We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I'm thinking about making salt shakers for Xmas presents. Does anyone who's had experience with this know what size holes are just right for ordinary table salt? It may depend on the thickness of the wood at the top of the shaker. BTW, this is for a table salt shaker, not a cooking shaker which is supposed to dispense at a greater rate.
The answer to the question really lies in what kind of salt the user is going to put in the shaker. The common everyday table salt is very fine and requires a tiny hole or two. But, sea salt/kosher salt is course and is best used from a box with a lid. Many people are anti-salt these days for good health reasons and that leads to more use of salt boxes. My 2cts. Phil
You are right that it depends on the thickness of what the salt is going to pass through. The longer the passage the greater the opportunity for the grains to "bridge" across the channel. And, a hole in wood will change size depending on humidity and how much water the salt stuck in the holes will soak up. I never saw a "crafted" salt shaker that wasn't made with a metal salt shaker insert. I suspect there is a reason they all use the metal inserts.
I have a table salt shaker that is entirely wooden (no metal insert). I did not make it, I think it was a wedding present or at least purchased shortly after my wife and I were married 15+ years ago. Anyway, I thought it was lousy when we first got it (and for some years later, also). With a whole lot of shaking effort, I could get about 4 grains of salt onto my scrambled eggs, or so it seemed. So, when I bought my first decent drill bit set, and I saw how small the smallest bit was, it dawned on me to drill out the 3 holes on the salt shaker. I think I used a 1/16" bit. Now, it seems to work "just right"--not too fast, and not too slow. Saltilocks is happy.
I've done it both ways: drilled my own holes in the top, and used an aluminum top supplied as a kit. The one which I drilled out doesn't dispense nearly as well as the kit's top. Both hole paterns are 1/16" diameterpenings. Closer inspection of my shakers reveals that the kit top has 7 holes, the wooden capped one has only 5.
I am re-drilling my 5 hole shaker to 5/64ths to try improving the flow.
Please take the above instructions with a grain of salt.
To ensure flow of bulk solids through a chute we use a rule of thumb that the size of the chute must be at least three times the maximum particle diameter...
I don't know if this rule applies to salt shakers or not :-) but I suspect that if the holes are sized with the above rule of thumb, with a reasonable chute length through a piece of wood, where the hole sizing criteria is to avoid clogging, then you would end up with excessive salt flow. The alternative, with smaller holes through the wood, would be clogged chutes and erratic, or no, salt flow.
Maybe that's why most wooden salt shakers use a metal distributor element - because they can be designed to be very thin (no chute length), and act as orifices rather than chutes.
I do have an interesting paper on predicting flow of bulk solids through orifices...but I doubt the correlations could be scaled down salt shaker flow rates ;-)
All of the obove could just be BS and the best advice is to find a salt shaker that works and copy it.
Re: flow of bulk solids through chutes and orifice
Barry Irby
I have cheap salt and pepper shakers with plastic lids. Got a couple of pepper grinders. Converted the pepper shaker to a salt shaker. Hole pattern was the same, but the diameter was too small. Found the bit that fit in the hole in the salt shaker and drilled out the holes on the other one. Did not work well. Looked closer at the salt shaker and found that the holes were counter sunk on the inside. Used a countersink by hand on the converted one and flared the holes. Works great now. I think the response above explains it, or maybe not.
Thanks for your informed comments and salty remarks, especially the medical one. I should have known I'd get my tail salted with this thread.
I've just returned from the kitchen where I was attempting to measure the size of a salt grain with, sequentially, a feeler gauge and a micrometer:-) This isn't quite as easy as I thought it would be, but I can test drill some holes in scrap to check it out. I just have to be careful not to get any salt on my cast iron tables.