Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Flattening a benchtop

Posts

Flattening a benchtop

#1

Flattening a benchtop

Nat Robison

Having grown tired of using my tablesaw for a "whatever" surface, I decided to build a bench in my garage for a proper work surface. This is nothing fancy, one side is anchored to a stud wall, two legs supporting the other side, the top is glued from ripped-down SPF studs (the most knot-free I could locate). A total of about $50 into it. Anyway, I glued up 2 12"-wide sections and glued them together. Problem is, there's a hump in the middle. So.........what's the quickest way to fix this?

Rip it down the middle, square up and re-glue?

I've seen mentioned a jig for flattening a top using a router. Is that the way to go?

I have to image that the router would take far longer than the first option. I'm not terribly confident about gluing wide, heavy pieces like this.

Re: Flattening a benchtop

#2

Clint Searl

Belt sander w/40 grit

Clint Searl

Follow up with successively finer grits.

Clint

Re: Flattening a benchtop

#3

I agree with Clint, unless....

Barry Irby

its really terrible. If the hump is an 1/8" or maybe even a 1/4", belt sand it, assuming you have one.

If its really bad, you could take it to someone that has a wide belt sander or wide planer.

Or you could use router rails. Figure out a way to attach a strip to the front and rear that are level and coplanar. Then make a shoe for the router that will allow you to run it back and forth and knock down anything higher than the low edges. The fact that you have it against a wall might make that a little complicated but not that bad. Knock down the high points and then sand.

You could also power plane with a electric hand plane if you have one. And even hand plane it (I can't believe I said that.)

Re: Flattening a benchtop

#4

Re: Flattening a benchtop

Marv

I suggest you talk to people who know how to do anything and everything with hand planes. Go ask your question on the Hand Tool forum. Lots of plane experts in there. They'll explain in detail how you can plane your bench top to within .002 flatness in about 20 minutes. That's one of the number one topics in there. :)

Marv

Re: Flattening a benchtop

#5

Less Time Than that if

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

you use an electric plane, though not so sure about the thickness tolerance, Nat.

I'd use a belt sander as Clint suggests, and keep it moving continually so as to avoid divits.

George

Re: Flattening a benchtop

#6

Re: Less Time Than that if

Marv

Oh yeah, an electric hand planer would remove a lot of wood in a short time. However, we don't discuss that over on the Hand Tool forum. :)

Marv

Re: Flattening a benchtop

#7

Re: I agree with Clint, unless....

john lucas

I agree with both of them. I flattened mine with the belt sander using the same techniques you use to hand plane. I mapped out the high spots with a straight edge, drew pencil lines on them and took those down with the belt sander. The n map them out again and do it again. After quite a few trials and change of grits several times I had my bench close enough you could barelys see light anywhere. Of course that was about 8 years ago and now it's so beat up you can see light everywhere. It's still flat but there are dents everywhere.

Re: Flattening a benchtop

#8

Re: Flattening a benchtop

John McGaw

For the average person, the router jig route is probably the easiest way to get to a really flat surface. There is obviously no guarantee that it will stay flat but that is going to be true no matter how you do the job. This method is great for flattening anything that is beyond the range of your jointer/planer.

http://www.highlandwoodworking.com/flattenaworkbenchwitharouter.aspx

Re: Flattening a benchtop

#9

Re: Flattening a benchtop

FredD

If you were able to work from both sides, which it doesn't sound like , a #7 Jointer plane is the way to go for flatening bench tops.

FredD

Re: Flattening a benchtop

#10

Bench planes, and some real world data *LINK*

wilbur

Disclaimer: of the variety of ways to do woodworking, I gravitate towards hand tool solutions.

For flattening a benchtop, I do think that using a pair of bench planes is the quickest and easiest way to accomplish this task. What you'll need is a jack plane (#5) with a blade with a decent camber on it, which can remove wood quickly, and then a jointer plane (#7 or #8) which will further flatten the surface. You can then use a smoother (#4) if you want, but that last step isn't completely necessary.

There's a great description of how to use bench planes very efficiently by Christopher Schwarz, who wrote an article called "Coarse, Medium, and Fine" that's available on the Popular Woodworking website. I put a link to it below.

I flattened my benchtop using the above method, and it took me 2 hours to work on a benchtop 8 feet long and 22" wide. I marked off 2 foot long sections and did them a section at a time. This was straight off of a glue up, and my benchtop was just under 1/8" out of flat across the width. 2 hours of planing may seem like a lot, but my feeling is that making a router jig and then running a router will be about the same amount of time altogether, and will kill your eardrums in the process.


Coarse, Medium, and Fine PDF article

Re: Flattening a benchtop

#11

Clint Searl

Re: Bench planes, and some real world data

Clint Searl

Sounds like a big investment in planes, irons, sharpening, and practice vs. a belt sander.

Clint

Re: Flattening a benchtop

#12

Dale Lenz

I believe....

Dale Lenz

every WW Should learn to use hand planes, then they can come to their own conclusion. It's amazing what a hand plane can do when added to your arsonal. As a good friend of mine said back in the 80's about hand planes:

Yea, you don't screw up as fast.

Since the workbench is built up against the wall, plane planing could be problem, then again the belt sander could also be.

Re: Flattening a benchtop

#13

Re: Flattening a benchtop

Marv

Nat,

If it isn't too ridiculously out of flat, how bout just getting a sheet of 3/4 ply and slap it on there. Put some molding around the edges. Paint the molding John Deere green and be proud!

Marv

Re: Flattening a benchtop

#14

Re: Bench planes, and some real world data

wilbur

Hi Clint,

Have you ever used a well set up hand plane being used? As you mention, you can spend a lot on planes, but here are some reasonable cost estimates:

Stanley #5: $40 on eBay

Stanley #7: $60 on eBay

Sharpening with sandpaper on glass/granite tile: $30 in materials

Total: $130

If you want a smoother, which you really don't need for this job, you can get a Stanley #4 for about $40, for a total of $170

Dewalt, Makita, and Bosch 3" x 21" belt sanders start at about $170, based on Amazon prices. Plus belts, which seem to be about $12 for a 5 pack.

Practice will come with use. If you plane down a benchtop by hand, you'll be an expert by the time you're done. And you'll need practice and good technique with a belt sander, otherwise you'll wind up with a big divot in the workbench.

Also, unlike a belt sander, a plane is a lifetime purchase. Once you get one and get it set up, you really won't have to get another one ever. I'm not sure you can say the same about a belt sander. In addition, there are many other uses for a bench plane besides flattening a benchtop, which makes the initial expenditure more of a bargain.