Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Bandsaw motors, again

Posts

Bandsaw motors, again

#1

Bandsaw motors, again

wilbur

I was at Woodworking in America, and even though I tend towards hand tool work, the most informative sessions for me was listening to Michael Fortune talk about setting up bandsaws. Besides the talk, there were bandsaws there that we could try out to put into practice the information that he covered.

One of the things that he said was that for your typical 14" Delta-type bandsaw, you didn't need a motor more than 1/2 HP, which is a topic that I had raised recently. He also said that you could do resawing on such a bandsaw with such a motor up to the 12" or so capacity that a 14" bandsaw has with a riser.

Just in case you didn't know, Michael Fortune is a professional woodworker, and uses bandsaws extensively in his shop in a commercial environment. It seems that he uses bandsaws for many operations that most people would use a table saw for: making tenons, ripping hardwood, and so on.

Now, I know that he probably has larger bandsaws with bigger motors in his shop. I think his main point was that for a typical home workshop, a lot of work can be done with a bandsaw with a modestly sized motor, and that if you think you need a bigger motor, you probably really have a problem with your blade or the way the bandsaw is set up.

Other interesting things he had to say included "There's no such thing as drift", "You don't need coplanar wheels", "The lower guides are unimportant" (confirmed that one last night on my bandsaw), and "High tension on the blade is not just unnecessary, it's bad for your bandsaw".

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

#2

Clint Searl

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

Clint Searl

Where does he get off, suggesting that conventional wisdom may be wrong?

Clint

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

#3

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I'm curious, was he basically addressing those points in referrence to 14" saws or smaller? I have to think that HP, coplanar and drift might be a different issue for larger saws?

Tom

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

#4

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Michael lives about an hour from Toronto and is a Sheridan College grad (Furniture Design). We had him as a guest speaker at our Halton Furniture Makers Society meeting back in the fall of 2007. He spoke for a brief period on bandsaws, he uses the same 15" General BS I have, with just about 6" of resaw. He showed many steps of the building process of his Number One chair they were all on the same saw, in no images did we see a BIG BS's in the shop.

He mentioned much the same that you did, I do have a 1 hp on mine. I agree on the lower guide and also the tension on the band (I use the pluck test). I will say and confirm that I have since his talk I nearly given up using the table saw, I found that he opened my thinking to my material preparation process, I have found the band saw fits my needs with better results now combined with my improved hand tool skills.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

#5

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio

Hi Wibur,

On the drift comment, did he go into any detail? Does he believe that it is caused by a poorly set blade.

I only ask because when I was doing flat work I always had to adjust for drift when resawing.

Thanks,

Dave

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

#6

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

wilbur

Here's Michael Fortune's procedure to eliminate the drift issue:

1. Adjust the top bandsaw wheel so that the blade is tracking dead center. This presumes you have a good crown on your bandsaw wheel tire.

2. Set your fence parallel with the miter slot.

3. Set the upper guides so that the guide blocks and thrust bearing are a cigarette paper's width away from the blade. This is thinner than the dollar bill that many people recommend for this task. The lower guides just need to be close.

4. Since the blade will be tracking perpendicular to wheels due to its centered position, you should have no drift at this point. If there is any drift, it's not because of the blade. It's because the table is misaligned to the wheels. Adjust the table if this is the case.

5. Adjusting the table is a big pain, but it's a one time setup. Once you finish doing this, you can deal with any "drift" simply by adjusting the upper bandsaw wheel. This is far easier than adjusting the fence, and as long as you track the blade in the center of the wheel, you'll be very close to a drift free position, if not already there.

6. The big test is to take a piece of wood and use the fence to make a short cut. If the blade is centered in the kerf, you're good to go.

Hope that made sense. I just tried this method of bandsaw setup tonight, and it works. My bandsaw is an old Walker Turner, and the fence is locked so that it's parallel to the miter slot and there's no way to adjust the fence for drift, and for the first time I think I can use my non-adjustable bandsaw fence.

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

#7

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

Steve Schoene

I see, he has you adjust for the drift by adjusting the table, not the fence.

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

#8

blade drift ??

del schisler

i belive adjusting the fence is easer that adj. the table. I have done this in a matter of min'. How long to adjust the table. I guess first do the 90 degrees to the blade . Than i guess it would be like turning the table like clock wise or the counter clock wise ? Seam's like more work. Now i know someone will say once you do this it is good for all blade's . I don't thank so. Wouldn't the set in some blade's be different? I will do it my way which hasn't failed me yet. Take a board tha mark a 1" all the way down length wise. Now free saw it staying on the line. Now this is important. saw 1/2 way down the board. Now stop. Don't let the board move. Now take your angle finder and put it mext to the wood with the other end flush on the edge of the bed. Set the angle. Take the wood out and than put the fence on the bed. Put the angle finder on the edge of the bet and than see if it is square? if not soosen ut the bolt's and move so that angle finder is flush. This is how i do it.Works for me I resaw so i don't have to do this everting i change blades. Now if i get a new 3tpi 1/2" I would check it and see if all was still right on. Thanks for reading

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

#9

Need to clarify

wilbur

If you read my post above again, you'll see that I said that adjusting the table is a one time adjustment. It may not need to be done at all. If you have to adjust the table for the one time you need to do it, if at all, when the blade is centered on the wheel, and the fence is aligned with the miter slot, and the fence/miter slot aligned with the blade, you'll never have to adjust the bandsaw fence again. All you have to do when switching to a new blade is to center it on the wheel, and it will be drift free.

