Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Hangin' With Ellis

Posts

Hangin' With Ellis

#1

Hangin' With Ellis

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I just got back from a few days off and a little vacation in southern Indiana. Much needed I might add. So last Friday I decided to take a chance and attend the Woodworking in America show in Cincinnati. I say "take a chance" because I have given up going to WW shows many years ago. More often than not most WW shows these days, IMHO, have deteriorated and are often populated by vendors selling cheap gadgets and gizmos.

The minute I walked in to the Woodworking show in Cincy I knew that my decision to attend would be rewarded. Right as I entered was Lee Valley and Lie-Nielsen. Neither at most shows. That was a good start. But things were about to get better. About 15 minutes after entering the show who should I run across? None other than the man himself....Ellis. I hadn't seen Ellis in years and what a happy reunion it was.

Not only did we have time to talk but I had the pleasure of walking the show with Ellis. Talk about an "inside connection"! Ellis knows everybody and everybody knows Ellis. What made that extra cool is that as we walked the show I discovered booth after booth of some of the finest tool makers in the world. Marcou planes, Sauer and Steiner, Blue Spruce,Bridge City, Hock, Lake Erie Toolworks, Elkhead Tools, Clark and Williams and many more. The place was completely full of high end hand tool makers....wow! And Ellis knows them all so he was kind enough to introduce me around to the "Big Kahunas" of tool making and I got some great hands on time with thier products. I will never own a $2,800 Marcou smoother but it was great fun to try one out. Very sweet I might add.

Ellis and I checked out a very cool traveling tool museum too. It was full of rare and unusual tools. No surprise to me, Ellis could I.D. most of the tools. Folks, Ellis blew my mind with his depth of woodworking knowledge.

I wish I could have hung out with him all day but travel plans cut my stay at the show short. I had a blast hangin' with Ellis and for the first time ever, came away from a WW show drooling like a Saint Barnard!

Thanks for your time and friendship Ellis. And I hope others here had a chance to see that rare fine show.

Tommy

Re: Hangin' With Ellis

#2

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Hangin' With Ellis

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Sounds like a great time Tom, I was almost there myself, it would have been nice to see you both as well.

Take care,

Jim


Re: Hangin' With Ellis

#4

Ellis Walentine

Great seeing you too, Tom

Ellis Walentine

It really has been a long time -- what, eight years since the Woodworks show in Indy? I'm so glad you and your wife made it down to Cincinnati and that I had a chance to walk around with you. It really was a wonderful show.

I have a lot of pictures that I will be posting soon. I'm still digging out from being away for four days.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: Hangin' With Ellis

#5

Just missed you.

Ray - Middletown, IN

I got there after lunch and, like you, Ellis was kind enough to take me around and introduce me to many of the vendors. I won't tell where we hooked up, but let's just say there was hand washing involved.

I'm not much of a hand tool guy, but I almost changed my mind, almost. I do have my student(?) chopping through tenons by hand, that is close enough for me. :) Next project will be some dovetails, and, while the chisels are out he might as well use them.

Ray

Re: Hangin' With Ellis

#6

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

So educate me...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

What is the point of a $2800 smoother?

Is it THAT much better than a $500 smoother? Does it stay sharp forever?

Or is it a piece of art?

Don't get me wrong--I'm not knocking the guy if he can sell them for that, I'm just curious.

Jason

Re: Hangin' With Ellis

#7

Re: So educate me...

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

That's a good tool philosophy debate question. Having held and tried one I can tell you that they are very handsome tools. The quality of their manufacture is flawless. But beauty and usefulness I feel are in the eyes of the beholder/user. While beautiful, they are very heavy planes. To many, that would be a negative. To others a plus. I myself would have a hard time believing that they could do their task any better than a well tuned $300-$500 plane (or even cheaper perhaps).

I know several professional furniture makers and I cannot say that any of them use such expensive planes. So my thoughts are that fine planes like that are appreciated most by tool officiandos and those who relish the experience of working with such remarkable craftsmanship.

Re: Hangin' With Ellis

#8

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: So educate me...

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

I also agree with Tommy,

A well tuned plane with a well sharpened iron in the hands of an experienced user can make wonderful shavings, no matter what the price.

I do have several plans in the 4 digit category, the attraction is the craftsmanship, the results when used and my own journey. The planes that I use in this niche are made by a good friend, otherwise I might not enjoy the journey using them as much. They feel right in my hands and in my shop, also I like to think they will be treasured by my daughter and her family when I gone.

