In defense of the half dovetail
Bill Tindall
Its principal advantage is in fitting, not speed of cutting it. The flat side enables the male piece to be planed on one side to coax it into a perfect fit. A perfect fit is desirable not only for mechanical strength but also for stress-free assembly. Too-tight sliding dovetails are notorious for locking up prematurely during assembly.
A lesser advantage is alignment. One knows exactly where the flat side will wind up in a half dovetail. With a full dovetail it is all too easy to get its location off a bit. Been there and done that.
The half dovetail is used where the alternative could be a mortise and tenon. Over the course of wood working history case pieces were dovetailed top and bottom with full dovetails and the drawer blades installed with mortise and tenon, half dovetails or full dovetails. There is a lot of furniture out there that has survived just fine where the drawer blades were M&T into the case sides. However, in my study of these pieces after 200 years there is frequently some separation of the joint between the case side and the drawer blade which could detract from the appearance. However, the top and bottom dovetails are holding the case together adequately.
Given where this joint is used, the additional locking ability of the full dovetail, compared to a half dovetail, is unnecessary. The drawer blade dovetail function in a case piece is simply to hold the sides into submission should there be any tendency to warping. The pieces I see in museums with half dovetails are as secure as those with full dovetails, and better than M&T.
If one is building with traditional hand tool techniques, there is one speed advantage. A dado plane is used to cut a dado across the case side. This quick operation establishes the perpendicular face for the half dovetail front and back, as well as a dado to accommodate the drawer runner. It is then a simple and quick operation to deepen the dado where the drawer blade will go and add the angled face for the dovetail.