#12

Ellis Walentine

PS  Quiz -- Where's the flaw in my sketch?

Ellis Walentine

Re: Making REALLY sturdy small tables?

#13

Re: PS  Quiz -- Where's the flaw in my sketch?

John Pappas

Hmmm...perhaps should be "lower shoulder".

Re: Making REALLY sturdy small tables?

#14

Dale Lenz

Cleats me?

Dale Lenz

Re: Making REALLY sturdy small tables?

#15

JL

Thanks for the responses.

JL

Keith - the fraternity is Alpha Chi Sigma, a professional science fraternity. It may not be "Animal House", but it still is a frat house. :D