If financial considerations are critical in making some choices then a return on investment formula should be used in finding the right tool in a given process. There must always be options in a business case.

In the end the way wood responds to planing/shaping is only is a reflection of the tool and skill used to transform it, it does not care about the price.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Hangin' With Ellis

#9

Re: So educate me...

wilbur

Snarky answer: what is the point of a $2800 chest of drawers? You can buy a chest of drawers for a fraction of the price that will hold clothes just as well. I'm sure we all would love it if the rest of the world placed the same value on fine woodworking that we would, so maybe we should extend that same courtesy to those who are in the market for $2800 smoothers.

Real answer: tools have a primary and a secondary function. The primary function is how it does its job -- in this case, making plane shavings and smoothing a surface. This is what most people are thinking of when they say, "Does this plane $1300 better than a $500 smoother?" The value of the tool in this respect is quantifiable, and if this is the only aspect of the tool's performance that you are thinking about, then the answer to this sort of question is usually "No, it doesn't plane $1300 better."

The secondary function of a tool is how it inspires you, and we all have experienced this. Some people get a charge of going to their shop and seeing that Marcou smoother and that inspires them to make that $2800 chest of drawers. Some get the same charge out of an old Stanley #4 that they got at a flea market. Again, this value is also quantifiable. Unlike the primary function, though, the value of the inspiration is variable from person to person. To one person, laying out the cash for a Marcou plane is worth it and may even be considered a bargain. To another, such thinking is completely nuts.

Both viewpoints are completely valid. What is not valid, however, is the idea that if you were not inclined to purchase a $2800 smoother, that it is crazy for someone else to come to a different conclusion. Here we really are into "Different strokes for different folks" territory.

Re: Hangin' With Ellis

#10

The good news.....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I went from booth to booth watching tool makers demonstrate planes from the $250 level to the $3,000 level (or more). The shavings from booth to booth were all clean and whisper thin. It's nice to know that there are great tools out there for all of us!

T.

Re: Hangin' With Ellis

#11

Re: Hangin' With Ellis

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

Tommy,

As you well know from her and on the Hand Tools Board.No pictures=No Proof...It did not happen.

Re: Hangin' With Ellis

#12

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

That's why I asked!

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I wanted some ideas as to why dropping $2800 on a plane WASN'T crazy. I was pretty sure someone woodworking full time for a living wouldn't likely do it.

Not to mention, if I had that kind of walking around money, I could see myself buying something like that, but nobody's ever accused me of being perfectly sensible, either. ;)

Jason

Re: Hangin' With Ellis

#13

Andy, Andy, Andy on the Hand Tool Forum...

Barry Irby

Its No daguerreotype it did not happen. Unless you are strict, then its no etching it did not happen. If you are in a hurry or snail mailing it, it no charcoal sketch it did not happen.

Sorry I missed this show,I would still be sketching.

Re: Hangin' With Ellis

#14

Ellis had a camera...

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

...he'll bail me out. Stay tuned.

Re: Hangin' With Ellis

#15

Ellis Walentine

Here's a teaser

Ellis Walentine

This was a glimpse of Dave Jeske's Blue Spruce Toolworks booth...


And, here's a modest Ron Brese plane sitting on a little pile of cherry shavings.


I'm working on a shop shot right now. With luck, it'll be done in the next couple days.

Ellis

PS Here's the shot of Tommy in his element...


Re: Hangin' With Ellis

#16

Re: Hangin' With Ellis

Bart Leetch

Ya Tommy leave it to you to know all the famous & notable wood working characters.


img

Re: Hangin' With Ellis

#17

Re: Hangin' With Ellis

Bart Leetch

The pic didn't show.


img

Re: Hangin' With Ellis

#18

Re: Hangin' With Ellis

Bart Leetch

Try this

http://s50.photobucket.com/albums/f347/originalbart/?action=view&current=TSkaggs.jpg

Re: Hangin' With Ellis

#19

Re: Hangin' With Ellis

David Hay Denver

In PhotoBucket, you need to copy the URL in the "Direct Link" box, as that's the actual image, not the page that contains the image.

David

Re: Hangin' With Ellis

#20

Re: Hangin' With Ellis

Bart Leetch

Re: Hangin' With Ellis

#21

Re: Hangin' With Ellis

Alan in Little Washington (NC)