MDF or plywood
ChrisF
Hi all.
I'm going to add some Arts & Crafts/Craftsman woodwork to the dining room in our 1923 house, including a high wainscot with a plate rail. The new woodwork will be made of sweet gum (aka: gumwood), the same wood that all of the existing trim (window trim, doors, crown molding, baseboard) is made of.
The wainscot will have a number of verticle stiles running between the plate rail and the baseboard. The area between them will be filled with wood panels, which will be held in place by quarter round molding nailed to the stiles.
I have agonized about how to securely attach the various parts of the wainscot to the wall without the fasteners showing. I doubt that many (if any) of the stiles will hit a stud, so face nailing isn't an option. I've also managed to source some new gumwood, but not as much as I'd like.
It occurred to me the other day that since the areas between the stiles will be filled, only the face of the stiles will actually be seen. This means that I could fasten some sort of 1/2" substrate to the walls first (using screws or toggle bolts), then face them with a 1/4" thick piece of gumwood (using glue and perhaps pin nails). This gets me the look I want and very secure fastening with only a minimal amount of gumwood used.
I have not done anything like this before, and don't know if my idea is feasible. If it is, would MDF or plywood (or something else) be best for the substrate? If anybody has any suggestions or thoughts, I'd very much like to hear them.
Thanks!
Chris





