Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Way OT; any flooring gurus out there?

Posts

Way OT; any flooring gurus out there?

#1

Way OT; any flooring gurus out there?

doug f, san clemente, ca

We're considering replacing our kitchen and family room floor and have found a limestone tile that we really like. Friend of mine heard a horror story about how limestone stains and discolors with any kind of water contact, i.e. water glasses left on a counter top can leave a white ring that won't come out.

Anyone have some actual experience with limestone flooring and reactions to water contact? We're starting to get cold feet. :D

Thanks for the help.

Doug

Re: Way OT; any flooring gurus out there?

#2

all limestone is not created equal

Bill Tindall

Personally I don't know much about limestone, but, I have been examining various rock for table tops and got engaged in a conversation about limestone with a person that has fabricated rock for many years. He happened to be using limestone as an example of how variable rock can be. He specifically mentioned how some varieties take days to dry out after sawing with the "wet saw" while others don't. This observation would indicate that some limestone is porous while some is not. You will need to rely on the experience of the rock supplier to guide you in an appropriate selection and the best sealer for whatever you select. Performance will depend on the sealer as much as the rock, according to this source. Personally, for a kitchen floor in a kitchen that gets used, I think a hard glazed tile is the only practical flooring.

Re: Way OT; any flooring gurus out there?

#3

Re: all limestone is not created equal

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

I agree with Bill, install a hard glazed tile. I put in porcelin tile myself in our kitchen, bathrooms, laundry and hallway. Think of how much of a mess you would have if someone dropped a bottle of catsup or mayonaise on the limnestone floor....yukkk.

Re: Way OT; any flooring gurus out there?

#4

An experiment...

doug f, san clemente, ca

Wow, I'm more confused than ever! Here's what we're gonna try. We have a big sample of the tile we like, so tonight we spilled ink, milk, ketchup and red wine on a tile. We'll let it set overnight, clean is up tomorrow and see what happens.

Results in the next episode.

Doug

Re: Way OT; any flooring gurus out there?

#5

Re: An experiment...

Sean Troy

Limestone needs to be well cleaned and sealed imeadately after installation. StoneTech is a good product but there are better and more expensive products out there. I was a contractor for a lot of years that specialized in Limestone,granite and marble in high end homes and businesses. My wholesale price for the best sealer was 180.00 a gallon years ago. No stain would get past it but the sealing process needs to be repeated at least every two years for the best protection. It can get expensive. email me if you have any questions and I'll try and answer them for you. Sean

Re: Way OT; any flooring gurus out there?

#6

The rock experts test

Bill Tindall

When he described testing rock for utility in kitchen counters he had something greasy in the mix of assaults as well as a "pigment" defined as colored stuff that isn't a water solution, ie dirt. Again, the durability of the sealer will be as important as the rock.

Re: Way OT; any flooring gurus out there?

#7

Exactly......

Bill Tindall

what my local rock expert said. What would happen in my home is that we would forget a resealing somewhere down the road and in a few years the floor would look like an irretrievably dirty floor in the high traffic areas.

I was shown some new porcelain products that look nearly identical to rock. The slate version would have fooled me from a distance of 5 feet. I suspect a limestone pattern is available but I didn't ask about it. When I think of limestone I think of gray crushed driveway and road rock so I didn't think to ask about limestone.

Re: Way OT; any flooring gurus out there?

#8

Re: Way OT; any flooring gurus out there?

Sean Troy

Limestone can be cleaned back to a new look pretty much however dirty it gets but you're looking at somewhere around a 1.50 per sq. ft. for cleaning or more. Porcelian is a great product. Slate is another great product but does need the same prep and care as Limestone.

Re: Way OT; any flooring gurus out there?

#9

Just FYI; after the experiment

doug f, san clemente, ca

OK, I cleaned up the tile that we messed up last night and here's the results.

Ketchup - didn't stain, no color at all, however the acid in the ketchup etched the surface of the tile to a dull, rough finish.

Red Wine - Very distinct red stain that did not come out with abrasive or even straight bleach.

Magic Marker - cleaned up easily with no effect.

Milk - no effect at all, cleaned easily.

Guess we'll have to rethink our choice.

Thanks for the help, guys.

Doug

Re: Way OT; any flooring gurus out there?

#10

Options

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Either that or quit drinkin' :b

:D

Re: Way OT; any flooring gurus out there?

#11

Re: Way OT; any flooring gurus out there?

paul in AZ

I sent this thread to my architect daughter who is completely redoing her own house. I thought she was using limestone for her kitchen counters. Wrong, but here is her response:

I did a soapstone, not a limestone. It�s in and gorgeous! Will try to get some photos later on today.

I wouldn�t ever do a limestone, we did a test in geology 101 where we had to go around and test different buildings on campus with acid to see if they were limestone. Limestone bubbles up and disappears with any acid. Not a good kitchen idea!

Re: Way OT; any flooring gurus out there?

#12

A different flooring choice would be easier!

doug f, san clemente, ca

Re: Way OT; any flooring gurus out there?

#13

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Just FYI; after the experiment

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Try an Oxy-Clean type product on the wine?

As for the ketchup etching the tile, so will citrus juice, pickles, and any other acidic food.