Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

electric chainsaw

Posts

electric chainsaw

#1

electric chainsaw

Jean

I was wondering what might be a good brand of electric chainsaw? I'm a wood turner and my husband usually does the chainsaw cutting, but when he can't I'm thinking that I need my own chainsaw----only smaller and lighter then a gas one. Thanks for any help!

Re: electric chainsaw

#2

Re: electric chainsaw

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Jean,

A couple years ago I bought a 14 inch Remington "Limb 'n Trim" electric chain saw. Its small and light, and is somewhat slow. However, I can't manage the heft of a gas powered model, nor could I ever justify one for the limited amount of bowl turning I do. I got it on sale for less than $20 at the local Do It Best hardware store.

George

Re: electric chainsaw

#3

Re: electric chainsaw

Howard Norman

The only electric chainsaw that I have used was a Remington that belongs to my son. For light work it was OK. It certainly would not compete with either my Stihl or my big Husky.

However, as George has stated there comes a time when you can't handle a big gas chainsaw. I think I have come to that point. I don't know what I would buy if I was really in the market for an electric chain saw but I think that I would look at the higher priced models rather than the inexpensive Remingtons and such.

Re: electric chainsaw

#4

Re: electric chainsaw

Stuart Hough

Unless I'm seriously mistaken, after looking at five of the models out on the market, they all are made by only two actual manufacturers, and consequently, there are not a lot of actual differences. I have used the same model that the Colonel spoke of, and agree with his assessment. I don't remember any being rated higher than 9 or 10 amps, so I would believe they all perform about the same. One thing I remember well, is that chain stretch is a bit of a problem. The one I used didn't stop stretching until I had only one or two threads left on the adjustment bolt, but it stretched no farther after that. Good luck!

Re: electric chainsaw

#5

Re: electric chainsaw

Galen Vetterick

I purchased a cheaper Poulan ES400 with an 18" bar and the nameplate says 13 amp ( 4.0 peak horsepower rating that means very little). So far it has done well in cutting the split ends of hardwood logs. You really have to watch splitting a log lengthwise as the ribbons of wood can be drawn in around the sprocket. The gap is wider than my gas chain saw but it can happen with it too.

Health reasons make it easier to use than pulling on the gas unit. Being in a townhome there is less noise from the electric and prevents complaints.

With only a Jet 1220 I'm not talking big logs just no bigger than the bar.

Re: electric chainsaw

#6

Re: electric chainsaw

Barry Irby

Jean this topic comes up here once in a while. I think its fair to say there is something of a consensus. They fall into two groups. The Stihl electric and everything else.

The Stihl is four or five hundred dollars and nearly as good as a gas powered saw, and better than some.

Then there are a bunch of them that are $80 to $100 or whatever and they are not nearly as powerful or good. I have had two or three Remingtons and they cut fairly well but were pretty crappy. I got one of them replaced under the warranty. I gave up and went to Sears and bought a Craftsman (Oh! Horror of horrors, he did not admit that did he? surely not a crapsman.) I paid about $89 for it and $12 for the extended warranty. They said, if it breaks, bring it back and we give you a new one, no questions asked. I used it hard. It would not die. At about three years it finally wore out the plastic drive gear. The warranty had expired before the gear did. I bought new parts and fixed it for a few bucks and it is still going strong. Well, maybe not strong, but going as well as ever. I am sure it was made by Remington for Sears. I can't believe that warranty did not pay off. Let me be clear. Its not a Stihl electric and its not a Stihl or any other Gas powered saw. Its a piece of crap, but for what it is, its a good one and has done better than I expected.

I like it because it is quiet, does not smoke, is lighter than a gas powered saw, cuts reasonably well and has a 16" bar. I do not like the bar oiler. It doesn't have a pump or anything else, it just drools on the chain. If you leave it sitting, the bar oil just drools out. All over the floor. So, I have been running mine for years without any bar oil. Don't see any negative effects. Can't really tell. No A/B comparison. Much of what we cut for turning is dirty, has debris embedded in the wood and certainly in the bark. Oil won't help if you hit a rock.