As far as this being good for all blades, according to Michael Fortune, the procedure described above has worked in a commercial and production environment for the past 30+ years.

I tried it last night, and it works, and it's far easier to center the blade on the wheel than it is to readjust the fence for each blade switch that you do. There are other ways to deal with this, like adjusting the fence for the blade, as you do. I'm not denying that. You mentioned that it takes a few minutes to set up a fence for blade drift. It took me seconds to get the blade adjusted going from a 3/4" 3TPI blade to a 1/2" 6 tpi blade with Michael Fortune's method.

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

#10

Big left-hand turn here!  Questions - long

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I've got so many questions for you, Jim, that I scarcely know where to start. First to explain a little about my own situation.

I'm a hobbyist woodworker, on and off for probably about 30 years or so. I'm largely self-taught, by which I mean I've never taken a formal class in WW'ing. However, I've benefited hugely from books, mags and the internet. Most of the furniture in my home and in the homes of my kids has been the product of my hands and time. By hobbyist, I also mean that I have the luxury of time, not having to work to a deadline or having my income dependent upon my skills and shop. Consequently, a project can sit for a bit while I figure out a procedure or a new skill to be mastered, etc.

HOWEVER, once in a while, I come across a statement like yours, that [speaking of Michael Fortune's presentation to your woodworking club]:

"I will say and confirm that I have since his talk I nearly given up using the table saw, I found that he opened my thinking to my material preparation process, I have found the band saw fits my needs with better results now combined with my improved hand tool skills."

Would you mind explaining that statement, sharing some detail on what has changed in your material prep process and what has changed in how you do your work? I'm always looking for a better way to do my own, and I'm pretty well convinced that (in spite of what I tell my wife) it doesn't always involve a new tool, just learning how to use the ones I have better and smarter. Specifically, work flow has always been a bit of a problem for me, but I think that's partly a function of only doing this sporadically, not full time.

Did you incorporate those techniques when you made that wonderful Morris chair a couple years back, and if so, how?

Whatever insight you can provide will be truly gratefully received.

Thanks.

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

#11

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio

Thanks Wilbur,

Best wishes,

Dave

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

#12

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

Mark Duginske

A friend of mine asked me to weigh in on this thread. My book THE BAND SAW HANDBOOK came out in 1989 after 5 years of research and experimentation. I redid much of the information in the book and added new material and info on the flat wheel Italian band saws. Both my father and grandfather did pattern making which requires band saw skill. I started cutting curves for him for complex patterns when I was six. My oldest brother was a shop teacher before he got his doctorate. I was very luck to be exposed to a real shop environment and also b e exposed to a good teacher like my brother. This background helped me greatly with my own woodworking business and helped me write the book.

I also worked in ER and in intensive care as an RN for 4 years. Although I was an English major working as a nurse helped my writing and critical thinking skill. I also learned not to write things that I could not substantiate.

My latest band saw book THE NEW COMPLETE GUIDE TO THE BAND SAW came out in 2008 and won the first place golden hammer award. It was edited by John Kelsey who did a really good job.

There are about 30 factors that effect band saw performance. I have experimented with many of these different facets. For example, I bought every tension gage on the market and hired an engineer to help interpret the results. I bought every blade and used many different models of saws to test performance what causes a variety of problems including blade �lead�.

Because of the popularity of my first book I have been involved with hundreds of band saw troubleshooting projects including large saw mills. I have also worked with most of the band saw manufactures

as a consultant.

One of my 4 saws is a 15� General like the one Fortune uses. It is a very nice saw that was coplanar when I got it and has minimal drift.

It is a very nice saw with minimal problems. However, I would not base my assumptions about band saws based on that saw.

Is it fair for a Corvette owner to assume that cars have 400 hp.

Information should be based on general principles, not exceptions to the rule. The Canadian General band saw and the Corvette are exceptions to the rule.

If "You don't need coplanar wheels" why are car wheel �aligned�.

Good wheel alignment with the blade tensioned is one of the 30 factors. On some saws if is more important than others.

"There's no such thing as drift" OH really. I can change saw dynamics to make it �lead� either to the right or the left. And��. I can also adjust how much it will lead.

That is like saying "There's no such thing as gravity"

"The lower guides are unimportant" Why are they on the saw? One of my saws is a band saw mill. It is very important that both sides of the cut be supported. I just finished a kitchen made from one butternut tree with book matched resawn doors. For really accurate cuts I pay special attention to the bottom guides. If you are doing curves in thin material (under 4�) then the guides are

not important, but if you are using your saw to the max everything should be accurately adjusted.

