Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Finish and matching

Posts

Finish and matching

#1

Finish and matching

Gary Smyth



OK, old maple cabinet. Picture shows part two of three levels. After a brisk cleaning, plastic wool, and sanding the colors vary from orange to yellow, cinnamon, honey, and bare wood. One side in bright sun the other in shade.

I'm not adverse to refinishing as worn wood or stain after 100 years of use. (If it fails I'll stain or paint the whole thing).

I'm in the process of layering colors for that to happen. 1st an overall amber/lemon yellow dye, followed by a darker "golden/reddish" color and finally a darker color in a transparent wine shade. All rubbed down with wear parts "bleeding" through to underlying colors. So I want to make the coloring as transparent as possible before any type of topcoat. I've not used them but suggested, will water stains, and/or analine mixed dyes do the job? I plan on wiping the base colors and eventually spraying the top coat. Anything anyone wants to warn me about? I have about thirty days until I have to start heating the place and the outdoors mostly will be lost to me. Between now and then I need to finish reconstructing the top cabinet which is mostly bare wood because earlier damage resulted in beyond my capability repair. This started as a simple project but I've grown to like this "thing". After reconstruction and the time it took I'd like to make this better looking than I originally intended. I'm open to suggestions.

Re: Finish and matching

#2

I'm missing the picture...

doug f, san clemente, ca

Re: Finish and matching

#3

Me also.  I'll resend tomorrow

Gary Smyth

Re: Finish and matching

#4

Pic

Gary Smyth


Re: Finish and matching

#5

Ellis Walentine

Quick take: Sand it

Ellis Walentine

I have the feeling that sanding might even out the color. More importantly, those colors are probably the vestiges of previous finishing materials. Unless you sand them off, your dye regime might not work as expected, or desired.

Ellis

Re: Finish and matching

#6

Agree

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Repaired a kid's bed for a neighbor. It was the grandfather's youth bed, finished in shellac, but both of the side rails had split. Reportedly made of maple, but in order to match the finish I had to remove the old finish. That revealed the bed as having been made of "factory wood." The turned posts were cherry, the headboard was a maple and birch glue-up, and the footboard was part maple and part poplar.

Instead of trying to stain and get an even color, I mixed up a quart of shellac to which I added medium brown and "wine" dye. I then used my small HVLP gun to apply the finish to selectively build the color. I was able to get things close enough that it's hard to tell one wood from the other. When fully dry, I top-coated with oil poly.

They were very pleased.

Consider sanding, even doing a bit of bleaching, then use a single color of dye, and finish with a tinted coating to blend the remaining variations.

Re: Finish and matching

#7

Entirely possible. Better ideas than mine.

Gary Smyth

Sanding is much less expensive than the regimine I thought about and an evening out coat followed by a color finishing coat is faster too. I have the time now to take advice, and if I do it your way, a bit of wiggle room as to time for the back end too.

Re: Finish and matching

#8

Ellis Walentine

I agree with everything Mark said...

Ellis Walentine

... except the part about a tinted finish coat. I am a big proponent of getting the color evened out before you start topcoating. Otherwise, you can end up with some pretty blotchy results, as the more colored finish you apply, the darker it gets in those areas.

Toning is another story, where the toner is very dilute and merely adds some hue variation to an existing color.

Ellis

Re: Finish and matching

#9

I'd strip, not sand

Steve Schoene

Unless you sand a LOT, you can leave old stain and/or old finish in the more porous parts of the wood, makingit difficult for dye or stain to be successful. Stripper pulls old finish out of the wood more effectively and more evenly giving a better surface to apply color.