OT GPS?
Thomas Norton
Just came back from Europe and had the occassion to rent a car and use a Tom Tom GPS. First time using a GPS and found it very helpful.
So my question to you guys is what is a good brand and will they all work here and abroad?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
OT GPS?
Thomas Norton
Just came back from Europe and had the occassion to rent a car and use a Tom Tom GPS. First time using a GPS and found it very helpful.
So my question to you guys is what is a good brand and will they all work here and abroad?
Re: OT GPS?
paul in AZ
It has been a little while now but I have had both Tom Tom and Garmin.
The Tom Tom worked ok but was very twitchy. The vocal directions kept saying 'turn right... or left' every time a highway made a 10 degree bend. Irritating. The mapping was not always accurate. I soon returned it for a Garmin which doesn't refresh quite as quickly but has been completely satisfactory. I like the larger screen -?4+ inch?
TomTom is supposed to have the best mapping for Europe while Garmin gets the nod for the US.
As with all electronic gadgets, specs change all the time. I'd suggest going to GPS magazine or one the similar sites to look at their buyer's guide and reviews of current models.
Re: OT GPS?
Howard Norman
Garmin seems to get the nod for US usage. I don't know about use in Europe. I have owned three Garmins over the years.
Re: OT GPS?
Gary Smyth
I have a Garmin w speech. I can't tell you how many gallons of gas it has saved me. It gets me to tool sales nicely too. I think mine is a 640W or something similar. Updates are $50 but unless you live in a city that changes street names or there are a slew of new housing developments, one update every three - four years is fine. I put a foam rubber frame around mine as it kept falling off the dash. Now I just take the lighter out, plug in the GPS and when I'm finished leave it or toss it under the seat.
Get a car adapter, the biggest screen possible, dimmable screen, and voice.
Re: OT GPS?
Warren White
I have a Garmin and it has been just fine for me. My daughter and her husband have both a Tom Tom and Garmin and she prefers the Garmin. I purchased the lifetime update option.
One word of caution. Don't leave either in the car when you have those little 'sucker' marks on your windshield. I have known a few people who have had their cars broken into for the GPS. Keep something in the car to clean the windshield off, thus depriving the low-life's of a clue.
Re: OT GPS?
Lee Schierer McKean, PA
I have a Garmin for the car and the boat. They both work great. The Garmin for the car gives good directions. The GPS will get you there, but they don't always choose the best route. The programming does not take into account traffic lights when determining fastest time through a city. Also if you really know and area, you can beat the GPS routing most of the time, but then if you know the area why are you using a GPS?
For Europe you have to get another map set for the Garmin, but it will work just fine. The lifetime update option is the way to go for maps.
Lee
Re: OT GPS?
Dave
One more word of advice, don't put your home address in the gps. If someone does steal it they know where you live and probably aren't home.
Re: OT GPS?
paul in AZ
The suction cup thingie on the windshield is not only an invitation to a broken window and theft but mine didn't stay stuck all that well. I got a beanbag mount that sits on the dash. I just throw a hat over it most of the time or sometimes put it under the seat and nobody can tell that I have GPS.
Garmin 255W
Joe Pack
Not an expert here, but I did stay at a Holiday Inn a couple of years ago.
I drive cars for several dealers (to/from auctions, dealer trades, etc.) with a bunch of other retired guys, most of whom have GPS units. The Garmin units, particularly the 255W, seem to be most popular because of their wide screen, intuitive programmming and price. You can find these anywhere from $125 - $175, maybe cheaper as a refurb. Garmins usually go from daylight mode to night mode automatically. The TomToms I have seen require manual switching.
Lots of units offer gimmicks like cell phone connectivity, street detail, etc., but make sure you can actually use them in your area. Lane choice detail is great, but why pay an extra $200 for it if you don't live in one of the larger cities where it is actually available? Why play an MP3 player through a 1" speaker? In my humble opinion, the only really helpful option is spoken directions. Everything else is just eye candy.
One of the best accessories for the GPS is a "bean bag" mount that just sits on the dash and is instantly moveable. Garmin offers a bag w/mount that just snaps into the back of the GPS. Nothing could be more simple; no suction cup marks, adhesive, etc. I bought mine online from BestBuy as a refurb for about $18.
Which ever one. DON'T buy a..
Craig in Silverdale
Sony. I bought one a while back because it had the largest screen at the time. It works pretty well for street names etc, but the routes it chooses are terrible. This GPS has taken me as far as 3 miles out of the way to get me two miles across town. I now have a Magellan RoadMate 1700, again because of the screen size. It's an eye sight thing. I like it, but the Garmin still may be a better unit.
Re: OT GPS?
Jim Dillon
Thomas,
Another vote for the Garmin 255W/T if it is still available. I paid roughly $180 for it, but the price is now down to $120 or so. It has everything I need. Get the largest screen and voice directions as they add a lot to enjoying the unit. I also got a beanbag and it works very well. Regarding maps, I think you do have to purchase maps for Europe etc. if you bought your GPS here in North America. I love mine and never cease to being amazed at its accuracy. A friend of mine showed off his GPS in his boat with maritime maps and that takes it to a whole new level, especially when in a fog.