One of the 30 factors is power. One of the benefits of the Italian saws is the substantial weight of the wheels which adds to the �fly wheel� effect helping the blade move at a uniform speed with uniform power. Small saws don�t have that advantage and relay on the motor for uniform blade speed. A week motor will slow and set up vibrations.

Good power helps blade efficiency, decreases vibration, is faster, requires less concentration and if generally more fun to use. On a 14 saw I would use at least a horse or better yet a horse and a half or 2. For nearly the same money I have put 2 HP on dozens of saws.

Mark Duginske

Merrill, Wisconsin

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

#13

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

FredD

I am glad you took the time to chime in Mark, I have always reccommended your thoughts on machine setups and trouble shooting.

Your credentials precede you in every woodworking magazine I ever subscribed to and your work is the standard to refer to.

FredD

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

#14

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio

Thanks Mark,

I believe your book was one of the first I ever bought. I followed it as I set up my first real bandsaw. The difference in performance was amazing.

As I am now mostly a woodturner I don't really need the fine tuning as in my flatwork days, but I still do it just because I like a well tuned machine. I just gives me a nice sense of satisfaction.

Thanks and best wishes,

Dave

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

#15

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

Stuart Hough

Thanks Mark! Let me preface this post with the statement that I am a neophyte, and by NO MEANS any kind of expert on this subject, but I do agree with everything you posted. I have your first book and have read it through and through twice. When I started using your principles to fine tune my old Buffalo Tools bandsaw I discovered that even something as coarse as that saw could be made to do very good work. I have changed out the guides for rollers, changed the bearings on the wheels, replaced the tensioner (that I didn't know had cracked until starting to work on the saw), and frankensteined a Jet riser block onto the unit. I had the wheels almost in the same plane, but could not ever quite get them there, until I added the riser. I guess there had been some twisting to the frame due to the blade never being de-tensioned by the previous owner. It seems I inadvertantly corrected the twist when I added the riser block. Thanks to your book I gained the knowledge and confidence I needed to tackle a machine I had never used before, and I think I may just have created the proverbial silk purse. Thanks again!

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

#16

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

wilbur

Hi Mark,

I bought the first edition of your book and found it invaluable for getting my old bandsaw back into shape, using most of the techniques you describe in your book except for getting the wheels coplanar -- mainly because I didn't have a good way to do that with my bandsaw.

Having said all that, after seeing Michael Fortune's talk, I tried setting up my bandsaw as he describes, and got results that were on par with setting it up as you recommend, and on par with the results seen in his talk. As part of his talk, he took an out of the box Asian-made Delta clone 14" bandsaw and set it up as he describes, resawed a piece of veneer, and passed it around so that we all could see what to expect with a well set up bandsaw for a resaw operation. Last night, as another check, I resawed an 8" wide piece of cherry, and got a consistent 3/64" veneer off of it without trouble. This is with an older bandsaw, 1/2 HP motor, and wheels that were not coplanar.

To clarify some things that you alluded to, and I'm sure that you know all this, Michael Fortune's recommendations on his method of bandsaw set up are not just based on his experience with a General 15" bandsaw. He has a variety of bandsaws in his shop, including a cheapo Ridgid bandsaw from the borg, set up the same way. He has had much experience serving as a consultant, including working on sawing operations in third world countries where the bandsaw being used was far from a precision piece of machinery. Probably most importantly, he uses his method in a production environment for over 30 years, so this method must have some value to him personally. What I can say is that he was able to teach a method of bandsaw set up that I was easily able to reproduce in my shop. And for me, and with all due respect to you, Mark, I feel more comfortable with the decreased tension on my bandsaw blade.

I think the important take home message is that for bandsaw set up, like many other things in woodworking, there are different processes that will get you to the same result. For sharpening, there's oilstones, waterstones, and Scary Sharp. For planes, there's bevel up and bevel down. For dovetails, there's pins or tails first, and so on.

I agree that you have a method of setting up a bandsaw that provides excellent results. I've used them myself. From what I learned last weekend, and what I've seen in my shop, there's another method to bandsaw set up that provides excellent results as well. It doesn't mean that one is right and one is wrong, any more than the decision to clean up a board with a smoothing plane or a random orbital sander is right or wrong.

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

#17

Clint Searl

Well said

Clint Searl

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

#18

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

Chuck Lenz

First of all I'll say that I have both of Mr Duginske's bandsaw books, and can verify that he's an upstanding guy. The other guys claim that you don't need anything larger then a 1/2 HP motor on a Delta type 14" Bandsaw with a riser kit maybe true to a point, but why would you want too ? Don't most of the 14" bandsaws nowdays come with a minimum 3/4 HP motor ? And if you buy one new with the riser kit allready installed it comes with a 1 HP or 1 1/4 HP motor.

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

#19

Re: Bandsaw motors, again

Keith Newton

Mark, I agree with all that you said. Every time I read someone claim 1/2 hp. Is enough as thickness increases, I just sigh.

I am sure that somewhere it is written, how much power needed per tooth in the cut / speed, to take a large enough chip, to take the heat away with it. Sure you could gear it down, who wants to do that? If you don't, you will ruin the blade sooner from over heating.