Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

OT- Propane vs. Natural gas

Posts

OT- Propane vs. Natural gas

#1

OT- Propane vs. Natural gas

Doug Ridley

Can I convert a propane weed burner to natural gas? I use about 2 bottles of propane to boil a 55 gallon drum of Cypress knees and wonder if the conversion can be made and if so would it get as hot as the Propane. Anybody know?

Re: OT- Propane vs. Natural gas

#2

Three Issues

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

1. Yes, you can switch, but you'll need to switch out to orifice(s) to the size required for NG and may need a different regulator.

2. No. Propane burns hotter than methane so your "stew" pot will take longer to boil. Any cost savings may be negated by the increased amount of gas used.

3. Caution. If you're switching from small-tank propane to natural gas, I will anticipate that you plan on tapping into gas service that comes from a main. It is "illegal" and dangerous to tap a NG gas line (or even a large LP tank) to supply a portable device, even with a cut-off valve at the tap. If you develop a leak it the item falls or is moved, the resulting explosion and fire will be continuously fed by the main rather than that small tank that is isolated. This is a Big Deal so don't do it!

Re: OT- Propane vs. Natural gas

#3

Re: OT- Propane vs. Natural gas

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Mark beat me by one minute!

Propane is metered as a semi-liquid (denser, more heat content per volume)while natural is metered as a gas. Natural orifices are about twice as big as propane. Pressure regulators for natural gas feed about twice as much pressure as for propane. Natural is usually 25% cheaper because there are no delivery charges figured into the price. Those drivers get paid. These changes are in thousandths of an inch and inches of water column. I suggest that you let your local gas dealer make the changes. Otherwise you may have smoking, difficult to lite, low heat, or safety problems. You may have a non-adjustable regulator that would require replacement. If the regulator is a POL regulator it will also probably need eplacement. POl regs have a big plastic connection nut with right hand threads. This can be done, but needs to be done properly.

Re: OT- Propane vs. Natural gas

#4

Re: OT- Propane vs. Natural gas

Doug Ridley

You guys have settled that for me. I'll stick with what I have. Thanks

Re: OT- Propane vs. Natural gas

#5

Example

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Years ago I bought a "tri-fuel" generator as our electric service went out often. I got the unit so that I could start out using gasoline, but if the power was off for days, I could hook up to the 1000 gal LP tank we have buried in the yard (or natural gas if they ever brought it up to our area (not). Being as the 9000 watt genny is on wheels and not appropriate (weather-proof enclosure, etc.) for permanent installation outside, our LP supplier was adamant in his prohibition, and informed me of all the rules. He was, however, quite willing to set up a separate 50gal. tank just for the generator. Seems as though the fifty gal tank is the limit for such use in my area. Since I get 10 hours out of 5 gallons of gas, I just keep three 5 gal cans and cycle them through the cars to keep the supply fresh. Never needed more than 2 at a time.

You do know that you can get a larger portable tank for your LP, right?

Re: OT- Propane vs. Natural gas

#6

SWMBO Says I Have An Abundance of Natural Gas

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Re: OT- Propane vs. Natural gas

#7

And my sweetie says

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

that there's a reason they call us "old f*rts."