Re: Bandsaw motors, again
Mark Duginske
A friend of mine asked me to weigh in on this thread. My book THE BAND SAW HANDBOOK came out in 1989 after 5 years of research and experimentation. I redid much of the information in the book and added new material and info on the flat wheel Italian band saws. Both my father and grandfather did pattern making which requires band saw skill. I started cutting curves for him for complex patterns when I was six. My oldest brother was a shop teacher before he got his doctorate. I was very luck to be exposed to a real shop environment and also b e exposed to a good teacher like my brother. This background helped me greatly with my own woodworking business and helped me write the book.
I also worked in ER and in intensive care as an RN for 4 years. Although I was an English major working as a nurse helped my writing and critical thinking skill. I also learned not to write things that I could not substantiate.
My latest band saw book THE NEW COMPLETE GUIDE TO THE BAND SAW came out in 2008 and won the first place golden hammer award. It was edited by John Kelsey who did a really good job.
There are about 30 factors that effect band saw performance. I have experimented with many of these different facets. For example, I bought every tension gage on the market and hired an engineer to help interpret the results. I bought every blade and used many different models of saws to test performance what causes a variety of problems including blade �lead�.
Because of the popularity of my first book I have been involved with hundreds of band saw troubleshooting projects including large saw mills. I have also worked with most of the band saw manufactures
as a consultant.
One of my 4 saws is a 15� General like the one Fortune uses. It is a very nice saw that was coplanar when I got it and has minimal drift.
It is a very nice saw with minimal problems. However, I would not base my assumptions about band saws based on that saw.
Is it fair for a Corvette owner to assume that cars have 400 hp.
Information should be based on general principles, not exceptions to the rule. The Canadian General band saw and the Corvette are exceptions to the rule.
If "You don't need coplanar wheels" why are car wheel �aligned�.
Good wheel alignment with the blade tensioned is one of the 30 factors. On some saws if is more important than others.
"There's no such thing as drift" OH really. I can change saw dynamics to make it �lead� either to the right or the left. And��. I can also adjust how much it will lead.
That is like saying "There's no such thing as gravity"
"The lower guides are unimportant" Why are they on the saw? One of my saws is a band saw mill. It is very important that both sides of the cut be supported. I just finished a kitchen made from one butternut tree with book matched resawn doors. For really accurate cuts I pay special attention to the bottom guides. If you are doing curves in thin material (under 4�) then the guides are
not important, but if you are using your saw to the max everything should be accurately adjusted.
One of the 30 factors is power. One of the benefits of the Italian saws is the substantial weight of the wheels which adds to the �fly wheel� effect helping the blade move at a uniform speed with uniform power. Small saws don�t have that advantage and relay on the motor for uniform blade speed. A week motor will slow and set up vibrations.
Good power helps blade efficiency, decreases vibration, is faster, requires less concentration and if generally more fun to use. On a 14 saw I would use at least a horse or better yet a horse and a half or 2. For nearly the same money I have put 2 HP on dozens of saws.
Mark Duginske
Merrill, Wisconsin