Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

18 V Battery "item of interest".

Posts

18 V Battery "item of interest".

#1

JL

18 V Battery "item of interest".

JL

One of the batteries for my 18 V Dewalt just gave up the ghost. No power, doesn't last, etc. The other one's demise is rapidly approaching. So I went to MTO's site to check on the price and print out the form. Then I went shopping for new batteries to make sure that I was getting a reasonable "deal".

18 V battery rebuild - $40 + shipping both ways.

New 18 V batteries (twin pack) - $98 + shipping for the XR+ batteries.

So, for roughly $9 more per battery, I can get the XR+ battery with 3300 mAh (instead of having my batteries rebuilt and getting 2400 mAh).

I obviously missed something happening. The last time I checked, it was $160+ for a pair of batteries. It looks like the prices have been drastically lowered (maybe due to the lithium ion tools?).

So - I ordered the pair of batteries. I figure I can recycle the old batteries.

Re: 18 V Battery "item of interest".

#2

Ditto

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I noticed the same thing when I needed 14v Dewalts. The rebuilders claim they use "better" cells, i.e. more/faster recharges, but I've been unable to independently confirm this. The one EE I spoke with said that he was fairly sure that two batteries with the same mAh rating would be functionally identical. I too bought new batteries and recycled the old ones.

Yes, I could have "upgraded" my old units from NiCad to Nmh cells, but the cost was prohibitive for my use patterns. Instead I went to 18v in Li when I got my Hitachi driver. Now THAT's a piece of work, I'll tell you.

Re: 18 V Battery "item of interest".

#3

Alternative battery sources

Bill Tindall

Shipping becomes a significant expense when rebuilding batteries. Even here in the hinterlands we have two "Batteries Plus" stores so I presume they must be everywhere. While I have not had them rebuild a battery yet, they claim they can/will and the cost estimate was attractive.

Re: 18 V Battery "item of interest".

#4

Battery quality/life discussion

Bill Tindall

I have a friend that works in the research division of a company that makes batteries. The following is what I have learned from discussions with him.

There are at least four kinds of "modern" batteries that might be found in the shop- Nickel Cadmium. metal hydride, lithium, and lithium ion. Everything about these battery types is different including their charging characteristics and discharging characteristics. These batteries, especially the lithium ion battery, are extraordinarily complex devices and there is much opportunity to reduce cost and compromise quality .

The life you can expect from any of these batteries is markedly dependent on the quality of the materials used to fabricate the anode, cathode and separator in the battery, as well as the quality of the charger used to charge them. At best one could expect a decade of service and hundreds if not thousands of charge/discharge cycles.

The problem of course is how does one know what is inside the charger or battery package. One can only hope that cost correlates with battery life. Another friend who is a photographer spent a pile of money on a charger for the rechargable batteries he uses in his light sources and other equipment. This charger has sophisticated electronics that optimally charges the battery in a way that preserves its capacity and life. All the lithium ion batteries, as well as the batteries themselves, have electronics to help preserve the battery life and keep them from exploding from over charging.

Re: 18 V Battery "item of interest".

#5

Re: Battery quality/life discussion

Barry Irby

I went to Batteries Plus. They don't want to open Makita batteries. Only the ones that have screws for access.

They want about $70 for 12 volt replacements they carried. They were not Makita. I didn't buy them.

And, Lithium Ion batteries can be dangerous. I did a home Inspection for a guy that burned his house down by trying to recharge a model airplane battery improperly. The batteries exploded and the contents burned like Napalm. His description, not mine. Lets be careful out there.

Re: 18 V Battery "item of interest".

#6

Re: Battery quality/life discussion

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

LiI battery chargers are all supposed to have a cooling fan running to keep the battery cool(er) during the charge, and even when left for a trickle charge. I know a contractor who thought he a nifty rig to field-charge his LiI batteries from his truck's electrical system.

He doesn't try it with his new truck.

Re: 18 V Battery "item of interest".

#7

Li ion batteries

Bill Tindall, East TN

Charging lithium batteries is a delicate task. Overcharge and they may explode so the charger has circuitry to prevent overcharging. Boggling things are going on during charging so the charging rate must be just so. If they discharge too much they irreversibly die, so the battery has circuitry to turn it off when it becomes optimally discharged. This is why they seem to "die" suddenly in use. There still is a lot of charge left but further discharge would prevent the battery from regaining optimum charge. It's a miracle they work. I would not want a car powered by one, or be in a wreck with a car powered by one.