I would be reluctant to buy anything else from Sears, but I would buy another of these in a minute.

Re: electric chainsaw

#7

Re: electric chainsaw

Matt Overton

I will preface this by saying I am a tool junkie and have a friend that is a Stihl dealer. I own the 560 gas unit. It is big and bad, a great saw. I somehow tried to justify needing a saw for cutting blanks in the shop and bought the bigger Stihl electric saw. all I can say is WOW! This is every bit as powerful as my 560, but much lighter and much more controllable, not to mention quiet. Well worth the very hefty pricetag.

Re: electric chainsaw

#8

Be careful!

Tom Dunlap

I'm an arborist and own gas saws from top handled pruning saws up to a Stihl 088.

There is an electric Craftsman in the shop at home too. I found it at a garage sale years ago and it's built well. Much better than the electrics on the market today...excepting the Stihl or Milwaukee ones.

Because of the high torque of electrics it's important to understand that most cut resistant chainsaw pants/chaps won't stop and electric. They will just chomp on through. I use pants/chaps with spun fibers that look like cotton balls not the hard layers of Kevlar. The reason is that I feel that the spun fibers ball up the chain and clutch. The Kevlar style are tough but the electrics can just chew their way in.

Re: electric chainsaw

#9

Re: electric chainsaw

john lucas

Jean as a turner I've heard a lot of bad things about the cheapy electrics. However when my local junk store got some for $16 I couldn't pass it up. It does work but for only really light stuff. I also feel like I need to put on a Cardigan sweater, bow tie and maybe patent leather shoes when I use that thing. It's nothing like the AAARh AAAARh AAARh you get when you power up the gas chain saws. I feel quite comfortable in levi's and a work short with no sleeves when I'm using those saws.

The cheaper electrics have plastic gears that wear out quickly. The ones I've used have a manual chain oiler and it leaks and gets oil all over everything. I'd certainly look at the more expensive models if you are going to use it much at all.

Re: electric chainsaw

#10

Ellis Walentine

Jean, please send me a note

Ellis Walentine

...an e-mail, so I can correct your address. You've requested email notification but every notice we've sent you on this thread has bounced because of a 554 error with your e-mail address as typed. Please be sure to use a valid address when requesting notification.

Thanks,

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: electric chainsaw

#11

Re: electric chainsaw

Galen Vetterick

John I read a lot of the earlier postings before I got the Poulan. It has a metal sprocket and automatic oiler. My two gas chain saws leak oil but the electric does not! Surprised me!

I guess I need to dress better when I use the electric. Bow tie? I have not owned one since I was a kid! Guess that type would keep out of the way better though. Got to think of shop safety!

Re: electric chainsaw

#12

Re: electric chainsaw

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Husky [Husqvarna] 316E is a 16" electric that will rival most 16" gas saws. Street cost about $270

Very similar is the Jansored 2116E 14" saw for the same price.

Stihl makes two electrics # 180C and #220Q. They are significantly more expensive, and while very good machines, not IMHO that much better than the Husky or than Janny.

Just a side note here, since they are electric, you'll be tempted to use them inside in the shop, even on a piece mounted on your lathe. If you do, be prepared to clean up the oil that gets thrown from the chains [DAMHIKT] :D

Re: electric chainsaw

#13

Re: electric chainsaw

ILYA Z

I bought a 16" Makita model UC4030A (http://makita.com/en-us/Modules/Tool....aspx?ID=25942) two years ago. I think I picked it after someone suggested this brand to me as being more reliable than Craftsman etc while being cheaper than Stihl and similar brands. I like it.

Re: electric chainsaw

#14

Re: electric chainsaw

del schisler

You can get a gas 12" homelite which is light weight. I have been in the timber logging trees a long time ago. I used to have the big guy's I now have the gas 12" homelite now. I live in florida and use it to trim palm tree's. It start's easy and will out cut a electric . Just my 2 cents