Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

MDF or plywood

Posts

MDF or plywood

#1

MDF or plywood

ChrisF

Hi all.

I'm going to add some Arts & Crafts/Craftsman woodwork to the dining room in our 1923 house, including a high wainscot with a plate rail. The new woodwork will be made of sweet gum (aka: gumwood), the same wood that all of the existing trim (window trim, doors, crown molding, baseboard) is made of.

The wainscot will have a number of verticle stiles running between the plate rail and the baseboard. The area between them will be filled with wood panels, which will be held in place by quarter round molding nailed to the stiles.

I have agonized about how to securely attach the various parts of the wainscot to the wall without the fasteners showing. I doubt that many (if any) of the stiles will hit a stud, so face nailing isn't an option. I've also managed to source some new gumwood, but not as much as I'd like.

It occurred to me the other day that since the areas between the stiles will be filled, only the face of the stiles will actually be seen. This means that I could fasten some sort of 1/2" substrate to the walls first (using screws or toggle bolts), then face them with a 1/4" thick piece of gumwood (using glue and perhaps pin nails). This gets me the look I want and very secure fastening with only a minimal amount of gumwood used.

I have not done anything like this before, and don't know if my idea is feasible. If it is, would MDF or plywood (or something else) be best for the substrate? If anybody has any suggestions or thoughts, I'd very much like to hear them.

Thanks!

Chris

Re: MDF or plywood

#2

Re: MDF or plywood

George Koch

Chris, if your house was built in 1923, there is a good chance that the walls are plaster over horizontal wood lath, therefore I would think you could use the glue and face pin nail method even for the vertical stiles. George

Re: MDF or plywood

#3

my observation,

DizD

is that plywood would have better nail-holding ability than MDF. You might test fastners on some scrap to see what your results would be.

Re: MDF or plywood

#4

Re: my observation,

Jerry Nicholson

The plywood I have seen at the home centers in the last few years has trouble holding itself together, let alone holding fasteners. :(

Jerry

Re: MDF or plywood

#5

Re: MDF or plywood

FredD

Chris,

you may be overthinking the Wainscot assembly, I have made it for longer then I remember and here is a common and fast and easy way to make it look good.

Make two rails , top and bottom , same length , cut all stiles the same length.

Glue them togather with biscuits.

Buy or make some step moulding that will accomadate a 1/4 Panel when it is recessed and nearly touching the wall with the back of the panel.

Cut and glue the moulding picture frame style, I use Gel form Cyanocrylate glue) togather making a frame that fits closely in the space between the stiles and then cut and glue the panel onto the back of the frame.

After installing the Wainscot frame with toenails at the top edge that the plate or chair rail will cover and face nail the bottom rail that the base will cover (base goes over the Wainscot bottom rail).

Before you install the panels you should on wide panels place a scrap piece of plywood or MDF or PT about 12 inches square or so on the wall behind the panel and glue this scrap on with construction adhesive.

If your carefull not to apply to much in one spot , expanding foam works fast but caution is needed to not let the foam expand until it pushes out the panel noticeably. I don't use it for this reason.

I always try to lay out the Wainscot so it will not cover any outlets and sometimes I will move a outlet , so it is centered on the panel.

Naturally ,you will already have applied the finish prior to installation.

Here's what White Ash looks like done this way.

http://picasaweb.google.com/FredD17209/AshWainscot?authkey=Gv1sRgCObx9PKnmujfWA&feat=directlink

FredD

Re: MDF or plywood

#6

Re: MDF or plywood

ChrisF

Thanks for the feedback guys. My plans were to use baltic birch plywood for the substrate, not home center junk. As for building it, that's very nice work Fred! My problem is that our house is very much out of level/square, and there are a lot of obstructions to deal with, so building the wainscot in place is pretty much a necessity.

Chris

Re: MDF or plywood

#7

Re: MDF or plywood

FredD

Out of level floor is not a problem Chris.

Snap a line at the level you want the Wainscot to be at (that would be directly underneath the chair or Plate rail)

Make the Wainscot frame a inch or so shy of the floor level at it's lowest point.

This gap will be covered by the Base and doing so cuts down on using a wider board for the bottom rail, then the top rail .

Use a furring strip to fill the gap so the Base is flat when installed.

I make both rails the same dimension to speed up the milling and not waste more lumber then is absoulutely neccassary.

Framing on the wall a stick at a time is time consuming and may result in a less then straight and level line at trhe top. Not to mention the hassle of finishing the Wainscot in place.

Lots of luck , run into a problem , feel free to email me.

BTW a "substrate" is not used in a typical Wainscot.

FredD

Re: MDF or plywood

#8

Re: MDF or plywood

ChrisF

My idea is to fasten the top rail to the walls level, attach the plate rail to that, then run stiles between the top rail and the existing baseboard. Fill the open areas with a panel (maybe a little construction adhesive on the back), then put quarter round around the frame to hold the panel in place. Arts & Crafts style is all about simplicity...can't get more simple than that! :)

It may seem more time consuming, but I think in my case, it's time well spent. I'd love to just build everything in the shop and pop it in place, but I tried doing that with my first few "built-in" projects, and even with copious amounts of "fudge factor" included in the designs, enormous amounts of time were spent trying to make things fit. IMHO, building this in place will ultimately be a lot easier.

Chris