Jim
Re: OT GPS?
R Payne
There are many good brands. And most of the features can be found on all of them.
What you need to decide is how you are going to use the GPS. If you want to type in an address and have it find a path you'll want a machine that does that.
I have a lower end Garmin. It doesn't allow for the typing in of an address, doesn't have a lot of streets, doesn't have a voice, doesn't do a lot of stuff that many people like. But I don't type in an address and ask for directions, I put waypoints in for places I go to only occasionally. It shows when I need to turn. I also use it to find my way back when I've been exploring.
It does not replace a map and compass.
ron
Re: Garmin 255W
Thomas Norton
This one sounds like a winner for me. I am having a bit of a challenge understanding how to use it in Europe. Does it come with the maps loaded or do I need to buy them later?
Re: Garmin 255W
Jim Dillon
Thomas,
I'm no expert for sure, but I think if you purchase the GPS in the USA, it comes only with the maps for North America plus territories. It does not come with other maps and those must be purchased separately. I'm a big fan of the ETA (estimated time of arrival) feature that is very useful in scheduling time for intermediate stops along the way to your final destination. And as Joe (I think) said, the fancy features like traffic alert and lane assist only work or are useful if you live in a metropolitan area. My 255WT came with the lifetime traffic feature (for an extra $30) and it has never been useful to me other than a curiosity. I purchased mine from Amazon and that site listed an excellent comparison of all the Garmin models along with different features.
Jim
Re: OT GPS?
Lee Gordon
You've had quite a few responses recommending Garmin, and I have no reason to doubt that Garmin is a good choice. I just wanted to add that I have a TomTom (XL 340-S) and I have been quite pleased with it.
Re: Garmin 255W *LINK*
Joe Pack
Jim is correct; North America maps are pre-installed. Europe is available for download, but I don't have details.
For what it's worth, the 255W is on sale right now through Amazon at $117 with shipping included. I don't think you will beat that price.
Note that a USB chord is needed to patch from the Garmin to your computer if you need to update anything. I didn't have one, so I called Garmin and they sent me one at no charge.
Also, a common problem with almost any GPS is that the 12v car plug seems to come loose. The fuse is often located inside the plug. The metal tip screws into the plastic plug and can come loose. I lost the tip of mine somewhere and had to order an new cord. Just be aware if you plug in and out a lot.
Amazon Garmin 255W
PS - dashboard mount *LINK*
Joe Pack
I strongly recommend the dashboard friction mount made specifically for the Garmin units. I can't imagine going back to suction cup mounts.
With the free shipping, this is the best price I have seen on these for a while.
Amazon Garmin Friction Mount
Re: TomTom XL340 TM
Rick L
I have the Garmin 265WT and TomTom XL340 TM. I find the 340 makes less mistakes than the Garmin overall and I can customize the TT and make map changes I can't on the Garmin. I would also get Lifetime Traffic and Maps. It also depends on where you live. Garmin uses Navtek and TT uses Teleatlas. TT is supposed to be better in Europe and Garmin is supposed to be better in the states. More bells and whistles on the TomTom. If I were looking to buy today I might consider the Garmin 1390 LMT. There is no easy answer and it depends on what you want it to do and how much you want to pay. I've researching for months now and have a pretty good understanding of them but new points keep coming up. I'm also looking for a truck GPS for commercial vehicles and they have them that take into consideration the truck height, weight, etc.
Garmin 265WT and dashboard mount
Hoa in Alameda
I have a 265WT with a dashboard mount. It is similar to the 255WT model, with the addition of bluetooth so I can use my cellphone hand-free. I don't use my cellphone a lot so if I bought a bluetooth headset, when I needed it, the battery would be dead. So having a bluetooth speaker phone when driving (the only time I need one) is great.
I also have a dashboard mount as Joe Pack suggested. But I don't use it as "dashboard mount" per se. Here is a photo showing how I use it. I think it's better than "dashboard mount."
I know the GPS unit covers the speedometer. But the GPS has a trip computer. The car's speedometer is not really needed.
I don't stick my paw through the steering wheel to adjust the GPS.
Another photo...
Hoa in Alameda
showing how easy it is to remove the GPS. In the photo, the GPS lies face down with the power cord sticking out from the back.
Re: TomTom is more flexible
Rick L
My TomTom 340 TM has lifetime traffic and maps. The other thing I like about the TomTom is you can update the maps online or on your GPS and the info can be shared online. Garmin maps are only updated by Garmin so you have no control. More bells and whistles on the TomTom and you can get more options online. I find it just as accurate if not more than my Garmin. You can also switch to bicycle or pedestrian. TomTom allows you to get line by line directions or map sequences to preview your trip. Much more customizable than Garmin.
Some of the Garmins can download "Citymaps" of major cities so it can take you on a walking tour and will take in account subways and buses. The download is only $0 per avaiable city.
There's far more to GPS's than anyone here has mentioned and some is just wrong. My TomTom switches between night and day automatically.