Best finish for dining table?
Barry Irby
My son and I built a dining table. It's cherry. What would you think is the best finish?
He'll be brushing it.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Best finish for dining table?
Barry Irby
My son and I built a dining table. It's cherry. What would you think is the best finish?
He'll be brushing it.
Varathane waterborne poly floor finish
Clint Searl
It contains aluminum oxide for abrasion resistance.
Clint
Two schools of thought
Jesse Cloud
There are two camps on this issue:
1. Use the hardest finish you can find, durable but probably a little plasticky
2. Use a simple oil/wax finish and do simple touch up when its dull or dented.
Last time I did one I took route 1 and used Behlen's Rockhard Tabletop varnish. The look is great and five years later its still in good shape. Only problem is that is takes two weeks to fully cure. Well, one more problem, then the wife wanted a buffet with the same finish to go with the table, then 6 chairs with the same finish. Would have been a lot easier with route 2 if I knew what was coming. 
Re: Two schools of thought
andrew nistock
Really, how long have you been married? You should have seen that one coming. :-) :-). I do prefer the oil/wax finish on anything I do if the customer agrees.
Re: Two schools of thought
FredD
Well you did good Jesse , one of the best finishe's available , exceptionally long lasting and rated high at resisting moisture transfer.
Of course like most things worth doing , it does take awhile .-))
FredD
Stuff is good for ANYTHING !
steve mackay
Re: Best finish for dining table?
Jesper, Denmark
Ihave had very good results with a semigloss poly. Don't remember brand, but it was 10+ years ago, and the table is in daily use. The substrate is Back Locust (What else?) and the table really started as a work desk/table for me when I started the business. That was in 1995.
It has seen a variety of PC's and a lot of different abuse since. Parties with everything spilt on it, kid banging wooden toys on it jadajadajada.
Re: Best finish for dining table?
George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA
I Agree Jesper.
I've used more poly than anything else, so perhaps I am biased. However, it works and looks great. My 10 kids grew up around our 7 foot long solid maple breakfast room table and so did many of their friends. I refinished it once, and layed semi gloss poly down again. Now its on our back porch, and with the same crowd plus grandkids.
George
Re: Best finish for dining table?
Howard Acheson
For best appearance but still maintaining good protection a non-poly varnish is best. Poly varnish has a sort of cloudy look particularly if more than two coats are applied. A non-poly varnish will be quite a bit more clear and still provide almost as much protection as a poly varnish.
For cherry, a darker varnish like Waterlox Original or Behlen Rockhard is best.
If your brother has not developed good brushing skills, whatever he applies will not look very good. He should practice on some scrap work until he can brush on a smooth brush mark free film. An alternate application method would be to thin the varnish about 50/50 with mineral spirits and then wipe it on.