Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Residential door question

Posts

Residential door question

#1

Residential door question

Barry Irby

I bought a house that was rode hard and put away wet. It needs repairs under the back doors. One, a five foot wide French door and the other an ordinary 2'8" steel door. I know how to make the repairs.

My question is does anyone actually know if there is a significant difference between the various doors available? Are any of them better in the sense of frames that won't rot, energy conservation or what?

Re: Residential door question

#2

JL

Re: Residential door question

JL

Andersen has always been a "name" as has Pella.

We are in the midst of renovating our church (new parish hall, kitchen, etc.). We have taken out a few of the old Andersen windows (maybe 20 years old or more). The windows are still in reasonable shape (considering the amount of maintenance), have good seals and are still intact. They are not "low E" windows given their age. What I'm trying to say is that these are still good windows. We're reusing some as opposed to buying new ones.

Some of Pella and Andersen products qualify as energy efficient. So if you replace before 12/31/2010, you should be able to get an energy tax credit.

Re: Residential door question

#3

Re: Residential door question

John Veerkamp

Another good product is Jeld-Wen. Tehir products are just as good as the two mentioned above but you aren't paying for the big name. These may not be available in your area. We just replaced the windows in my daughters house and saved 40%. The company is very good at working with self installers.

Not affiliated, just a satisfied customer.

John

Re: Residential door question

#4

Re: Residential door question

Howard Norman

When I built this house in the late 90's I investigated the various window and door manufactures and settled on Marvin. No regrets. At that time I found Pella and Anderson to both be over priced and underdesigned and built in my opinion.

Re: Residential door question

#5

Re: Residential door question

Merle

I agree relative to Andersen! I've had no experience with Pella.

Re: Residential door question

#6

No

Mark Nowicki

Re: Residential door question

#7

Re: Residential door question

FredD

Barry , you should know the answer to your question.

Aluminum jambs don't rot or rust.

Wood Jambs can be sucessfully used for many years , depending on the placement to the prevailing weather and whether there is good drainage away from the Sill .

Also the Wood has a better insulation number then metal.

Quality doors regardless of type or manufacture depend on maintenance of the finish, if you have a Dog clawing the door , use Metal , if the kids are gone , use Wood and enjoy the appearence.

In addition to the door material , the type and quality of the Weather strip has a lot to do with the door and should be looked at.

A expensive door for example, hung on a cheaply made Jamb and next to nothing for weather stripping is a door you will be replacing sooner , rather then later.

If you were in Ca or closer then you are , I would highly reccomend Feather River Door in Oroville , or International door in San Diego.

Andersen commands a good price as , well as Pella and since they have a longer life are a excellant choice.

The one time we used Marvin , because the developer was cutting costs , but still wanted to advertise he used wood windows, the windows came out paint grade, unfinished and the material was finger jointed Pine , as opposed to Vinyl clad wood such as Andersen or Pella.

One advantage Pella has is it's pattened RolScreen , which runs between the double glazing and is moved with a thumb wheel, and looks and acts like a tiny Venetian blind to control light and heat gain.

FredD

Re: Residential door question

#8

Re: Residential door question

Howard Norman

My Marvin windows and sliding door were metal clad which holds up much better in the Arizona sun than vinyl clad products. I think vinyl may work fine in less extreme climates but I would not use them in AZ.

Re: Residential door question

#9

Re: Residential door question

BradinMD

I put in two Provia doors on my house based on recommendations of a very particular window and door installer. I found the doors to be beyond my expections. Excellant Quality - but you pay for it. This is brand does not get the name recongitation as Pella and Andersen, but I felt the doors were better quality than the new Andersen French Door I recently installed.

Re: Residential door question

#10

Re: Residential door question

FredD

Having been greatly pleased with the reccomended Provia doors , why did you buy a Andersen the next time? Just curious.

FredD

Re: Residential door question

#11

Re: Residential door question

BradinMD

It was actually the reverse. I bought the Andersen first. Then the Provia